104 answers

Would You Let Your 9 Year Old Walk Home from School?

My 9 year old son wants to walk to his friend's house after school on Friday. He would be walking with his friend & the distance is probably less than a mile. The neighborhood is good, but I'm nervous. I won't be home until around 6 because I work.

My son has told me that his friend's parents think that I am too overly protective. I have a neighbor in law enforcement that mentioned that there are 5 pedaphiles (excuse the spelling) in the area. They aparently don't show up on the internet list for various reasons such as they are still under investigation, are known to police but not enough evidence, etc. This neighbor will not let his kids into the front yard unattended. I am also not sure what he means by "the area". I had another neighbor that (a couple of years back) told me that a man had parked in front of my house (there is a clear view of the 5-6th grade school down a drainage ditch from where he was parked) for a couple of days in a row right when school was letting out. She said she watched the first day but never saw him pick anyone up. The second day she made it obvious that she was watching & he drove away when he saw her.

Despite these stories, the neighborhood is probably as safe as any other. The 10 years we've lived there, there has been 1 burglery & that was by neighborhood teens who knew the homeowner & where they hid the key.

Am I over-protective? What would you do?

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thanks to everyone for the moral support. It is very reassuring to know that so many of you feel the same way. I was worried that I might have been way off the mark.

For the record, my son's friend's parents are very nice people & have always honored my wishes. My son plays at their house regularly and they are careful to walk him home when he's done. As for them saying that I was overly protective, this may just be my son's interpretation. Even if it's not, my son knows that I am just looking out for him and already he has told me that he appreciates that.

This was difficult for me because I hate telling him no for something that he's got his heart set on. These two had been making plans at school all week. It ended up that the friend's mom offered to pick them up after school that day. What a relief! I gave him my work number & he called me as soon as he got to their house. He is such a good kid.

Featured Answers

Simply put and from my heart - not in this city. I am a paramedic (who has seen things no one should ever have been victim too) and I went to college to get my BA in Psych. Looking at it from all of those views and the crime rate in Houston now. . .I simply could not chance it until he was a bit a bit older.

No. I don't care care how close it was. I grew up in a tiny town where it was safe and me and one of my friends would walk everywhere we went. We were only in middle school and junior high but it was safe. Now in that same town I would be scared to walk through it. People have gotten crazy in these past few years. I watch the news every morning while getting ready for work, and there are too many "missing people" stories for my comfort. I will be 22 next month and I am already worried about the community my 18 month old will have to grow up in.

I would never let them walk home alone. I'm scared that he'll get kidnapped. It's happened before. If he hasa cellphone, that's a different story.

More Answers

You need to trust your inner voice. Do not let other people's opinion sway you from what you are comfortable with. You are not over protective. You are realistic about the world we live in. Good luck.

1 mom found this helpful

Trust your instincts. Who cares what the other parents think about you, this is your son. When friends come to our house
we honor their parents request and keep the rules of our home.
Keep your son safe.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi C.,
If you are not comfortable with it, then don't do it. Don't let your son's friends/parents decide what is best for you. Maybe they are too carefree? And that will come back to bite them in the ... someday, if they are not careful. Just my thoughts, you can never be too careful. K.

1 mom found this helpful

I agree with you. Your son is too young to stay at home by hisself. I lived in area like what you discribe and did let my kids walk home until one of the men on the list stopped to talk to one of my sons. I was home and put a stop to them walking home after this. I had two boys and they did pretty good being by their selfs but they would have wild days and get into trouble. I think any time you can keep a child busy and not alone to create his own trouble, the better off you are.
The same children who parents are saying you are too protective are the same one who may get to stand in front of a judge with their children that got into trouble. Times are very dangerous. We no longer have to just worry about our childrens friends but our neighbors also.
I always found if I do what I think is best for my child no matter what any one else says I alway came out a head. I learnded the hard way no one know my children like I do so their advice is not always correct. I think you should do what you think is best for your child. He will be gone soon enough enjoy him now.

R.

1 mom found this helpful

Main entry portal for the Texas Dps Sex offender website is:

https://records.txdps.state.tx.us/DPS_WEB/Sor/index.aspx

there are other websites on the web, but this is the only one that I would trust to be the most accurate in Texas…

I found a guy that literally lives across the street from me. I do not let my kids outside even for a second w/o me w/ them-much less walk home from anywhere.
The old saying, "It's better to be safe then sorry" plays in my head everytime I try to make a decision about anything.

1 mom found this helpful

C.-Absolutely not are you over-protective! I am a sex offender probation officer by day and do real estate also. Just because your neighborhhod is "safe" does not mean anything. I supervise sex offenders in the nicest of neighborhoods. Remember the case of Michael Devlin who kidnapped Shawn Hornbeck, 11, at his bus stop in St. Louis in 2002? I do not want to make you paranoid but we are in a different day and age than when we were young and walked home from school. As many great memories as I have from walking home with friends I will never let any child of mine walk home from school. The only way to protect your own children is to do it yourself. If you did let your son walk home and God forbid something happened you would look back at this e-mail you sent out and never forgive yourself. Be safe. Your gut instict told you already not to allow it, go with it, that is what we do as mothers. I wish you the best and stay strong.

1 mom found this helpful

I think a lot about stuff like this although I've yet to really arrive at the decision making point- my two are 5 and 7 (8 tomorrow!).
I think that I want them to have some independence, but I want them to be safe.
The closest experience I have to what you are mentioning is the idea of letting my girls ride the city bus one day, so they can go to the big public library, a museum, or some other interesting spot. I want them to be able to do that, but I don't know what age they'll be (obviously I think it'll be before they turn 16).
My idea for you here is not to let them do anything you haven't already done with them. When I teach my girls to use the bus, I'll be with them the first several times. I will teach them how to do it and how to act during the trip, the whole banana. I won't let them go near it until I feel like we've done it enough times for it to be...automatic.
Same deal with taking walks/rides around the neighborhood. I don't let them do that without me yet, but we practice a lot. We take walks or rides (or sometimes skates) around the neighborhood and I ask them where to turn and how do we get home from here throughout the process. My 5yo now knows her right from her left and she could get you home from her pre-school if you asked her. You don't want them to be afraid, you want them to be empowered, and confident, calm, and able to respond appropriately- to cars, people, dogs, etc... Oddly enough dogs are among the largest dangers we face in our neighborhood- running loose and that will throw off my children's sense of 'what do I do- he's coming right at me'.
You have to teach them what to do, model it, and let them copy you.
Summer's coming- so maybe think towards next year as a goal. Tell him, you want to walk with your friend, I'm going to show you how. And practice several times with him until you feel sure about things, walking with him is the only way you'll know what he will experience. That'll be hard with your work schedule, but I'd encourage you to try and find some afternoons during the summer when you could walk the walk and talk about what to look out for and how to respond if this or that happens (maybe even Saturday afternoons). I bet he'll feel better about it that way, and you will too.
Finally, labeling parents does not do anyone any good. Don't fall into the trap of 'they said this so I'll respond by allowing that'- he's not their kid. period.
Hope this helps a little! Best of luck!

1 mom found this helpful

Me personally I would not let my child walk home especially if I knew that there were pedaphiles in the area. I say it's better to be safe than sorry. I know people may say you are being overprotective but you need to do what you feel is right to protect your family. Unfortunately, the world we live in is not a safe one and things happen to children everyday. If your neighbor cop won't even let his children play in the front unattended then why would you allow your child to walk by himself..I would take the advice of the cop and not let your child do it. There is definitely a good reason why he is not allowing his children to play unattended. Again, better to be safe than sorry.

1 mom found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.