I find it so hard to find after shave/balm unless I go to a dept store. You can only get Gillette or Nivea etc at Walmart/Target. I've never tried Arbonne.
My husband likes the Nivea and how it feels but isn't crazy about the scent.
He likes the Calvin Klein Obsession and Eternity. Burberry London and there is another one - I don't remember if there is a name of the scent but it is by Usher.