How to Deal with "Unhygienic" Babysitter?

Updated on February 28, 2010
L.S. asks from Wheaton, IL
22 answers

This is an awkward thing to ask, particularly if my sitter's mom is on this website, which I hope is not the case ...

I sometimes hire a girl (who I'll call "Ann") to come over on Saturdays as a "mother's helper" while I am home and busy getting things done. She plays with my 3 kids (ages 2, 5 and 6.5), but I do all the "heavy lifting," such as diaper changes and meals. She is 12 and has never babysat for anyone before and has no younger siblings, cousins, etc., so she is not experienced, but that also makes her affordable compared to what I would have to pay an older, more experienced girl who could handle every aspect of babysitting - which would be cost-prohibitive for me. She is a shy, sweet girl, and my kids like her.

Lately, Ann has been coming over directly from playing basketball on a team every Saturday morning. She doesn't go home to take a shower and is unwilling to do so at our apartment, so she arrives "fresh off the court." Without going into the "TMI" range, suffice it to say that, particularly in our small apartment (we're living here temporarily due to a fire at our house), the odor is extremely unpleasant, and I find the whole situation very unsanitary since she is in bodily contact with my kids, their toys, the furniture, etc. It doesn't appear that her hands have even been washed. Ann's dad, who lives about 15 mins. away, drops her off after her game, which is very near us, so it would be inconvenient for him to have to go back to his house with her for her to shower and then drive her back. I do not want to have to pick her up from his house since that would take time and gas, plus I would have to take my kids with me (my husband sometimes is here, but not always, and even if he is, he wouldn't be willing to be in charge of them - that's an issue for another post though). Ann's mom lives very near me, but she is at work on Saturdays, which is when Ann and her older siblings visit with their dad.

Ann is actually here now as I am typing this to get other moms' advice, which I am motivated to do because the situation is so bad today. I don't want to hurt her feelings in any way (especially at her very vulnerable and insecure age of 12), and I don't know either of her parents well enough to feel like I could say anything to either of them about the situation. The first week that this situation happened, I didn't yet realize that Ann hadn't showered after her basketball game, and I innocently asked her when she arrived (in gym shorts, duh - but I didn't notice that right away, and she had a winter jacket on over her gym shirt) if she had already had time to go back to her dad's house and shower, since she had arrived so quickly after her game was due to be over. I was disappointed that she chose to lie, since she looked right at me and answered, "Yes." Ann's mom later confirmed that Ann had not gone to her dad's house to shower and offered, by way of explanation for Ann's lie, that Ann was afraid I would make her shower at my apartment, which she said that Ann is not willing to do since Ann "would feel self-conscious."

Short of deciding to stop having Ann come over (which will then undoubtedly cause Ann's mom to ask me why I never hire her daughter anymore - and then what do I say?), what can I do about this? I'd like not to lose her help with my kids on Saturdays, but I also can't have her back anymore under these conditions.

UPDATE (based on the responses so far):

(1) I have already talked to the mom twice about this in a roundabout way since I didn't want to offend the mom. The mom is a smart woman, so I believe she understands from our 2 conversations that I would like Ann to shower before coming over, but I think the mom also doesn't consider it to be a big deal, plus there is nothing she can do about it - she is at work, and it is not an option for Ann's dad to go to her house. The first conversation with the mom was to ask if Ann's dad had driven her back to his house to shower since I couldn't see how all that could have been done given the time I thought the mom said the game would be over. (I did it under the guise of inquiring what time the game was, but in all honesty, I was curious to know whether Ann really had lied to me, as all indications seemed to be - but I was very much hoping that she hadn't lied, since I am trusting her to watch my children, so I was hoping for some innocent explanation.) That was when the mom explained Ann's lie, as I wrote above. The second conversation was yesterday when confirming with the mom that Ann would be coming over after her game (literally right after, I guess). I asked the mom if Ann will have showered before coming over, and her mom said "no," so I again offered that Ann could shower at my apartment, and the mom again said that Ann isn't willing to do that.

(2) I don't know the dad at all.

(3) My sense of smell tells me that, unfortunately, Ann doesn't wear deodorant.

(4) I come into this situation with my own "baggage" that is maybe making me a little paranoid about saying/doing anything short of not hiring Ann anymore. I became a stepmother to my husband's daughter when she was 12. She had terrible hygiene, including rarely bathing, and neither her father or mother apparently seemed to notice or care to do anything about it since their lives were so dysfunctional with her and each other that it was the least of their issues, as far as I have ever been able to figure out. She and her dad moved in with me after we got married since he had custody of her. Long story short, with the help of a marriage counselor, since we immediately began having problems about her, my husband agreed to tell his daughter that she had to bathe every day. Of course, he didn't shield her from knowing that it was her evil new stepmother who thought she should be bathing every day, so that, among other reasons, caused her to hate me from Day 1. To this day, he repeatedly tells me that I "damaged" her by "making her feel badly about herself" by being critical of her hygiene as a pre-teen girl. (She is now a man, since she later opted to surgically become one.) I'm sorry if that is also "TMI," but perhaps you can now all understand why I am so at a loss about what to do in this situation. My husband, of course, is the last person on earth I could talk to about Ann since (1) he claims not to notice there's a problem (I know he is not being honest), and (2) he will use it as a platform to again blame me for supposedly damaging his child at this same age.

(5) For the reasons that L. O. below pointed out, I am actually less bothered by the "germs" than by the smell, which permeates our apartment and doesn't go away for about a day after Ann leaves. As for the "germs" though, her hands are visibly dirty from handling basketballs in warmups and in the game. (I used to play competitive basketball and sometimes still play for fun - my hands were always very visibly dirty after practices and games, and I see that Ann's hands look the same when she comes over.)

(6) You've all given me great advice, thank you. I'm leaning toward doing something along the lines of what Anette H. and others have written below - i.e., just telling Ann that she needs to shower before coming over, or she can shower at our apartment ... but if it were your 12-year-old daughter, WOULD YOU PREFER THAT I TALK TO YOU INSTEAD AND LET YOU HANDLE IT WITH YOUR DAUGHTER HOWEVER YOU SEE FIT (INCLUDING POSSIBLY TELLING ME THAT SHE WON'T BE BABYSITTING FOR ME ANYMORE, LOL), OR SHOULD I TALK TO ANN DIRECTLY? Selfishly, I don't like the option of losing Ann's babysitting services, since I'm not going to find anyone else as affordable, and my kids have gotten to know and like her, so that's why I'm asking you all for advice. At the same time though, I do have a heart and don't want to bring about the outcome I want (i.e., a cleaned-up babysitter) by hurting Ann's feelings irreversibly (I know they will be somewhat hurt no matter how I handle this) or by alienating her mom - I do consider her mom to be a friend; we're just not close.

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.S.

answers from New London on

Go to the drug store and buy those "bathing cloths." They are usually used for older people that can't shower everyday, but they are like large wipes. Just say to her "I noticed you don't have time to shower after practice so I got you some cleaning cloths you can use instead. Also, please make sure you wash your hands and change into a fresh clean set of clothes when you get here. thank you." You can even throw in some antiperspirant in the bag and maybe she will take the hint.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.P.

answers from Chicago on

I havent read any of the responses, but I just wanted to respond from maybe "Ann's" perspective (or her parents). I personally would not want my daughter showering at your house. Especially because you have stated you dont know her parents very well, maybe they feel the same way about you, and your husband. I wouldnt want my 12 yr old girl showering at someones house that I dont really know. I think that is unfair (and a bit strange) to ask of her.

From reading your post it really sounds like you just want it your way or no way, and you havent really left many options for yourself. But the reality is, you cant force her to shower at your house, and you cant force her dad to drive her to his house and back to yours, so either you need to ask her to wash her hands and deal with the rest, or you need to let her go.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

N.D.

answers from Chicago on

Yuck! My suggestion is to politely ask "Ann" to shower before she comes over. You could either leave it at that or you could tell her that your kids have commented a couple of times that they want to give her more hugs/ kisses but that they don't want to get too close. That while they love her dearly, she still smells sweaty from basketball.

Alternatively, you could talk to Ann's mom about it and let her know that your apartment is small and while you understand that it may be inconvenient for the Dad, could Ann shower before coming over and/or would it be okay if she showered at your place? IF it were me personally, I would approach it by simply asking Ann's Mom if it would be okay for Ann to shower at your place after her basketball. That she seemed hesistant and so you thought you would ask her Mom if it would be okay.

Give the family (Ann and her parents) to make it right before not using her anymore. Worst case scenario is that the outcome will be the same. Ann won't be babysitting anymore. Best case, your house smells better when Ann is over.

Good luck. That sucks.
N

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.P.

answers from Pittsburgh on

I don't think there's any more you can do without acting like a jerk. I would bet the mom already knows the deal from your conversations....I'd just try to fond someone else. At the very least, I'd ask her to wash her hands when she gets there...if you keep her, at least you know what to get her for her birthday! J/K LOL

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.M.

answers from Portland on

Since your sitter has little experience, you have the option of helping her succeed in her future employment by being clear about your needs and expectations as her employer. It's a delicate situation to address someone else's hygiene, but you could keep it somewhat neutral with statements like the following:

"I like the service you provide (be as specific as possible about what you appreciate)."

"AND, I have a problem with dirty hands and sweaty gym clothes in my small home. I'd like to keep hiring you, but I will need you to bring a change of clothes and a plastic bag for your game clothes. And I expect you to wash your hands thoroughly as soon as you get here; clean hands is a rule for my children, too."

There could be plenty of implied insult in language that minces around and drops hints. There is no implied insult in clear, straightforward, factual language. You are letting her know in an objective way what you expect from her, and as her employer, you have the right to do so, within reason. She won't pick it up through osmosis.

Maybe a change into fresh clothes will limit the amount of locker-room fragrance to a level you can deal with, considering the money you save with her. I would worry about germs on her hands, but as mentioned below, the bacteria in her sweat is not likely to carry disease.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

M.A.

answers from Orlando on

Could you say something like: "Sweetie, my Mom used to tell me the same thing that I am about to tell you" "You need to shower & clean up after playing basketball" "There is no way that anyone can sweat as much as you do playing basketball & smell good when you are done". "I am not singling you out, but I now know what my Mom meant when she told me that." "Now you have a choice, you can shower at the gym before you leave, at your Dad's before you come, or when you get here, but you need to choose one of those 3 places".

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.W.

answers from San Francisco on

I'd just say, "hey honey, would you mind washing your hands?" I ask most of my kids' friends to wash their hands when they come over, since they've just been at a 2000 kid germy high school all day. And if she's going to come over right after basketball, just say, "hey, could you bring a clean shirt to put on after your basketball game, you're kind of sweaty." And if the b.o. was really bad, I'd say, "hey honey, I think it's time for some deodorant." Or some such thing. It's normal to stink after you work out. Nothing personal.

I don't think you need to worry about damaging her. This is just fact and common sense. We all are dirty and sweaty after basketball games. I'd have no problem asking a 12 year old to clean up.

There's no need to have her stop babysitting.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.B.

answers from Boise on

Unfortunately a LOT of people don't get hints. You are going to have to be direct and gentle.

If you are not willing to do that, you can change the day she comes over to Sundays, when she doesnt have a game. Or, move the time she comes over two hours later- so that she has time to do her thing. If she still somes over unkept, it is time for a talk with someone.

For example, if the mother says "she is unwilling to shower at your house, she is too shy" , then you say- "ok- I will move the starting time forward an hour or two so that she has time for this necessity".

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.P.

answers from Chicago on

Instead of Saturday, maybe you can ask Ann to come over on a day where she isn't playing basketball and she has time to bathe beforehand?

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.H.

answers from Washington DC on

Ok here is my take and it might be a little tough.....I would tell her either shower or you are out of a job. Period. Ball is in her court...no pun intended.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.C.

answers from Los Angeles on

not sure how to approach this myself. but i would definitely not say anything to Ann because it is highly likely that she will be emotionally affected.

When I was in Junior high, 7th grade (actually summers school before 7th grade), there was a girl in our class that had really bad B.O. And everyone was gossiping about her and just complaining about how bad she stunk. It went on for about a month...until I decided to step in..

I felt really bad for her and didn't like that she was being made fun off when she probably didn't know she smelled. So I pulled her aside and told her privately what was going on and was trying to be very delicate and helpful as possible. Well, I never saw her again. She probably quit summer school and transferred to another school. Yikes. I hope at least that saved her from any future embarrassment at a new school.

But as you can see..that kind of honesty, no matter how well intended can damage a kid. It should only be discussed by HER parents. Not any stranger.

If i have to let Ann go...I would. Just make something up. Or change your schedule as someone has suggested. Rather than tell her she needs to bathe.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.T.

answers from Denver on

It's not that big of a deal to ask her mom or dad to pack a change of clothes for her after her game so that she can shower when she gets to your house because she's sweaty after her games.

You can also use it as a learning opportunity for "Ann" as well. You dont have to tell her "OMG YOU STINK!" We already have started training our 7yr old to shower after his basketball games even though he really isnt that stinky. I'm sure Ann would appreciate some "older woman" advice from you. Don't bring up the past, just explain that when kids get to be about 11 or 12, they start to need to shower after PE and games because they start to get body odor when they sweat. It's just what we all have to do when we grow up - I'm certain she notices that every professional athelete showers after a game.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.F.

answers from Boston on

Well.........all I can say is that sweaty kids who don't wear deodorant at age 12 smells awful!! And sweat can have bacteria in it. Its coming off your body and on to your furniture. If it was my house getting all stinky, I would kindly not have her back.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

D.S.

answers from New York on

I think the answer is simple, find a new mothers helper.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.A.

answers from Columbia on

If I would in your shoes...To get her to wash her hands...the minute she waks in the door just be like "Hey, Ann, can you wash your hands I need help preparing a snack for the kids." Something like that.... Also..Go to the Dollar store and make her like a gif basket with deoderant, body spray, lotion, nail polish, hand sanitizer, just put lil stuff like that in it and give it to her as a you are doing a good job present and maybe she will take a hint.... Or sometimes I spray my perfume around the house.. You could accidently spray her...ooops.. lol :) just kidding...Hope this helps

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.S.

answers from Chicago on

L., I work in middle school and this is a big problem. They are still young.Forgetful, and you know embarrassed. CALL the COACH and GYM teachers at the school and ask them if they could give the kids a talk, in the meantime, buy a cheap deodorant and some baby wipes and tell her the truth. Straight out, not attacking like ewwwe you smell, but say my apartment has no ventilation or something like that and in addition to my bathroom adding smells, I have to take extra care of my own hygiene. And adopt her as your friend, big sister confidante, whatever. Or wave the deodorant about and say oh need some? Good luck.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.K.

answers from Sacramento on

What a tough one! Ann is probably uncomfortable with the way she smells also and would like a resolution as much as you would. I would talk to whomever you have the best relationship with to find a solution. If you pose it delicately to Ann or her mother, I am sure that they would understand. Is there an option for Ann's dad to take her to the Mom's house near to you for a quick shower?

At 12 she might be needing support around this herself. Her body is changing and sometimes parents aren't on top of these issues as much as they should be. Does she wear deodorant yet? I would think of ways to frame it to support her and get the results you need that way to try to spare feelings...

Good luck!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.A.

answers from Chicago on

I think the only thing you can really do is just not have her back anymore. Get the kids signed up for some sort of activity on Saturdays or maybe try and find a mom who you can swap childcare with every other Saturday and give each other a break. Then it won't cost you a thing including hurting the girl's feelings.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.S.

answers from Minneapolis on

First, a kid this age should be taking daily showers and not just "rinsing off". I would bet that she is not bathing daily and if she is she just isn't doing a good job. Because to be honest, she should not be so punk after a basketball game even without a shower afterward. Also, I would wonder if her workout clothes/uniform are being washed after every game.

So what to do? All kids go thru the stinky phase as one poster pointed out. I myself have a niece in this situation that we have directly requested that she shower, shower better, and wear deodorant. Hasn't really helped.

I gave my niece a gift basket at christmas that included girly things like perfume and lotion and bubble bath but snuck it teenage-cool deodorant, baby powder and deodorant shower gel.

Edit: After reading your update I just wanted to say (tho I am sure you know this), educating your step daughter about hygiene did not damage her and/or cause her to alter herself surgically. Doing something so drastic could never be traced back to something so insignificant as requesting daily showers. If the babysitter is just too stinky and the parents are unwilling to address it and if requesting that she de-stink herself upon reaching your house aren't working, you will have to stop calling on her.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

R.W.

answers from San Francisco on

Aside from smell, sweat can be damaging to furniture (moisture and salt) so you could approach it that way.
You could tell her that she can keep a change of clothes and her own towel at your house if she would feel more comfortable that way.
Honestly, sometimes at that age kids just don't realize that they smell (ask any 6th or 7th grade teacher!) and it might be better to hear it from an adult than from a peer at school.
Have you tried talking to her parents? Maybe they might have some idea of how to handle this---they know her best.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.B.

answers from Tulsa on

You could just not need her for a couple of weekends because you have things to do that fall within the time the games are. Have your kids noticed the smell? Kids can be brutely honest. They could simply ask her why she smells bad. I had kids in child care ask me why I was fat, it was simple, way back when, that I was going to have a baby soon. I don't have an excuse now.

In the past when I have had preteens in my house I have simply handed them some deoderant and told them to go put it on. Not harshly but whispered in a kind way.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.O.

answers from Detroit on

she may be stinky from sweating.. but that doesnt equal germy.

so she is not getting your kids or theri toys dirty or germy.

It might be reasonable to have her wash her hands if you think that would make you feel better. but your kids are older and out there in the germy school world every day anyway an dpicking up germs from all the other kids.

either ignore it or hire a new babysitter.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions