Mamapedia City Voices highlights the inside scoop on your city by selected writers, from up-and-coming mom bloggers to well-known mom experts.
Cheetos vs. Carrots: (Not) Fighting to Feed Kids Healthy Foods
My kids are sick of healthy lunches. They don’t want organic soybean butter and Farmer’s Market fig jam sandwiches, they want Lunchables: crackers, processed cheese, salty disks that pass for lunch meat and a whole lot of chemicals wrapped up in a plastic box. My son just confessed he’s been dumping his organic carrot snacks in the trash (and I thought the ranch dip was decadent). My daughter’s been trading her edamame for Twinkies. Forget the organic veggie chips I carefully stowed in wax paper bags—heaven for these children would be to open up their lunch boxes and spy a bright-orange bag of Flamin’ Hot Cheetos.
If you haven’t been following the Cheetos controversy, last year’s NPR exposé found the snack has addictive properties that I’m theorizing might be caused by an excess of red dye number five. Every time Angelina Jolie takes her brood out for a walk, the paparazzi snaps them snacking on the deep-fried, day-glo crunchies. And the cheetah-emblazoned bag has elevated elementary-school pariahs to the status of homecoming kings—as long as they have trading privileges.
Now I’m no stranger to junk food. After enduring years of brown-bag lunches with an oversized, barely washed carrot from my father’s vegetable garden peeking out of the top as evidence of my snack, I spent many years of rebellion indulging in a plethora of processed foods. But the organic apple doesn’t fall far from the tree: I always felt better when I was eating healthy foods, like those I’d grown up with.
In the hopes that I’d similarly indoctrinate my own children, I introduced healthy eating habits early. As toddlers, my kids ate everything from seaweed to asparagus. I followed the five rules to a tee:
1. Have regular family meals.
2. Serve a variety of healthy foods and snacks.
3. Be a role model by eating healthy yourself.
4. Avoid battles over food.
5. Involve kids in the process.
We eat a family meal at least five nights a week. A big bowl of organic fruit sits on the counter. Most weekends, I take them to the Farmer’s Market. At the supermarket, we hold discussions in the processed food aisle about how my job as a parent is to protect them from harm—including chemicals.
But guess what? At 10 and seven, two out of my three children exist on a diet of pasta, pizza, chicken nuggets and the occasional hamburger. Occasionally, in the 15 minutes between theater class, skateboarding lessons and thrice-weekly baseball practice we even hit the McDonald’s drive-thru.
They gotta eat, right?
The point is, I do my best. The pasta is organic whole wheat, the pizza is homemade, the chicken nuggets are actually soy and hamburgers at home are free range and organic. All meals are augmented by a daily serving of green vegetables, and in-between snacks involve a whole lot of organic string cheese. My son has an aversion to fruit (hence, the string cheese), but both my daughters nibble on what’s in season.
Sometimes, I even let them have Cheetos. (But never in their lunch boxes.)
And, in keeping with rule number four, I try not to argue with them about food. I encourage, yes. I cajole, absolutely. And I definitely set a good example. As a result, I hope one day my kids and I will sit down to a meal of freshly prepared foods that they don’t recognize—and they’ll take a bite, without question. I may have to wait until they’re 25, but I do believe it can happen.
Hey, a mom can dream, can’t she?
HEALTHY CHILD HEALTHY WORLD is a national non-profit igniting a movement that inspires parents to protect young children from harmful chemicals. Healthy Child educates parents, supports protective policies, and engages communities to make wise choices and responsible decisions to create healthy environments where children and families can flourish.
Ashley, August 12, 2010
Well said! Teaching our children healthy eating habits before they know why they need to be healthy is, in my mind good parenting. I grew up in a house where we ate healthy enough but we snacked constantly. I grew up with treats consisting of a bag of chips and a chocolate bar. I struggled with weight through my teen years and into early adulthood until I realized I'm responsible for what goes in and just like poor TV and bad language - garbage in garbage out...
Melissa (Confessions of a Dr.Mom), August 13, 2010
I really like this article. I'm with you, all we can do is keep trying and set a good example. If they occasionally indulge in cheetos, McDonalds...I'm not going to worry about it. We talk about eating healthy and why it's important but I don't want to have battles over it. I still think everything in moderation. Thanks for putting it all in perspective.
MommaL, August 13, 2010
I totally agree! We eat quite healthy as well, but have our share of Chik-fil-A nuggets on the go, or pizza.
The way I see it, is to provide a healthy base and teaching them the right foods to eat, because they will face times when the only food available is processed, like at a birthday party or friends house, or parent brought snacks after a soccer game.
KB, August 14, 2010
Thank you for this!! I am in the midst of the food battle with my 2.5 yr old son - have been feeding healthy organic since he was old enough to have solids and now he's rejecting everything!! He'll eat a ceral bar for breakfast (organic..again better than nothing is the assumption here) and loves pizza and mac and cheese..so glad to know I'm not the only one in this!
Sara, August 15, 2010
I know parents who consider gummy bears with "fruit juice added" to be healthy foods for their kids... If you are setting a good example they will hopefully develop a tendency toward making healthy food choices, and if the occasional french fry sneaks in they will still be ahead of the game compared to the kids who live on that stuff...
Susan, August 15, 2010
Enjoyed this! I, too, struggle with my girls (ages 9,11,13). What has happened to my dream of kids who crave healthy foods? Thanks for helping me drop some of the guilt :)
Amy, August 17, 2010
Kids eat so bad! I traded the occasional healthy thing for junk at school as a kid and try not to be too militant, but kids eat sooooooo bad, I'm not looking forward to the ages you mention even with all the good habits I'm forming! We were in Paris once, and two skater tweens in stretch jeans and converse stopped by a corner market and grabbed-brace yourself-bottled water and apples. Alone. No parents. WATER??!! TEENS??!! I wondered...do only American kids eat soooooo bad?
Naomi Marie, August 20, 2010
When my son was about 8 he pushed back on the healthy stuff.
I said fine - we'll buy it - but before you put it in your body you have to look it up online and make a real decision for yourself. You have to determine if you want it in your body.
90% of it went back.
He likes some ice cream and chips once in a while. An occasional sub sandwich.
This past April we where at an airport, looking at the food choices in the food court...
Alexa , August 20, 2010
I love seeing so many families doing their best to educate and provide for their children. We struggled for a long time to get our RDA of good food until I found Juice Plus. It has been around for years and is actually real fruits and veggies, with the water taken out in a capsule. We have found that everyone wants more fresh foods. Our immune systems are stronger and I know prevention is easier than cure. Check out the research www.alexamarceaux.com.
Ma. Teresa S. Habitan, August 20, 2010
I had running battles with my grandparents and my mom (never my dad though even if it was his parents!) when I was 5 years old, because I was being badgered to eat vegetables. I did once, and then I got severe tummy ache! I can still remember my 3 year old bratty self scolding all the adults in the household that it was their fault that I was sick! Thank goodness I outgrew both the brattiness and the aversion to vegetables...
Michele Clembury, August 20, 2010
I hear you! Man do I hear you. The hard thing is that the battle to get healthy food in them is undermined constantly. You send healthy food in lunch to camp, then they open the cantine and other kids are buying candy they've never even seen. You send healthy food to lunch at school and the teacher is sending treat bags of candy to introduce herself. But we do all sit down to the same meal every night and I know I've sent them off with healthy food in their stomache in the morning...
Annie, August 20, 2010
I love this article. I'm there with my 6 yr old right now. But, he sometimes chooses to hold his own at the school lunch table: singing the greatness of a whole wheat tortilla stuffed with organic pb and fresh apples over mystery meat casserole.
You're right, we do the best we can and let them choose - but make sure they have the best options. Keep up the good work!
Jessy Baker, August 20, 2010
Are you aware of the all natural Cheetos? While still a processed food, they don't have the artificial color and only about four or five ingredients including real cheddar cheese. It could be a great compromise, and they taste great.
shelley, August 20, 2010
I am guessing that in Paris they don't have the overabundant access to the junk food we do or the advertising to support it. So yeah, probably is an American thing. :(
But Rachel, what you said was right on; you yourself rebelled but then you came back again. Teaching your kids right at home, both by instruction and your example, will engrain the good habits and give them a palate for what's good, even if they don't always choose the best now.
Ginger Garner, August 20, 2010
So timely - as I just posted a blog about this very subject today. You can find it: "Is Your Child A Food Snob? (maybe she/he should be) at Breathing In This Life - a blog for women and mothers living Fit and Fearless at www.gingergarner.blogpost.com