Bossy 5 Year Old!! Help?

Updated on August 09, 2011
D.W. asks from Lancaster, NY
6 answers

My daughter is 5, an only child and starting kindergarten in 3 weeks. For the most part she is a VERY sweet girl BUT she is very independent and vocal about having things her own way. Example, she wants to pick out her clothes, or her plate, cup, spoon, fork, if you pick it out for her she will say no and go to the drawer and get her own choice. She gets mad if you put on a song or movie she doesn't like. This morning we got in a fight about the hair tie I picked out for her hair ( and the fact that I put her hair up today) and she was saying I put the wrong sock on the wrong foot first and cried and screamed. She will get mad if you draw on her picture or put a sticker or anything on it. She is a MAJOR over-reactor and needless to say my husband and I are not giving in to every protest so she spends a lot of time in time out when she acts this way. She has gotten soap in the mouth and that is my threat to get her to be nicer or we have a toy of the day that sits on the counter and if she is not nice we threaten to give it away but still we have these episodes. her teachers tell me she is the friendliest girl in pre-k and for the most part she is not this way when playing with friiends at home. but I am tired of yelling...please tell me this is normal behavior/phase or should I check her ( and myself) in to the crazy barn??? thank you!!!

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Thank you everyone! I do let her pick out her clothes and for the most part she is a big factor in decision making throughout her day I guess demanding is the word and quick to freak out. Last night I told her a story about a little girl "Maggie" who was bossy and not nice to her parents and how sad it made them and told her how if you ask nicely for things you are less likely to get in trouble. And she told me a story about a nice girl named Angelina who ised her manners and was good and nice. She said she would rather be an Angelina then a Maggie. So Maggie is now our code word for your misbehaving. This morning she picked out her dress and I was combing her hair and she said MOM! I WANT ! and she stopped herself and said Mom, may I wear my hair down today? I said isn't that nicer? Then she said Mom, may I please have pancakes and Mom, may I please hold the Ipod in the car? So baby steps! I'm sure this is not the end of this rocky road but we made progress for today. Thank you all for all of your wonderful advice! You are all very helpful!

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.F.

answers from Reno on

My son's preschool had a great policy. It asked all parents to let their kids do as much for themselves as possible. They didn't care if clothes didn't match, socks were inside out, shoes were on the wrong feet, whether hair accessories matched the rest of the outfit, etc., etc. They just wanted the kids to have a chance to make decisions for themselves. As long as the kids were clean underneath, hair and teeth were brushed, the rest of it was not important. The kids looked a total disaster: mismatched tops, shorts, colors, designs, hairstyles, bed head was everywhere! LOL...you should've seen the look on my mom's face when we picked my son up one day! There was no way she could handle that much "bad" fashion decision-making! But, it wasn't about what the parents were comfortable with; it was all about the kids learning to make their own choices.

That said, I would humbly ask you...are these the fights worth fighting? Is it such a problem that she choose her own clothes, plate, cup, spoon, fork, hairstyle & accessories? Really ask yourself what's more important: your daughter's budding ability to make choices OR that everything matches? Another humble question...does it bother *you* so much if she's mismatched? The answer may provide some illuminating, and possibly uncomfortable, answers.

Here's what I see...if you let your daughter make as many choices as she can, when YOU decide to make a choice--what the family will watch, what sock to put on first, etc.--and she screams at you, you can simply look up and say, very calmly, "Sweetie, you got to choose [fill in three things here] today. Now, it's my turn to choose [fill in what you're doing here]. You may either accept my choice or you may sit in your room. Which do you want to do?" Now, the burden of choice is on her. If she stays and continues to complain, calmly walk her to her room and let her sit there.

She may spend a lot of time in her room, but you'll be much happier with less fights. Capitalize on your daughter's decision-making capabilities and use it to your advantage! <wink>

Good luck, mama! Budding CEO's can be tough to deal with!

4 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.C.

answers from Boston on

Hi,
I have an only female the same age and I think you are doing a fine job with her. This all sounds very normal to me that she wants to make her own choices. For me personally, I choose my battles, as they say, and let her pick out her clothes, hair ties and shoes and compromise when I see fit and say to her "I can be flexible on that". But when it comes down to bed time, meals, snacks, treats, talking nicely, using nice manners, etc. then we do not compromise. I think it is a control issue and I know you will feel better if you could losen up the reigns just a little bit, give her some choices or let her pick these things that are not that important and I think things will flow better for you. Hope this helps. One other thing, you may try to take a day to just relax and not have anything scheduled where she and you can just take a breather - I know who has time for that , right? Iit may help.

K.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.J.

answers from Dallas on

Not to start something, but I recently read an article that these "bossy" behaviors can be a sign of being educationally gifted. The fact they sort and have processes, etc and are clear on their wants/needs and direct others,e tc. They also think they are little adults. Definately get her tested by the GT department at the school - sometimes they won't do it until the end of Kindergarten, but sounds like she fits the bill.
On a personal/parenting note, my recommendation is keep her grounded at home through the discipline for her reactions. You could also try to stave off some of the issues by asking her input on things. "Hey sue, why don't you set the table tonight." Or" Hey honey, go pick out your shoes and socks." and then let her put them on herself:) As she gets older she will need more independence and these little decisions and opportunities to "lead" might help you all in the long run.
good luck!

1 mom found this helpful

T.K.

answers from Dallas on

I knew it was going to be a girl before I even opened your question. I have a bossy 4 yr old girl. I've asked this question and I've seen it asked on here, several times. That leads me to believe this is very common. I think it's a stage many little girls go through. I can tell that mine is coming out the other side of it, to a degree. It is getting better. I let her know the bevavior isn't going to get her the outcome she was hoping for. It seems to be working. Or maybe she's just growing out of it. Take heart. It's not just your little girl.

B.F.

answers from Toledo on

Are you looking in my windows??? Sounds like my 6 yr old to a T...perfect at school, and at the sitters, at home everything has to be on HER terms and HER way...I try to let her do as much as possible that I know she can do and as long as she isnt dressing for school (they have uniforms) she can wear whatever she wants...stripes with plaid, mix matched whatever...as long as it is clean or it isnt picture time, I try to be flexible. If she gives me a hard time about putting her hair up, but really wants it down, then she can take it out and recomb it.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.S.

answers from Houston on

You sound very hands on. Maybe its time for hands off! Instead of focusing on her bossiness, focus on teaching her responsibility for her actions.

She's going to need it in order to learn to respect other authority figures in her life and upcoming academic career.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions