B.L. asks from Newton Falls, OH on April 21, 2009
Would You Dye Your Daughter's Hair?
My 7-yr old (soon to be 8) asked me tonight if she can change her dark blond hair to black. I'm torn! On one hand, it seems weird to allow a young child to dye her hair. But I believe that hair is "just hair"...why not have fun with it? I asked her why she wanted to do it, and she said she thinks she would like to have hair the same color as mine (my natural color). Of course that's flattering, lol, but I was also reassured that she wasn't asking just because someone else did it, or because she wants to be "pretty", or anything like that.
I am not worried it will lead to a slippery slope, because I know where I stand on other issues such as appropriate clothing or tattoos. I am definitely not one of those parents who allows my kids to do whatever they want; I actually tend to lean towards stricter parenting. If I do allow her, I'd use a semipermanent that would just gradually fade, and it would be a natural-based (not chemical) one that is not harsh on hair.
Thoughts???
So What Happened?™
Thank you to everyone...there is a wide variety of wonderful opinions and advice on here!!
After thinking, I'm going to let her, but you all helped me figure out some important details. I talked to her again about it, and she confirmed that she knows she is 100% beautiful just as God made her, and her only motive is to "have fun". She's even asked for a pink or purple streak in the front!
I was wrong about using semi-permanent...the dye I found is a "direct dye", meaning no chemicals are involved. It just basically stains her hair and washes out within a week or two. I even checked the MSDS sheets online, and it's completely hazard- and chemical-free. Also, I am going to have her wait til the last day of school, so she can have "fun" with it without disrupting school. Their last day is nothing but a fun day anyway.
When she first asked about it, she didn't even know it could really be done...she just said "I want to make my hair black". Nobody in our home dyes their hair, and of my daughters she has the more adventurous streak. I've decided that as long as we only use chemical-free, safe dye, she can play with her hair and I'll keep focusing on what really matters to me - nutrition, God, manners and morals (to name a few). And if she hates it...well, she can wait the week or two for it to wash out and will learn a good life lesson.
Thank you so much for all the good advice and information!!!
Featured Answers
B.B. answers from Cleveland on April 22, 2009
Just my opinion, but at that age, I would say "no." Hair dyes are full of chemicals! At that age, you don't know what effect that could have on her body.
1 mom found this helpful
C.B. answers from Dayton on April 22, 2009
Hi B.,
Maybe try it at Halloween or some other dress up time. Otherwise you may be setting the stage for something more dramatic down the road....
Good luck.
C.
M.B. answers from Cincinnati on April 22, 2009
B....I would ask a hairdresser. There is something about a child's hair vs. an adults. The layers of hair shaft or something. It might ruin her hair. I would probably wait until she's older. Blond is beautiful......
More Answers
B.B. answers from Cleveland on April 22, 2009
Just my opinion, but at that age, I would say "no." Hair dyes are full of chemicals! At that age, you don't know what effect that could have on her body.
1 mom found this helpful
K.S. answers from Cincinnati on April 22, 2009
You have a lot of great opinions so far! I would just go with highlights for now, that way you can see what it will really look like. Plus, once you start dying, you really can't stop! You will constantly be covering up roots, until you change it back to her original color, which is VERY hard to do. Also, a totally random thought, but you might need to be careful with her school. The school where my daughter goes has a very strict policy about dying hair. They will make you change it back/wash it out.
S.S. answers from Cincinnati on April 22, 2009
I recently learned something interesting from my hairdresser. She said a child's hair doesn't reach "maturity" until around age 11. Once a child reaches 11, you can bet that's how her hair will be for the rest of her life. Until then, she recommended not doing anything more than cutting and styling because other things (coloring, perms, etc.) could damage the hair.
On a different note, we were talking about potentially coloring my hair to cover the gray (yikes!). She suggested starting with a semi-permanant color that will wash out in a few weeks. This would allow me to see if I like it and want to do the up-keep. She also explained that permanant color acutally lifts color from your hair and then dyes it. If you decide to go back to natural, the hair will probably be about 2 shades lighter than where you started. So, that's something to keep in mind when thinking this decision through.
Good luck!
M.K. answers from Cleveland on April 22, 2009
I would not do it, it's harmful to your child, especially at such a young age. Speak to a professional hairdresser first, about doing it, they would have the most experience with potential problems, health and otherwise. Because her hair is lighter, remind her that her hair will darken overtime and yes I think that it will be a large slippery slope. There will most likely be bad responses from other parents. I would say that the youngest that it should happen would be teens.
K.W. answers from Indianapolis on April 22, 2009
I have two girls who are teenagers now. But, my rule was always this: while I had to do their hair, I got to say how it was styled (how long/short, color, etc.). Once they learned to care for it themselves, they could decide what to do with it. We had more issues with how long or short to keep it rather than color. I did do highlights for one of my girls and she learned real quick that it grows out!! LOL She didn't want to have to sit through getting it done all the time!
Also, it helped because one of my daughters hated fixing her hair. The other one would get up and immediately put her hair up or brush it or whatever. Once they were taking care of it themselves, they seemed to know better what they wanted, too, and I didn't have to worry about it being a faddish thing.
This is just my experience, though. Sounds like she wants to be like Mom!!! :)
D.T. answers from Cincinnati on April 22, 2009
NO, NO, NO! yes, it's only hair, but it still apart of her being. This is how we lose our kids youthness, because we let them change and alter themselves for non-emergency reasons. Don't get me wrong, I'm not directing this towards you, but something as small as changing her hair color could lead to asking for Breast implants at 16, LOL. I would suggest letting her to conntinue to be a child and explain to her she is too young to be thinking about dying her hair. Also, going from blonde to black at that age is a bit to much and she may not like it, or it may not turn out right and then she may have to deal with her peers teasing her. No, No, No.
38 yr old wife and mother of 4 (4-boy, 6-girl, 8-girl, 10-boy)
L.C. answers from Cincinnati on April 22, 2009
Hi B.,
There is no "right or wrong" answer here. I would not allow my daughter to change the color of her hair at the age of seven but I would consider it at sixteen. At age seven I would focus on building up my daughter so she would appreciate who she is (body, mind and spirit) because I think that the media puts out a message that girls are "not enough." Kids are growing up too soon. Why are we seeing kids entering into what typically was considered "adult activity" 15 years ago? I fear that when we allow our little ones to experience things too early, they will not have anything to look forward to. Self-improvement is a wonderful thing, but I would say that at this age "character counts" more than hair color.
A.W. answers from Columbus on April 21, 2009
If you are going to allow your daughter to color her hair I would not let her go black. It is the hardest color to get out should she decide she does not like it. I would talk to a stylist for advice on what you could do that wouldn't ruin her hair but would allow her to play a little.
You need to remember she is only 7, and if she is anything like my 7 year old she is going to change her mind about a hundred times. Remember she is only 7 and still a child, do you really want her to grow up quicker then she needs to.
Email