M.R. asks from South Dartmouth, MA on October 19, 2010
Why Would a High School Coach Say This?
I have two children who both play sports. One is in high school and the other is finishing up Junior High. Last night, at one of my kid’s games, I heard the most infuriating thing come out of the Varsity coach's mouth. This guy has been a real piece of work since day one as far as coaching a team goes, but this commentary really took the cake for me. Our high school, like most, has a Junior Varsity and a Varsity team in most sports. Our JV team was playing horribly last night and got beaten by a team that they really should've won against. It happens. The kids were off, not playing their best, and they lost. While the JV team was playing, the Varsity Coach was on the sidelines literally making fun of some of the players and the mistakes that they were making. It was very unsettling to watch this happening and as a parent, I was really angry at this behavior. Then, as if it could be any worse, he walks over to the JV Coach at the end of the game and says....and I quote....."There will be three things happening next year on my team. #1 is that no one from your JV Team will ever be on my Varsity Team, #2 is that I will be bumping 4 Varsity players to JV, and lastly, I am going to go to our Junior High feeder schools to watch the 8th graders play to see if there's any new meat over there.” So basically, what I heard here is that a YEAR in advance, this guy is making decisions about kids, their abilities, and the team. A lot can change in a year as far as a kid’s skill level in a particular sport and also the movement of a player from JV to Varsity and vice versa. I heard all this banter because I happened to be in the right spot at the right time and I’m not too happy with this. The JV Coach was appalled at the comments and he told the guy that he is nuts and that he has no concept of how to bolster confidence in kids that play sports and that his tactics will do nothing but breed animosity between the kids and the teams. What do you parents think of this? If you were me and you heard this stuff, what would you do? Here’s my big dilemma…..I have a child on JV right now and they happen to be the best player on the team. Do I tell my child that they have no shot at Varsity next year because the Coach has already condemned everyone on JV a year in advance? Also, I have an 8th grader who is a top-notch player as well and this Coach sent my JV child over to me last night to ask me what the sports schedule is at her Junior High School so he can go watch them play. I guess that means my 8th grader is the “new meat” he was referring to earlier. He couldn’t walk his fanny over to me and speak to me as the parent but sends my “JV Loser” over to inquire about my younger child. I honestly don’t know what to make of all this. Personally, I think this Varsity Coach is a presumptuous, pompous, idiot. How in the heck can you make judgments as to who will be playing on next years Varsity team a year in advance like that? Parents….I need some feedback, please. What do you think about this?
Featured Answers
M.P. answers from Pittsburgh on October 19, 2010
If it were me I would email every parent of a child on the team and tell them what you heard. CC the athletic director and the principal as well. This is unnaceptable. You would be remiss if you did not act on it. Get this coach FIRED. You can do it.
6 moms found this helpful
S.H. answers from St. Louis on October 19, 2010
unless you're willing to address this thru administration, I'd recommend just letting it go. He was mouthing, & hopefully that's it.
Hard to do, but he's a jerk.....& bear that in mind in every single interaction with him. Good Luck.
4 moms found this helpful
More Answers
M.H. answers from Raleigh on October 19, 2010
Go to the athletic director asap! This man needs to go. Also, do not tell your JV child that there is no chance of varsity. Some coaches speak before thinking and end up eating their words later...no reason to worry your JV child! All in all, this is a crummy situation. Some people really should know better!
7 moms found this helpful
C.G. answers from Atlanta on October 19, 2010
Go to the principal. This is unacceptable. Let the JV coach know you went to the principal so he can back up your story.
7 moms found this helpful
M.A. answers from Orlando on October 19, 2010
Set up a meeting with the JV coach & principle, so you both can tell what happened.
6 moms found this helpful
M.P. answers from Pittsburgh on October 19, 2010
If it were me I would email every parent of a child on the team and tell them what you heard. CC the athletic director and the principal as well. This is unnaceptable. You would be remiss if you did not act on it. Get this coach FIRED. You can do it.
6 moms found this helpful
A.N. answers from Madison on October 19, 2010
I completely understand your frustration and disgust with this coach. I would be, too! First, and foremost, I think you should discuss this with the JV coach -- tell him what you heard and get his impression. If you are not satisfied, you should then go to the Athletic Director with what you know. I would avoid discussing it with your kids, but if you've already done so, be sure to follow up with what you find out from the JV coach and AD. Encourage them to still do their best, especially if they really enjoy playing! Do not let the coach discourage them. Best of luck and be sure to let us know what happens!
6 moms found this helpful
C.J. answers from Dallas on October 19, 2010
Ugh! From the daughter of a coach (who at times was a pompus @hole), you have my sincere empathy.
That said, I would NOT start riling up a bunch of trouble and calling all the parents, CCing folks, telling your son he has no shot at Varisity, etc. Just based on one overheard conversation.
If the JV coach is aware of this issue, he will be vocal and support the kids. AND guess what? If no one from JV moves up - ever, that is going to look really weird and pretty soon the program will crumble. . .any dope of a coach knows that:)
What you may have heard/seen may not have been what you think it is. Maybe this coach knows he is on his way out and he is making trouble for folks, maybe he is frustrated in his own ability and is jealous of JV coach and what you saw was a conversation between them that was intended to hurt/demean the JV coach and the kids' ability got caught in the crossfire.
Athletics are a strange and twisted politics in many schools, I have found that by laying low and being there to encourage your child and not giving a flip about a coach and insted respecting (right or wrong) their decisions it sets up a level of respect in your children and keep s you and them out of the crossfire. Let their ability speak for itself.
Don't know if any of this helped, but one final addition - guys are different from girls. Where we see this and think it is forever and a promise, to them it is spouting off because they are frustrated and want to shock folks into action.
5 moms found this helpful
J.B. answers from Atlanta on October 19, 2010
NO -don't tell your JV kid anything right now -you call the school and demand a meeting with that coach and the administration. Sit down and tell him you, as a parent, are appalled at what you heard him say. See if any other parents who were there want to go with you. Let him know you understand coaching a bunch of guys in jr. high and high school isn't all about holding their hands and making them feel special, but it's also not about demeaning and belittling young guys who happen to be having an off night. Bring up any other issues you've seen out of him this season as well. He needs something in his disciplinary file, and if he can't or won't amend his coaching techniques and behavior, he needs to find another career. Find out his plans for try outs, cutting, etc. for next year's team -and you'll have the administration as a witness.
I am a "suck-it-up" non-coddling type of mother. I have two young boys who I hope will both play team sports. I give them lots of affection and love, but I have no patience for the crying, whiny, overly-dramatic bit. I do hope to raise young men who are confident and proud and don't freak out over every little thing. However, if a coach of them acts in this manner -you can bet he'll be hearing from me! It's one thing to push kids to excel and tell them to suck it up because you KNOW they can do better so ultimately they have confidence in themselves and their abilities -and an altogether different thing to belittle them, humiliate them and make them hate what they're involved in. He may have lots of experience as a coach -I don't know -but it doesn't seem like he is a very good one.
4 moms found this helpful
S.H. answers from St. Louis on October 19, 2010
unless you're willing to address this thru administration, I'd recommend just letting it go. He was mouthing, & hopefully that's it.
Hard to do, but he's a jerk.....& bear that in mind in every single interaction with him. Good Luck.
4 moms found this helpful
Email