Photo by: Hickory Hardscrabble

Stay-At-Home-Mom vs. Work-Away from-Home-Mom...

Photo by: Hickory Hardscrabble

When I signed the registration form for being a parent I had no idea what I was getting into. The only disclaimer I’d read in the past 48 hours included something about 99.9% effective and blah, blah, blah. Oh, I knew it would be hard, I’d seen things, I’d heard things, heck I’d even been a kid myself. I knew that when I chose to bring a child into this world my life would change, and that I would permanently be responsible for someone else. I also knew that I’d face people with opinions on everything.

There were people who made sure I knew that a drug free delivery was the only way to go, while others were strongly suggesting I “say YES to drugs”, there were the pro breastfeeding gals, who breastfed their children until they were 30 and figured that was the way everyone should go, and then there were my formula friends, who supported the fact that my boobs and milk just didn’t happen. There was Camp Spanks a Lot, and the Time Out bungalows. The saga has gone on and on as the time as turned. With each stage and development, come a whole new batch of people with a whole new bunch of opinions.

For the most part I was ready for that kind of stuff. I am pretty opinionated myself and so from time to time I’ve shared my views on things with the people around me (although I always include the disclaimer that states clearly, “This is the opinion of the author, please feel free to take, use or discard any and all information spewing forth”). I’ve taken the good with the bad, I’ve let a lot of it go and taken some pretty rockin’ advice to heart. The thing is, there was one debate I was completely and utterly ignorant to. The Stay at Home Mom (SAHM) vs. the Work Away from Home Mom (I don’t know the abbreviation here so let’s call her WAHM).

There are people who say that the only “good parent” is a SAHM (this is not me talking, NOT ME, but others), there are those who are very WAHM, keeps you young, in touch with things you know. There are arguments that it’s harder to be a SAHM than a WAHM. There are accusations of laziness on the part of the SAHM and selfishness on the part of the WAHM. Are you SAHM’d and WAHM’d out yet? Because I sure as heck am!

To most of it I say, whatever and a great big “Pffft” (punctuated with Daffy Duck like spit spray). But the thing is, sometimes it stings. A cousin of mine faced this just recently and brought forth yet again, the fire of emotions that I have on the subject. A comment made to her about Stay at Home Moms, of which she is and a pretty stinkin’ good one at that, is that SAHMs are not as smart as the working Mom. That’s right, SAHMs are S-M-R-T smart. Because the suit they put on in the morning is of the sweat variety not the double-breasted, or pack a diaper bag instead of a briefcase, their intelligence level is far below that of the average working stiff.

Well, that’s just plain brew-ha-ha! Garbage in the first degree. It’s a comment that, when made to someone I love and respect, offended even me, miles away.

I’m a working, stay at home mom. Sound a little contradictory, let me explain. I work 3 days a week in a business office, that happens to be in my parent’s home. It’s a fully functioning business, 24 years in business (WHOOT Mom and Dad!), and I do actual, brain activating work there. I also, have my two girls in tow. They play, “help” and distract us daily, but they are always there. In fact they hold the title of mini office assistants (MOAs, my girls are at 3 and 1, don’t you know) So, while I work I am still parenting my daughters.

I live in both camps, Tuesday – Thursday we’re working girls, of the classy division, Bethany, Audrey and I. Friday – Monday we’re Stay at Home, or shop till we drop ladies, still maintaining our class – unless one of us breaks down sobbing in the middle of IKEA because we can’t have that ridiculously ugly mirror with magnets, then the class disappears for everyone involved.

What I know, is that no matter what I do, being at home, going to work, this gig, being a Momma is hard. It’s rewarding, fulfilling, and wicked awesome, but most days it’s hard. Whether you work at home, work out of the home or stay home, on a minute by minute basis, you are faced with challenges that no schooling could have prepared you for. Haven’t you ever wondered why universities don’t offer degrees in Parenting? Why Parenting 101 isn’t the top of their curriculum? I mean they’d make a killing offering those classes, even if they only charged $25 a person.

It’s because there’s no formula to this being a Mom business. There’s no Holy Grail of Motherhood, a book that has the answer to every question, every problem for every child. Each kid is different, even when spawned from the same 2 parents. Just ask the Duggars, I betcha all 19 of their kids are different and have presented them with different joys and challenges over the past 20 something years. We have our first child, and think we’ve got it all figured and what we don’t know, we’re sure a quick phone call to Mom will fix, I mean, she’s our Mom, she’ll have the answer. And sometimes she does, but most often she doesn’t. She has advice, knowledge and life experience that leads you on the path to making your own decision as a parent.

Being a good parent isn’t contingent on whether or not you are a SAHM, a WAHM or CAHM (crazy at home Mom). It’s not measured on degrees or merits, nobody grades your laundry levels, measures the slime forming in your toilet or documents the fact that in a pinch you wipe your kid’s nose with the back of your hand and wipe in on your pants without even thinking (Oh, come on. Like you haven’t done it!)

It’s not the childless people with too much to say, the old ladies who’ve lost all sense of verbal control or the other competitive Moms who’s opinions matter. And even though you live with your husband/partner, and they had a small part in getting those kidlets here (when you weigh out the pregnancy and delivery part, the putting of the bun in the oven is the smallest part, sorry babe), it’s not even their opinion that matters.

The only ones who matter are the recipients of your parenting. The little buddies who receive all the love and hugs, lectures and scolding, time outs and date nights out. The ones who inspire those moments that you thinking, “Yes! I’ve got this. Maybe I am a good Mom!” and who are also the cause for those many, many times during the day you think, “What am I doing?! I didn’t sign up for THIS, get me outta here!” (Not that you want out of being a parent but out of the moment, absolutely)

They are also the ones who give you hugs that actually make you feel like your insides are warm, who make you laugh until milk comes out of your nose and who’s daily development leaves you astounded. They’re the ones who matter and if they are happy, healthy and content, then you’re doing your job, and your pay check, the one with your kids’ happy faces all over it, is well deserved.

So, whether you’re fortunate enough to be a SAHM or if being WAHM is what your life entails (and if that’s your choice there’s nothing wrong with it either! I just say fortunate because I’d love to not have to work), or if you’re like me and while you can’t not work, God and your parents have laid out the best of both worlds for you, if you’re having a good day or a bad. Take a moment, look at your kids (or a picture of them when they weren’t driving you to edge of insanity) and know you’re a good Mom! No, I take it back, you’re a GREAT Mom! You’re making life work for you and your family, you’re floundering sometimes and flourishing others, you love your kids and they love you.

In their eyes you’re a hero, a warrior, a doctor and a genius (unless they are teenagers and then no matter what you do you’re they’re still "smarter"). And to them you’re the best you can be, and that, my Mommy friends is all, that matters.

Ashley Stone, is a SAHM, WAHM and a blogger on the side. She has 2 beautiful little girls who fill her life with love, joy and exhaustion!

Like This Article

Like Mamapedia

Learn From Moms Like You

Get answers, tips, deals, and amazing advice from other Moms.

124 Comments

Thank you for this article. I have been a SAHM for 4 years to two boys, aged 4 and 18mos. I have recently accepted a part time job, only 2 days a week, outside of the home. Our regular babysitter is going to be our part time nanny so the boys can continue their normal routines at home. I have received a lot of input from both my SAHM friends and my WAHM friends. Either way, I think working away from home 2 days a week will be good for all of us. And, I can still be a SAHM 5 days a week.

I have done it all - full-time job, part-time job, and full-time stay at home mom over the past 6 years- and each has a different sets of pros cons. Any way you slice it, there are sacrifices. It's time we learn to make the right decision for ourselves and at the same time support others in making their own 'right' decision, even if it's different than what we've chosen.

Every family is different. Because we are all such creative beings, the ways to raise successful kids is myriad. We are made in the image of God, and as such can be creative, as He is in many different ways.

I also believe each child is in the right family for their personality and temperament. There are no mistakes. As such, when someone gives ME advice, I look at is as if I were in the supermarket - I can listen to different peoples' advice, but have the choice to take it or not take...

See entire comment

Thanks for a great article - it has been terrific to read the comments. I too have been a SAHM, a SAHM / WAHM, and a full time WAHM (at first with dual working parents and now with a SAHD). My kids are 13, 17 and 18 (wow!). I agree with the comment that what I would really love to see is more support of any choice (like I am seeing here)...

See entire comment

Why is this even a debate? There is room in the world for everyone. Make the choice that's best for you and don't worry about the choices others make for themselves. I'm tired of this useless, waste of time, waste of energy debate. Let's all just focus on being the best mothers that we can be and support others in doing the same! Great children have been raised by both stay at home moms and working mothers.

On getting baby to sleep ( 8 months) Have you tried singing lullabies? they really work. or telling bedtime stories of valor, kindness, being helpful, or showing picture books. But better to sing lullabies.

A gift for your husband on your 10th anniversary? Well , for sure, more love and care is the greatest gift especially if you prepare him with meals that are healthy, for long life !! And maybe buy him a shirt of his favorite color.

I wish I had access to a live-in au pair when my teenage girls were small! The au pairs are in the US for 12-24 months and provide up to 45 hours of help per week for $340/week per family. I would have been able to be a sane stay-at-home mom or work if needed!

What a wonderful article! And a great reminder that the people who's opinions really count at the end of the day are those of your kids (and husband/wife if you have one). Though I've been happily settled about my decision for a while, it was rough at the get go. Hadn't planned to stay home when my daughter was born, in fact I'd just completed my MBA right before getting pregnant, and was sure I was happiest climbing the corporate ladder...

See entire comment

Ashley...absolutely loved reading your insightful yet cool post on SAHM vs WAHM. You are 100% on target in my book - it is a woman's choice. As long as everyone's doing the best that they truly can do with parenting and the kids are thriving not suffering...I'm all for it!!

Thank you. It's so nice to hear someone say that its up to an individual. I think the worst hurt for me at least came from my ex hubbys opinion. The stay at homes are lazy, etc. I would probley have my foot in both worlds if could change the past setup. I like a balance of things somewhere in the middle if I can have it. I did say if I could have it! :) I have 2 children, one on their own/one just turned 18. Oh joy and pain! :).

I love this article. After years of frustration over debating this topic, I vowed once and for all to never trouble myself with my choices or anybody else's (in this matter) ever again. There are hundreds of workable scenarios when it comes to supporting a family...and as long as the children are loved and nourished, that's about where my judgment ends.

My daughter is the sole provider of her family at the present time, so our granddaughter is with us two days a week and day-care three days. She is a joy and the love of our life. She is thriving so having a working mom has been no problem, being at day-care has been educational and stimulating,and being with us has been wonderful! When she runs into our house and puts up her arms to be lifted and hugged, I am almost in tears, it is so magnicent. She is 18 months old!

I think you should write a book.. That was great to read and VERY true.. I have been both and I feel VERY blessed to be a SAHM. I think every mother does what she feel is best for her family.

No one should judge anothers parenting.

Love reading!!!

Right on-- and I think more and more mom's are opting out of the debate by finding a middle ground-- working from home or working part time, or staggering shifts with their hubby (which is what my parents did-- Dad worked days and mom evenings or vice versa, no idea how they stayed married but we spent VERY little time with a sitter!) As a single mom I get creative with a part time job that pays quite a bit per hour, hand me downs for Isaac, no new clothes for me, WIC and some times food stamps, but I make it work!

I love this very well-written engaging and totally cool article! Bravo!!! From a SAHM who is thinking about returning to my career of choice, this reminds me that it's all good...

Leave a Comment

Required
Required (will not be published)
Required (to prove you're human)
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on topic and not abusive
For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us
Want to become a contributor?
Want to become a contributor?

If you'd like to contribute to the Wisdom of Moms on Mamapedia, please sign up here to learn more: Sign Up

Recent Voices Posts

See all