Issues with Step-daughter

Updated on October 28, 2009
D.S. asks from Clinton, IA
6 answers

Hi! I've posted a couple other things on this website that I have gotten good advice for. I always enjoy seeing how others handle things and getting advice from others in how to handle my situations.

My husband and I have been married for 3 years next month and have a son together that just turned 2. My husband also has a daughter from his previous marriage that I care a lot about. She is 15 and I know the age has a lot to do with things, but I'm asking for suggestions on how to handle things. My step daughter lives 3 hours away from us, so it is not feasible for her to come as often as she would like. We also have limited funds that do not allow for travel as often as we would like. My husband and I have had discussions with her about how we do not like some of the things she says. She is flat out disrespectful towards her father at times and we have talked about that with her. I have told her that I will not tolerate that in our house. She also tries the guilt trip thing saying that her dad does not love her. She knows that is far from the truth. She does text her father (my husband is deaf and does not speak on the phone) very regularly. Her mother and I (and my husband) do have a open relationship in terms of being able to talk with each other about things. I have had some very lengthy discussions with my husband's ex about how I feel about my step daughter and how she treats/talks with her father and how she is towards my family. I know she does not talk us down to her and talk about things with her and we do too, but it's getting old to be constantly reminding her about how she hurts our feelings too. Like I said, I know a lot of it is the age thing, but are there any suggestions out there that we might not have tried? I also know that we should take some of this behavior as saying that she does love her father and her brother, but there are other ways of showing that.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Thanks to those of you who submitted positive responses. My situation is different than the usual step parent situation. I will not go into details with that. I understand that some do not always have a positive experience with step parents, etc and can understand why. I am a person who believes that exes can be friends and can work things out for the benefit of their child. My husband's ex is the one who approached me first about issues and has made me feel that I can talk with her about things. The reason I do that is part of the details I have left out in an effort to make things short. Again, thanks to you who posted a positive response.

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.L.

answers from Minneapolis on

I don't have much experience in this area or much advice, except that I think you are right much of it probably has to do with her age. My oldest son just turned 13 so I am just starting the teenage years. Maybe she's a little jealous of her little brother? With three parents in her life it is probably possible that she is trying to manipulate the three of you to her advantage. I wanted to say that I thought one of the other posters was a little harsh, and I applaud you for working with her mother and having a positive relationship with her. I think that is very mature and could have nothing but a positive effect on your stepdaughter. I have no idea why you would want to assume she is "the enemy," and I think that would only make things worse for your stepdaughter. Blended families can be difficult and it sounds like you are a very busy woman, but maybe you could get some counseling to give you some additional ideas of how to work with your stepdaughter and not let it interfere with your relationship with your husband either. Good luck.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

E.S.

answers from Minneapolis on

My daughter does not like the man I am with now. She blames him the breakup between me and my ex-husband. She has some strong residual anger feelings. Even though she loves me and hugs me, she has a difficult time even having a civil conversation with Chris.

First, we try the ground rules. We write down what are fair rules from all perspectives. We all sign off on it.

Second, I explain calmly and repeatedly what things and behavior are ok, and which are not. For a long time, I let her get away with EVERYTHING because I was so cautious about making things worse.

We still aren't out of the danger zone. I'm going to take her to a family therapist. I'm going to have her do some one on one discussions. Then I'm going to sit in with her. Then we'll move on to family sessions. She can't really be at peace until she deals with the negative emotions that are biting away at her.

These turn into short snappy, waspish statements and completely disrespectful tones when she talks to me.

I do not ever have my ex and my current talk to each other, especially about the children. So, I'd probably ditto J.L. and say stop the conversations with bio mom. It's probably not a good way to go about helping the girl get her feelings under control.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.L.

answers from Minneapolis on

.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

E.F.

answers from Omaha on

1 - She's 15...enough said.

2 - Have you been a child of divorce? A child of a step-parent? Cut her some slack. It SUCKS!!! It's hard, it's confusing, it's sad. It's like there was a death in the family when your parents get divorced. Life is OVER as you know it and it will affect you for your ENTIRE life. Then they go and marry someone else and expect you to just accept it. I don't know what's wrong with parents that they think they can turn their children's worlds upside down and expect them to go with it, act normal, etc.

Of course she's going to feel like her dad doesn't love her...he's got a new wife and new kid and she's a teenager w/crazy hormones.

It's not her problem that you don't have money to travel to see her...figure out a way for your husband to visit her more...one on one w/o you and the baby would be cheaper and possibly more meaningful to her. Maybe you guys need to give up a few things to make it work. 3 hours is NOT far...you should be seeing her at least 1x/montj! Seriously how much does it cost to drive 6 hours for a visit OR can't your ex meet you 1/2 way so that you can only have to drive 3 hours total and bring her to your house for a weekend visit once a month????

If that doesn't work...can you move closer to her?

I don't know what to say ...it all seems normal for a 15 year old to me...and while she shouldn't be disrespectful I think it's typical for teenagers, especially one put in this situation that her parents created by moving so far apart.

Good luck.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.N.

answers from Lincoln on

I'm sorry I don't know how to help you in your issues with your step-daughter. But I read the responses you got and felt compelled to respond.

My husband and step-son's mother have an amicable relationship. She made it very clear from the beginning that she knew very well that my presence in her son's life would have an impact whether I did anything about it or not. (Whether I liked it or not. Whether she liked it or not.) She chose to acknowledge that and I became involved in his life early on. My stepson has gone through some rough patches in his young life, and all 3 of us have been very frank and open about what we saw, how we saw it, how we thought we should proceed. We have attended therapy together, as a family. We have agreed and disagreed...

You should not feel like she's the enemy. If she is, then she is. But if she isn't, please don't walk away from this post feeling like you should. Are there people out there that use their children against their exes? Sure. Is everyone like that? No, absolutely not!!

There are people that actually talk to their friends about their feelings of frustration against an ex, instead of their children. There are people who make it very clear that just because the parents aren't together, it doesn't mean they aren't parents anymore. People who chose to stand up for their child's best interest instead of their own foolish pride (just don't let go of your dignity).

Such people listen when they are told their children misbehave because they want to know how to correct that... because they don't want their offspring to become anti-social. "It takes a village"!

At least, that's what my experience has been. If you feel like perhaps you should watch out, then go ahead. But please don't believe that everyone out there is bitter about their ex and their new spouse.

Good luck!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.L.

answers from Minneapolis on

It usually doesn't work too well to look to an adolescent to make you feel good. Do everything you can to keep yourself loving and happy, and she will learn from your example--although it may take a while. If you can take care of your own feelings, at least you will be feeling good while you wait for her to change.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions

Related Searches