15 answers

Which Formula to Choose???

I have tried almost everything-I have a 3 month old that I breastfed for a month (do to circumstances I am no longer able.) Ever since I have been struggling with formula's. My doctor is no help so I am asking experienced moms. I started my daughter out on Enfamil Low Iron (it worked for her brother) and she was very colicy/gassy. I changed to Enfamil Gentleease and she would wake up with her face all swollen and puffy. I then tried Enfamil Soy, like her doctor suggested, and she refused to drink it and when she did her bowel movements were so hard she would get really upset. I now am trying Good Start DHA and ARA but she doesn't seem to want to drink much at all. She is gaining weight on schedule and she is peeing and everything just fine but I am concerned because some days she will have about 4 bottles a day but some days she will only have one bottle a day. I have tried different nipples but that doesn't seem to work is there any suggestions of what I may be doing wrong? She is the perfect baby and I am just trying to be the perfect mother.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Reading everyone's advice I looked into some other options and have decided to stick with the Good Start formula. I have read all of the reasons to change formulas on line and since she is going to the bathroom regularly and is eating quite a bit every other day I am going to stick with the Good Start unless other problems arise. Thank you for all of your help and I will probably have more problems in the future that will need your expertise.

Featured Answers

Oh Mama do I feel for you. My husband and I went throught the same. we wound up finding he took to the most expensive Alimentum. I thing the brand is similac. I tried soy based seemed okay but soom woohoo constipation we used gel suppositories it got so bad. Also I still add apple juice and/or dark caro syrup as told by doctor for the constipation.
As far as the number of bottles, she'll eat when she is hungry, as long as she is dehydrated or losing weight. Sometimes I think the added sweetness to the formula or milk makes it good to them. (less than an ounce)

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

Since you are using the Good Start formula I would stick with
that. I have a 5 1/2 month old who I am breastfeeding and
am also using the same formula that you are when I am at work. It seems to me that she doesnt really care for the formula either because sometimes she will gulp down bottle after bottle and some days she just doesn't want any. I have to keep reminding myself that children's appetites vary every day. As long as your child is eating when she is hungry and is going to the bathroom like she should be every thing sounds to me like it is okay!!:)

1 mom found this helpful

Oh Mama do I feel for you. My husband and I went throught the same. we wound up finding he took to the most expensive Alimentum. I thing the brand is similac. I tried soy based seemed okay but soom woohoo constipation we used gel suppositories it got so bad. Also I still add apple juice and/or dark caro syrup as told by doctor for the constipation.
As far as the number of bottles, she'll eat when she is hungry, as long as she is dehydrated or losing weight. Sometimes I think the added sweetness to the formula or milk makes it good to them. (less than an ounce)

1 mom found this helpful

If your child is gassy & colicky please try neutrimigen. i had that for both my girls & it worked like a charm. its expensive but its soooo worth it. u will see a totally different child. if u have wic or help paying for formula buy a can or two on your own. then if it works let your dr know & they will have to write up a note for u to take to wic. also u may want to try the liquid form. my daughter couldnt take the powdered type it had to be the one where u add water or its already pre mixed for ya. let me know how u do. good luck.

M.,

I also tried a couple of different formulas for my daughter. She didn't like the Good Start and would spit up very badly with it. Her spit up would look like rotten milk. So I use Similac Isomil Advance. It is a soy formula, but her spit up is much better and she isn't gassy with it. I would try that kind. I hope this helps.

What about similac soy? That worked my son, he didn't like any other brand.

M.,
I have been very happy with Similac Isomil Advance Soy Formula. My daughter spits up less and is less gassy with it.
I went with Similac because that is what the hospital used when I had my daughter.

I have to ask why can't you nurse I know people who can help with just about any situation. Your baby won't starve just keep trying and listen to your baby.

After the 6 we went through with my sons GERD and colic, I would go straight to Good Start every time from here on out. The amount is probably due to the nipples you are using and not the formula. Switching does take an adjustment for the baby, we had to quit too and although they were leaky and didn't seal goo the only ones my son liked were avent.
Good luck!
C.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.