Mamapedia City Voices highlights the inside scoop on your city by selected writers, from up-and-coming mom bloggers to well-known mom experts.
Men Don't Wear Earrings
Last “French Fry Friday”, a family tradition in which my kids (2 1/2 and 4 1/2) and I throw caution to the wind and drive through McDonalds to split a small fries three ways (being careful that they don’t drop any on my 10 month old between them in the back seat), the man taking our money had two sparkling earrings. My four year old exclaimed, “Mom! That man had two earrings!” To which I said, “Yup.” She then said, sort of giggly, sort of not, “Men don’t wear earrings!” To which I said, “Well, sure they do, he’s wearing some right now.” End of topic. Or so I thought.
As we idled and waited for our turn at the pick up window, she said, with surprising venom and conviction for a dainty 4 and 1/2, “Well I don’t LIKE it!” Out of nowhere. On French Fry Friday, a day of levity and love.
Shocked, I scanned my brain for where she could have gotten this-especially the oomph behind it. With a father who is a heavy metal musician covered head to toe in tattoos, and a mother, myself, an artist, who is normal enough now, but had her share of fashion escapades in the past, including designing clothes for many years for people with everything pierced, and our adult peer group consisting of every type, ethnicity and just plain “weird” person there is, as well as “normal” ones, I was baffled.
I tried so HARD to break away from my conservative parents when I was young, fleeing to big cities and other countries to do so, I’ve practically come full circle. Granted, we have now moved away from the city to have kids, our kids rarely see our friends, and the biggest fashion faux pas we see are “mom jeans” and mullets, but we make a point never to criticize the appearances of others—even those in mom jeans and mullets—in front of the kids. I was stunned to hear something judgmental along these lines from my 4 1/2 year old daughter.
The one thing I have loved most in my life living in diverse places is blending with any and all people. It is my goal that my kids learn to judge people by their actions and words, not their fashion choices or any other surface element, for the sake of safety as well as morality. Obviously, no good can come from alienating good people based on their appearances, and trusting evil ones for the same reason.
Had grandma gotten in some superficial digs on a “weirdo” the last time we visited when I wasn’t around? Is there a redneck on the staff in my daughter’s preschool telling the kids that Men who wear earrings are You-Know-What? Or am I alarmed for nothing, and my daughter had merely not noticed earrings on the prince in her princess video and thus was expressing herself with “authority”? Hmmmm.
So I said, “Well sweetie, that’s a little harsh, I mean, he’s a person with feelings, and he seems very nice. He gets dressed every morning in what he likes, and it would probably hurt his feelings if he knew you said that. How would you feel if he said he didn’t like your favorite dress, when you feel so happy wearing it?” Silence. I felt that sufficed for drama, and kept things light. The fries were passed around and we were off to the park.
“Mom,” I heard, with a tremor. “What, sweetie?” “I’m really sorry I said that about the man’s earrings.” Full tears and sobbing ensued. Again, I was shocked at the emotion in the whole exchange. I said, “Hey, don’t worry, babe. He didn’t hear you say that. Now that you understand, do you think it’s OK that he wears those?” “Yes, mom, I LIKE his earrings.” “Well, OK then. That’s good. Maybe you can tell him sometime. OK?” “OK.” End of topic. Time to load out at the park.
The moments I treasure every day with the luxury of spending time with my kids, are the ones watching them develop through mundane activities and exchanges. I wouldn’t miss it. Think of the difference in her young heart, in just a few moments, if I had said, “Ya, men SHOULDN’T wear earrings.” Or if I had ignored it altogether-thus accepting it. Or if a parent said something like “Ya, I don’t like black people or fat people or yuppies or foreigners…..” in a similar learning situation on a tiny fresh slate.
In her emotion I could feel her reaching for my approval of her judgement. A new step in her life. I hope since I will not help her alienate others, she will not alienate me one day, or exclude herself from opportunities for joy and kindness. And maybe I’m making too much of the whole thing. But if there is anything spontaneous and valuable we can share as parents during the long hours we spend with our kids, it’s these very small things, our words and our hearts, and for that I am thankful.
Amy Abattoir is a painter and stay at home mother of three amazing children under 5 living in central Pennsylvania.
Amanda, July 16, 2010
Wonderful article! Thank you, Amy.
Genevieve, July 16, 2010
Funny what they focus on. I've had a few incidents similar. We recently moved back to an artist/creative-type community with our kids. Our house going into foreclosure really made me inspect our lives and wonder why we moved the kids so far away from a community that embraces, or shows by example, our values and roots...
Mommy B, July 16, 2010
Just HAD to comment on this! I'm an artist as well married to a rock musician- who wears earrings! Very good article, though! I too, am trying my best to teach my children tolerance and acceptance specifically with people who may look different than they or someone they think looks odd, etc... race, style, size, shape, hair, no hair, etc.
jp, July 17, 2010
Beautiful writing, Amy...like you I am fascinated by the degree of both positive and negative emotion the incident generated in the wee one. It's a measure, I think, to which she has already been pounded by society's DO NOT DEVIATE FROM GENDER NORMS message, despite being exposed to so many free thinkers. Sobering.
Crissi, July 18, 2010
I think it's good that you let her know proper ettiquette for sparing other people's feelings when she doesn't like a certain look they are wearing, etc. But what bothers me is that after she learned that she might be hurting his feelings with her opinion, she changed her opinion to one that would please him. She basically let go of her own voice in favor of someone else. It's ok for anyone to decide they like certain looks or don't like other looks...
Kerry, July 18, 2010
Great post, and what wonderful responses you gave her. I think that preschoolers are trying so hard to figure out what it means to be male (or female) that they have a lot of trouble coping with any ambiguity--they want some black-and-white rules about what you do, or don't do, and no overlap. I'm a preschool teacher, and I've heard children assert that girls can't be doctors (when their mom is a doctor) or that boys have short hair, when Daddy wears a ponytail...
Brina, July 19, 2010
what a sweet note on the wonderful differences in all of us- I hope I am as thoughtful and tactful when my daughter has questions just like these!!
NIcole, July 19, 2010
Wow Amy, thanks for making my Monday, with that.
Mary, July 19, 2010
Time spent in the car with kids has always been time well spent--an opportunity for the type of life lesson conversations your piece thoughtfully explores! My adult daughters and I still experience moments of pleasure, comfort and divine wisdom whenever we three converge in central PA and go on "Our Ride" along our favored backroads lined with cornfields that we traversed many nights after dinner. Thank you for sharing your experience.
Shauna, July 22, 2010
Great article and one that reminded me of another Mamapedia post and Newsweek article that talked about how in an attempt to be color blind (by not talking about different races, ethnicities, etc.) we are actually creating more confusion for our children. basically that children automatically need to compartmentalize and our lack of communication is indeed a very loud statement - that's if it's not talked about, it must be bad...
sherry, July 23, 2010
Love your post Amy.
Texan mama, July 24, 2010
I like your article a lot. And, it resonated with me for a different reason: in high school I was a blond cheerleader. I am just a natural blonde, and I did cheerleading because I like it. But I wasn't ditzy or stupid. However, people looked at me and assumed I was, just because of how I looked. They also assumed I was stuck up which I most definitely wasn't. Same thing happened in college when I joined a sorority...
Ruth Martin, July 24, 2010
Loved your article. I direct a preschool in a liberal town. I love how you shared and guided your daughter thru this amazing milestone moment.
Paise, July 24, 2010
My MIL pulled the same crap over my tattoo, piercings, and etc.. It was wrong and I had to prove to my daughter that there are many types of people who making the world. In my case, I took her to my piercing artist when I had to pick up a retainer before having surgery not long after. I couldn't remove the jewelry without something in it's place because the piercing was less than year old at the time. I wasn't about to risk having it close up...
Renee, July 24, 2010
I love jewelry. What woman doesn't? What man doesn't? If a person likes it and feels comfortable in their own skin, go for it. :)
My preference is, however, earrings for men with a purpose, i.e. military, civil service, microphones, ministers, etc. Whatever right? LOL.