K.P. asks from North Falmouth, MA on December 30, 2008
When to Stop Showering/sleeping with Daughter?
So here's my situation. I have a 9 1/2 year old step-daughter who won't sleep over our house. She will if she's having a friend sleep over, but that's it. She would if my husband would sleep in the room with her too, but we think she's too old for that. Her mother on the other hand still sleeps with her at least two nights a week. This is not my step-daughter going into her Mom's room b/c she's scared, this is her mother coming and getting into bed with her. She also still showers with her, and we think she's way too old for that. Her mother has been with her boyfriend for about 6 months less than my husband and I (about 6 1/2 years), and he lives there, so it's not like she's alone. She says we're jealous b/c she has a close relationship with her daughter, but that's not the case. I just had my first daughter in Aug. 07, so I have not gone through any of this yet, so maybe I'm wrong. So my question is this: Is this a typical mother-daughter relationship, or is 9 1/2 too old to be showering/sleeping with? Please help, I need some unbiased opinions.
Featured Answers
K.R. answers from Portland on December 31, 2008
in my humble opinion this is not normal and a serious boundary problem. The mother should instilling privacy and independence by 9 1/2 years old!
More Answers
L.D. answers from Hartford on December 31, 2008
Hi K.,
I was wondering how you know what is really going on at the mother's house? What relationship does the mother have with her daughter? If the girl is comfortable about sleeping and showering with her mother, then I think there is no issue. I know many of us here would not do these things but it doesn't imply anything bad is happening either. If she isn't self conscious about her body yet, that will very likely change in the near future. I know both my girls began wanting 'privacy' when they started developing.
With respect to the sleeping arrangement, I have 3 older children ( 13, 12, 10), first 2 are girls, and they ALL still want me to sleep with them/ or sleep with me if my husband is away. They actually fight over it- whose turn it will be next etc.. Every night, they all ask me for cuddles- which is when I lay down next to them and we whisper in the dark for a few minutes. It's a very endearing and precious time together. While I do fall asleep with them for a short while sometimes, they are always asking me to stay longer. It is actually exhausting for me, and I don't get to all 3 every night; they accept no as an answer peacefully when the time won't allow it. Sometimes I think I am crazy for doing it, but they enjoy having me there as they drift off to sleep. I know this won't last forever but it's what we do. And honestly, when I'm not too tired, I love to just look at their angelic faces, falling asleep with that sleepy, smiley grin as they drift off. It is just so amazing how the years fly by....I suspect it won't last too much longer...and that will be ok too.
They do spend extended time just fine away from home too, so this is just a nice, quiet, cozy down time ritual we do at home.
Just thought to share that perhaps your step daughter wants her mom there. Having said that, I don't shower with any of them, though!
J.H. answers from Boston on December 31, 2008
Sounds to me like this is her mom's way of keeping her to herself and not sharing her with your husband and your family. It is very odd to have a child of that age sleeping and showering with their mom.
D.A. answers from Boston on December 31, 2008
Hi K.,
It is odd for most pre teen girls to want to shower with their mom in this country. What harm is being done. Is she socially adjusted? Introverted personalty? If there is no effect on her ego or it is not stunting her growth as a person I think she will eventually grow out of it.
I also don't know that it is your place to say anything about it. Even though it has been almost 7 years you have all known each other. That is a conversation that should be kept between the child's' father and mother.
Good luck in the future creating a strong bond between you and your step daughter.
D.
T.A. answers from Providence on December 30, 2008
I have an 8 year old son and he used to shower with my husband.We stopped when he turned 7.He sleeps with us on occasion but it's very rare now.I felt he was getting too old.I think your step daughter is also to old for showering and sleeping with her mom.
M.B. answers from Boston on December 31, 2008
ya, I personally think at that age she should sleeping and showering on her own. I would have a even harder time if your husband (her dad)was given in and sleeping with her in her room.
sounds like the mother has some serious issues.
D.P. answers from Boston on December 31, 2008
Just chiming in to balance out the responses. You received a lot of responses from moms who are put off by this practice, just a few who don't object. I think that we're culturally trained to find such platonic intimacy between parents and children beyond toddlerhood offensive, but our discomfort does not mean there is something wrong with it. And--bottom line-- the decision is the mother's. I honestly don't see right and wrong in the situation, just different approaches that unfortunately aren't working harmoniously right now. Best of luck resolving it!
J.R. answers from Boston on January 05, 2009
I would say shes way too old to be showering with her mother still. I have a daughter who will be six in march and I think the last time she took a shower with me she was 3. We where at a family members house and trying to save time and hot water and she asked why I had hair down there and when would she get it. That was are last shower together! As far as sleeping together I don't know everyones diffrent but in my daughters case she slept with me until she was four and if I didnt meet someone then she might still be but only because I didnt want to sleep alone. I dont understand the fact that she has a man but still does this. So I couldn't say its not normal but its def not healthy.
L.C. answers from Boston on December 31, 2008
I don't think it's typical at all. It sounds very, very weird. I remember my nieces at that age, and the last thing they wanted (as they were starting to become body-conscious and wanting a little privacy) was to share a shower with their mother. Good luck with this one because it seems like no matter how nice you voice your concerns, her mother is going to disagree.
Email