What's the Big Deal Anyway? Am I Too Strict?

Sure, and MY mother wondered what was the big deal to have a PHONE (landline) in the house.

And HER mother wondered what's the big deal to have a CAR in the family.

And HER mother wondered what's the big deal to have ELECTRICITY in the house....

And so on and so forth.

Same issue, different generation!

:)

7 moms found this helpful

The reason the woman is making a big deal about it is because she wants other mothers to validate what she is doing with her daughter. AND it makes her feel superior to you to say this stuff.

Shame on her for talking to you that way.

If this were happening to your daughter, you would likely say what YOUR mother said to you back in the day. "If your friends jumped off a cliff, would you jump with them?" So.... don't be the one to jump just because this mom wants company!!

D.

6 moms found this helpful

Its not a big deal.
You do what YOU feel, is right for your daughter.

Just because all the other kids have it or something else, does not mean you have to follow-suit.
What does that teach your Daughter?

Just because kids that age may be having sex/doing drugs, does that mean she has to, too?
Her friend's Mom, has misguided logic.

You are FINE.

6 moms found this helpful

If she hasn't asked for it, she apparently isn't all that interested in it.

6 moms found this helpful

I don't think so and I am perplexed by the push to make our kids grow up. They'll get there soon enough!

6 moms found this helpful

How does FB or email actually improve a 14yr old's life???? It sounds like your DD has an active life that does not revolve around the internet- AWESOME. I don't think you're being strict, especially if she's not asking for it. Some parents are way too concerned with seeming cool to their kids, or being "friends" with them, and thinking FB is vital to a teen's life is rather.... immature in my opinion. Sorry for being blunt about that.

5 moms found this helpful

An "H to the E to the double L ...NO!" My kids can have a facebook when they have moved out and are on their own.

They can get in more than enough trouble and mental anguish without me allowing them to have facebook. We have a local woman in town who "sells her services" at the local motel she manages, she also arrives at work almost daily drunk...and she has at least three of my son's 4th/5th grade friends friended on her page. WHY would you ever allow 10 year old boys to be your friend as a 30 something woman??? Her page is filled with cryptic messages about her daliances with the local truck drivers...and these kids are on there reading this stuff...NASTY!

There is absolutely no benefit to your kid having a facebook account. It isn't fact filled, informative, life saving or necessary. Just one more thing to police and manage. Also...calling facebook and social networking sites "technology" is ridiculous. Hats off to you for holding your ground.

5 moms found this helpful

I did not have an email until I had a computer and I paid for my own internet and I did not have a myspace (pre facebook) until I moved and thought it was a good way to stay in contact with my friends (phone works better) so I closed my myspace and never started a facebook. I will not allow my kid(s) to have a FB while in my home unless something changes and you can not function w/out it (do not see that happening). People ask me all the time for my FB along with my phone number when I make new friends and I tell them, don't have one, won't have one but if you want you can call/text me. Email is for family/friends and I have an email that I give out to those stores that ask for it to send coupons and such separate from my email acct. Basically I have an "inbox" email and a communication acct that few have access to. I live my life well enough w/out blasting it for the world to see.

4 moms found this helpful

NO you are not strict...kudos to you. FB is just the latest fad...she has a phone and that's essential...

4 moms found this helpful

Not too strict, just right :)
She doesn't want it AND she really doesn't need it. Sounds like your daughter has a good head on her shoulders. Good job, mom!!

3 moms found this helpful

No facebook here, the girls are 13 and 15.
My older daughter has a phone and a computer, she takes online classes.
THey both have email.
You are not too strict about this stuff.

3 moms found this helpful

In this day and age, the mentality is a world filled with the latest technology. But I think it is refreshing to not have too much access to a world so uncensored. I think that around this age, an e-mail wouldn't be horrible. But I have to say that now that the latest Blackberry and Droid rage has arrived. I don't want to have access to my e-mails via my phone! I see the kids at my work picking up their phones constantly and answering facebook messages or e-mails. I feel when I am at home, I spend enough time wasted on the Internet. I wouldn't want it following me where ever I go!
What happened to the days when we only had landlines and they were hooked to a cord?! Life was much simpler then!
I do like the cell phone concept and don't know how I would have survived my kids not having them to keep in touch with me but all these new bells and whistles are unecesarry. So I'm with you...
As long as she is not asking...no hurry.
When you do give in... you can still set up the boundaries.

3 moms found this helpful

I am a fairly techy Mom, so we have smarty-phones...email and FB (well hubby doesn't anymore, but he just used it to play a game till he got bored with it, so cancelled the whole deal).

But email. My daughter is now 16 and she actually needed one for school. It was required for her to have a school one for teachers to communicate and email some of the papers and links to online textbook things at her new school, and even at her old one. The school provided it thru their server, etc, but things can be forwarded to one they check more often if they want, so I suppose it could go to a parents, but the kid needed to have access to it as well.

If nothing else, I think kids today need to gain the skills for using one, I guess, as it will also be a needed skill for college, where it WILL be required. I recently (as a 40 year old) finished pt/evening/online classes to complete a 2 year degree (that took me 5 years to do, with time off in there when my Mother died..took a year off and rarely went summers). The college provided an email acct and it was how they communicated EVERYTHING as it was almost exclusively paperless (grades, teacher communications, even more for online classes obviously).

I have no issue with parents being parents and making these choices, I just feel kids do get behind the techy curve that is a major part of their generation when someone doesn't properly guide them with it.

3 moms found this helpful

No biggie stick to what works best for your family and your household.

3 moms found this helpful

I say that since she hasn't asked or expressed any interest why would you want to push that sort of thing on her. Good for you and her for not allowing a predator gateway to your daughter. I am not and do not plan to ever be part of facebook and I would be worried to have my teenage daughter have one, espesially since I am not familiar enough with it to keep her safe while using it. Who cares that everyone and their dog has an account, if she is okay with not having one then why should anyone else care?

3 moms found this helpful

If she's allowed online (and I'm fairly certain her school has computers), I'm willing to put $5 on the table she HAS an email account. I'd say 50/50 on FB, so I'm not willing to take that bet... but DO try googling her name to see if one pops up.

BTW... does your daughter *know* your feelings on email/FB? I didn't even think to ask my mum to set one up 15 years ago, I just set one up. It took he over a year to realize I had email, and only because her phone wasn't blowing up (landlines) like it used to. She assumed I was making plans with friends while in school, which was true, but I was also getting a lot of email back and forth between people. I didn't think to mention it, she didn't think to ask... so I had email for a LONG time before she knew. I wasn't hiding it, it just only takes 2 minutes to check it and I spent hours in my room, at the library, at sports, at school... all places where I had easy internet access either through the house computer or my friends or the school or the library.

3 moms found this helpful

Kuddos for you!!!!!! my DD is 7 and she's asking for cel phone, lap top, facebook and all kind stuff that her classmate already have...She's in first grade!! and my Husband and I have agree at least for the next 6 years she will not have any, we have our family pc that she use under our supervision...you must feel blessed that she doesn't ask for it....Kids don't need to be all day online, is very well known that cel phones can cause cancer, and I imagine lap tops too, plus damage the vision and all that social life for what?? is better to keep them busy with sports!!
this is my opinion and I respect others too.....

3 moms found this helpful

If she isn't asking for it yet I would not push it - BUT please make sure you are talking to her about how to use these tools safely and with proper conduct. You may not be there the first time she does some of this stuff. It is so easy to make a mistake that will either harm her in the short term or worse, follow her for the rest of her life.

3 moms found this helpful

why push soemthing she doesn't want or need? as long as she is happy with what she has leave it to that!!

2 moms found this helpful

I don't think it's a have to have situation. She's not asking for it, doesn't have a job that requires it. Although maybe for her volunteering, having an email could possibly be helpful if she needs to send a document for some random thing. But that would be more administration sort of stuff. I know my high school teachers accepted me emailing my homework to them if I was sick or what not.
I don't think it's a big deal. Why give a toddler candy if they don't ask for it? Same sort of idea.

2 moms found this helpful

Stick to your guns and don't let your adult friend bully you or pressure you into giving your daughter Facebook. No matter what Facebook claims, the information on it belongs to Facebook as a company; no matter what privacy settings they claim you can have, someone can get around them sometime. With Internet and e-mail bullying, with freaks out there tryiing to find kids on Facebook, with other kids putting up inappropriate messages or photos -- why open that can of worms? As for "all the kids have it," well, if all the kids want everyone in the world (including future employers) to see every embarrassing photo and read every inane, childish posting, they can go for it. Teach your daughter how to value her privacy more than that. Good for you. If her friends want to reach her, they can call her at whatever number you say they can use, during the hours you say they can call.

2 moms found this helpful

Many of my daughters extra curricular coaches/leaders contact her through email. It makes her responsible for her own schedule. I dont see anything wrong with fb and an email at her age. Especially with proper monitoring.

2 moms found this helpful

I think it is a little rigid, HOWEVER, IF she has not expressed interest.... just wait until she does.

We have FB, IPhones, laptops......my daughter has a yahoo email and internet access with her phone and laptop. She stays in contact with friends and family via FB as well. SHe uses her laptop for FB but also a LOT for school making power point presentations, etc.

You don't want to "push" it on her but you also don't want her behind the curve on technology.

Our daughter uses the email a lot.... coaches contact the cheerleaders via email, calling their cells, and/or texting. It is just the way things have progressed over the years. I don't buy into all the cancer causing phones, computers etc... If you think about it... everything has been said to cause cancer at some point.

If your daughter is responsible and wants FB, I'd allow it. Of course, have it set up on top privacy settings and monitor it.

You have to do what is right for your family... what is right for one is not for another.... don't worry about what others think.. you don't answer to them!!

2 moms found this helpful

In regards to e-mail, I am a high school teacher and I often e-mail out instructions, changes to the class syllabus, and corrections to students. They and their parents have the option of giving me their e-mail addresses at the start of the year, which I compile into a List-serve and then use if there are any changes I feel like they need to be aware of - for example, I found out last Friday afternoon that my classes were going to be used for counselor presentations today so the quiz I had planned for them needed to be moved to Tuesday. I sent the students an e-mail letting them know that they had an extra day to prepare - which the students always appreciate. I have done this the last 3 years, my guess is about 90 - 95% of my students take advantage of it, and it has proven to be helpful.

There are teachers on campus here who have Facebook accounts set up for their classes and they post questions and answers, and some also have Twitter accounts where they will Tweet a question that goes along with the reading assignment for that night that will give them a hint for the upcoming quiz. I will hold off on those types of things until the district tells me we have to do them to be more "in-touch" with today's youth. Sigh.....

2 moms found this helpful

My soon to be 14 yo daughter only has a flip phone, primarily for calling after extracurricular activities. She does not have a texting plan. And although she wants one, she does not and will not be getting a Facebook account, until she is at least 16...and it's a maybe then. She does have email, but I have the password and check it regularly. Your daughter is not missing out on anything.

2 moms found this helpful

I don't know for sure "now-a-days," but my first email was in college and I had to take a crash-course on how to use it (that was in 2001). My parents did not have a computer at home at the time (my dad still doesn't) and we were not given permission to use the internet at school even until my senior year in high school. I know plenty of adults who are not into social networking or any of that other stuff, and there are definitely days when I wish I didn't have it, either. It has its uses, but is not essential to life and is just one more area you have to monitor your children and make sure you are protecting them from themselves and other people--not something I'm looking forward to. It sounds less like you are strict and more like your daughter has no interest in wasting her time online when she has people she can interact with in real life.

I don't even know what an IPhone is anyway, and I'm 27. =)

2 moms found this helpful

Sometimes misery loves company! LOL
I'd say you're lucky. I wouldn't push it.
She's not even asking about FB or email so there's no problem.

2 moms found this helpful

If she's not asking for it, then just go with the flow and not worry about it until she does. Honestly, it's just more stuff to monitor. Both of my oldest kids (in 7th grade) use FB. One is on all the time and the other maybe once or twice a week. Neither one has a computer and only one has a cell phone so that limits access for them. To get a FB account, your child has to have an e-mail address so one goes with the other. Neither one of these kids has ever used their e-mail address other than setting up FB, but I tutor high school students and an e-mail account eventually becomes a necessity. High school kids might have to e-mail a document to a teacher or classmate for a group project, and my students e-mail me their work.

Once she does request FB and goes on, you will need to become very familiar with it very quickly. I was on before my kids, so I am comfortable with setting their security and privacy settings, finding things that they might try to hide, etc. Anyone who does not regularly log into his or her child's FB page is woefully ignorant, IMO. It's pretty obvious even at this age who is being monitored and who has parents who are totally clueless.

Also, google her name just to make sure she doesn't have a FB account. At least three of my son's friends' parents had no idea that their kids were on FB until I showed them. It's not rocket science to set it up so she may have an account that she has set up somewhere else and you have no idea.

2 moms found this helpful

if she doesnt want an account then whats that mom care? my 7 year old has an account to play the games and get messages from family out of state. (of course i have the password and am on there more than her) if your 14 year old doesnt care you shouldnt either

2 moms found this helpful

Santa brought our four year old her own pc for Christmas along with several pc related games and toys. The majority of them are from disney and use a cd, no internet required. Some, like the Dora Link Doll do require the internet but it only goes to that site. We also got the disney docking station where she places one of the character tubes into the docking station and it will automatically go only to that site for games. She is being exposed to "technology" without being exposed to the predators. I don't think you're being to strict at all. If she has not expressed any interest in it why push it on her. Hubby and I have FB to keep in contact with family and friends but our daughters will not. Too many weirdo's out there sending friend requests acting like their young kids. There is no way to know who if people actually are who they say they are. Not to mention all the cyber bullying from class mates. I say a regular cell phone without internet is more than enough for them to keep in contact with you and their friends. There are news stories every day of kids/teens going missing after meeting up with an "internet friend." We can teach our children right from wrong but lets face it, teens think they know everything and nothing bad will ever happen to them. Hold out as long as you can :)

2 moms found this helpful

girl please, you're not too strict. my friends & I (in our early 30's) talk ALL the time 'bout how we didn't have any of that stuff growing up and since we didn't grow up that way, we don't see any way in hell we'll let our kiddos do it....of course, we all have toddlers so i'm sure our opinions may change, but for now, we're all like 'hell no' to the technology thing for our kiddos.
however, all my friends are major into the "super-connected" world & have all the gadgets you mentioned, including fb. me...i have a practical phone & cld care less 'bout having an i-phone & i just deactivated my fb. i actually feel liberated b/c i'm not doing what everyone else is doing - lol.
anyway, nope, i completely agree w/you mama! :)

1 mom found this helpful

My daughter is 8, and has her own e-mail account (which copies every sent and received e-mail to my own account, so I can keep track of who she's talking to - she knows this and expects it). She uses it mostly to chat with school friends, cousins, and grandparents. She has a Facebook account for the same purpose. We have the security features set up so that "random" people can't see her photo, any of her posts, friends of friends can't see anything, etc. It's a fun way for her to keep in touch with her cousins and the rest of the family without tying up the phone line for hours at a time! =)

1 mom found this helpful

I think to each family their own. My stepdaughter wouldn't have FB if it was entirely up to me, but it's not. My daughter will not have a phone with all the gadgets that her sister got very young - there is no reason a 10 yr old needs a web-enabled phone.

I think that while FB is a big social tool, I also do not think it's a mandatory social tool. My stepson (a little older and wiser) has in the past deleted is account because it got too aggravating, and I know a lot of people who have stepped back from FB for many reasons.

The long and short is that YOU are her mom and if YOU decide that she doesn't need FB or an iPhone or rated R movies, then that's your choice.

I personally would allow the email because I've found that a lot more teachers are doing things with email now. My stepkids have been able to get work while sick and/or turn in work and/or communicate with coaches and directors via email. Again, a tool you teach her how to use appropriately.

1 mom found this helpful

If your daughter hasn't asked, then you haven't even had the opportunity to be strict ;) I wouldn't give it a second thought... just cross that bridge when you come to it.

1 mom found this helpful

If your daughter doesn't care, why split hairs? When she feels that she wants or needs it, I am sure she will ask about it. My 10 year old step daughter has a cell phone (which I personally feel is ridiculous, but I don't foot the bill), but no facebook- even though some kids do at her age which I find frightening. I think your daughter has found much more productive ways to engage with her friends IN PERSON that she probably doesn't feel much of a need for the technology to connect with them.

1 mom found this helpful

I don't think your being strict. Our daughter has had an email account since 14 with us having access to it. Of course, I'm not to big on facebook, twitter or any of that stuff. Our teen is now 16 about to be 17 this month. However, since our daughter is on the high school yearbook staff; it was a requirement for her to have a facebook acct to make it easier to interview students or setup picture meets. So our daughter has a facebook acct now with the exception of she had to friend dad; so dad can always monitor her activity. Do what you feel is right for your daughter; following your instinct never goes wrong.

1 mom found this helpful

My daughter has a FB account so she can keep up with friends from an old school. I do monitor it. When she asked me to load some photos this week, I told her we can but it has to be available to friends only. I also monitor her email.
I recently went into her FB and unfriended 2 boys from school due to their photos--totally inappropriate for their age and their language was just unbelievable. I blocked them so they cannot send a friend request and she cannot add. She did not even realize they had it out there since she does not go on veery often. I would not worry about it if she has not asked.

BTW, I do have a FB account to keep in touch with family but rarely go in unless they send me a message.

1 mom found this helpful

my daughter who is 4 has a fb but only so family can see her grow that is out of state. i ok everyone on her page and if i dont know you personally you dont get added. she goes on there and plays games and i update her page and such. also her page can not be viewed by strangers in any way.

i say that you should talk to your daughter about the facebook and if she wants one set it up for her. have it set up so all the alerts goto your email (that what i have for my daughter) so i can see everything that goes on. you can just lay out the rules. your daughter seems very well mannered and knows what is expected of her. either way its your choice as a parent to decide if your child uses it our not.

1 mom found this helpful