Kids will argue if there is an argument to be had...you are the adult so there should be no argument with a 6 year old. She may be "bratty", she may not be completely respectful of you but her parents should address this and if they are not, then maybe you, as the aunt can be firm and let her know that she is being unreasonable and you will not accept this tone, behavior etc from her as her aunt. I am also unsure as to the living situation but sometimes kids get irritated (just like adults) when their "space" is invaded. I am not saying this is what is happening I am simply saying that she may be acting out because she sees you as another sibling since it is her parents home and you are living (as she sees it) as another dependent. Once again, I am not saying you are....children are not always aware of the adult world of paying room rent etc., NOR should they be. However, maybe a little bit of concern for the relationship expressed to your sister in law will help your relationship with your niece improve.