T.W. asks from Fort Worth, TX on August 04, 2009
What Responsibilities Should I Require of My 5 Year Old--and How Much Allowance?
My son is 5 years old and we have decided to assign responsibilities for himself, as well as household duties--chores. What do you/ did you expect of a 5 year old? How should I "reward" or compensate him--allowance? We want to teach him that he has to save his money and spend it wisely, so that we don't end up buying toys all the time--or telling him no every time he asks. We want it to be something he works toward. I am also going to encourage a percentage to go to savings and to the offering at church. If I start him young, maybe he won't have the problems many of us have. Thanks for your help.
1 mom found this helpful
Featured Answers
V.T. answers from Dallas on August 04, 2009
My sister made her kids pay 50% of their allowance to a savings account and 25% to "family taxes". The rest of the money was theirs to spend on what ever they wanted, even toys. Most young kids don't need a lot of money, but they liked being able to buy whatever they wanted and it also taught them to save for bigger items. When they collected enough in family taxes, they did a family activity, bowling, dinner, movies, etc.
R.E. answers from Dallas on August 04, 2009
I've always heard $1 per year of age is the norm for kids in respect to allowance, so 5 years old would be $5. As for chores, my 4 year old can fill the dog's bowl every morning with dog food, make his bed (I smooth the sheets and he puts the pillows and animals on it), put his clothes in the hamper, pick up the dog poop in the backyard (he wanted this chore!), put the silverware on the table at dinner time, and wipe down the toilet in the bathroom with a disposable wipe (again, he wanted this one!). My 7 year old makes his bed, puts clothes in the hamper, puts water in the dog bowls, makes and puts out drinks for dinner, cleans the bathroom counter in his bathroom, cleans the backyard toys, and changes the calendar each day. In addition to those, they both are responsible for keeping their rooms clean and the playroom. Once school starts, I'll probably not make them make their beds, but it's worked this summer. I don't do a weekly allowance, but I made a chart on excel with their chores listed. If they do them, they get a star. Once the chart is filled, I'll pay them accordingly. I also give extra points for doing the chores without being reminded or anything additional like helping daddy in the garden or something.
More Answers
C.T. answers from Dallas on August 05, 2009
My son gets an allowance to teach him how money works. His chores-bed making, picking up toys, cleaning play room, helping bring in groceries-are not tied to his allowance. Those are his responsibilites around the house, like my husband and I have, that we do not get paid for. He receives $5 every Monday and I never take away for misbehavior or not doing his chores. However, if I have to do a chore then he has to pay me as I would have to do with a housekeeper. I remind him of this when he doesn't want to make his bed or clean up and he has never "hired" me to do these things. I wish he would give some money to the church, but at his age he just doesn't want to, so we do not insist on it. Giving to a church or charity should come from the heart. No one should be made to give to these organizations, in our opinion. He is required to save some and he can spend some. He may spend $1, 2 or 3 each week and the rest goes into savings. It is his decision how much he spends on a toy or candy or pack of gum, but it can't be more than $3. If we go on a trip or somewhere special, then he can take $5-10 from savings to buy something from wherever we visit. He usually buys something small and always has money left over. There are lots of things I want to teach him about money, but at 5, I think keeping it simple is best and if I feel he is making a mistake, I try to keep quiet and let him make it. Better now than later. Good luck!!
1 mom found this helpful
C.H. answers from Dallas on August 05, 2009
My daughter is 6, and we give her $2/week. It doesn't sound like a lot, but she's managed to save to buy herself an iCarly nightshirt (at $14), a Razor scooter (at $24), and a toy guitar (at $36...she had some birthday money help with that one), and a KidsBop CD (at $9). She's very good about putting her money in her wallet and keeping it there until there's something she really wants. She's talked about spending it on things like ice cream and candy, but she ends up keeping it until she can afford something big. I would say to figure out what you guys can afford and how much you think your son needs to buy some things he'd want.
As for chores, we're still trying to figure out something that's just her own. I'm liking the vacuum idea. Right now, she's in charge of her room--keeping it picked up, making the bed, etc. She and her brother pick up toys, take their dishes to the sink, etc. However, those things relate more to picking up her own messes. We've discussed with her that she needs to contribute to family chores, too.
R.E. answers from Dallas on August 04, 2009
I've always heard $1 per year of age is the norm for kids in respect to allowance, so 5 years old would be $5. As for chores, my 4 year old can fill the dog's bowl every morning with dog food, make his bed (I smooth the sheets and he puts the pillows and animals on it), put his clothes in the hamper, pick up the dog poop in the backyard (he wanted this chore!), put the silverware on the table at dinner time, and wipe down the toilet in the bathroom with a disposable wipe (again, he wanted this one!). My 7 year old makes his bed, puts clothes in the hamper, puts water in the dog bowls, makes and puts out drinks for dinner, cleans the bathroom counter in his bathroom, cleans the backyard toys, and changes the calendar each day. In addition to those, they both are responsible for keeping their rooms clean and the playroom. Once school starts, I'll probably not make them make their beds, but it's worked this summer. I don't do a weekly allowance, but I made a chart on excel with their chores listed. If they do them, they get a star. Once the chart is filled, I'll pay them accordingly. I also give extra points for doing the chores without being reminded or anything additional like helping daddy in the garden or something.
V.T. answers from Dallas on August 04, 2009
My sister made her kids pay 50% of their allowance to a savings account and 25% to "family taxes". The rest of the money was theirs to spend on what ever they wanted, even toys. Most young kids don't need a lot of money, but they liked being able to buy whatever they wanted and it also taught them to save for bigger items. When they collected enough in family taxes, they did a family activity, bowling, dinner, movies, etc.
K.F. answers from Dallas on August 05, 2009
I have a 6 year old and there are MANY things she can do - even putting clean sheets on her bed and vaccuum although those chores aren't every week. She gets $1 per day allowance (and we pay her daily IF her chores are done and she's been helpful, if they aren't done, no money that day). I always liked the $1 per year rule but paying daily just works so much better for us. Also, I encourage her to put some in save, some in spend, and some in give. I let her choose how much goes in each and it works really well. It gives her control while still teaching her to save and give. (BTW, I have given her incentives of offering her extra to do some jobs that she thinks are too hard - then once she sees that she can do them, it gives her a great sense of accomplishment and next time I don't have to pay her extra :-)) Good lulck!
T.F. answers from Dallas on August 04, 2009
Kudos to you for teaching delayed gratification!!!
Our daughter is 14 now and in reality, never really had a " set chore system". She does get an allowance weekly. At this point, she has such a busy, tough schedule at school, her " job" is to focus at school and maintain her honors, orchestra and cheer.
With the $ we give her weekly.... She is in charge of buying her clothing. I'll say.... It is amazing at how frugal she becomes when the $$$ is coming out of her pocket vs mine!!! I was surprised at how many times she decided to spend her $ on clothes vs movies this summer!!
We do give a bonus, especially now, to get new school clothes, etc.
You are on the right track. No specific advice from me except let the children decide what is so important to themto have. Then when it comes time to pay out.... They ( at least mine) chooses to make a better decision.
Good job for starting the understanding of $$ early.
P.W. answers from Dallas on August 06, 2009
This is what we did. We gave a weekly allowance. Each child received their age. A five year old would receive $5 per week......but 10% went towards a charitable contribution of their choice. 30% went to savings account. 30% went towards saving for something special and 30% was mad money they could have any time they wanted it for whatever they wanted...within reason of course. I kept this in a notebook so that they could see it grow. If he saves his 10% for charity all year then he can adopt an Angel at christmas, etc... it can really be great and empowering.
The great thing about this is that you can actually save money. For example if you are in the grocery store and your son asks for something, then you can say "I don't want to spend my money on that, but you can spend your money." You will be amazed at what your son suddenly no longer needs to have when it isn't on your dime. He may run out of money in the beginning, but then he will see the value of holding off for what he really wants.
We did not equate the allowance to chores. At five, straightening up after himself, taking dishes to the sink....we were okay with that.
Best of Luck in what you decide,
P.
L.R. answers from Dallas on August 05, 2009
I found a great magnetic chore/responsibility chart from Melissa & Doug on line. Shop around for the best price on line. I have my 3 & 4 yr old doing chores such as...making their bed, brushing their teeth, cleaning off the table, picking up toys, and my favorite is Helping Momma (which can be just about anything from helping me sweep to putting away their clothes.)
I've set up 3 glass jars for each of them. A give, a save, and a spend. They are each saving for a special toy and my daughter has decided she wants some of the give money to go to an orphan we support. With the glass jars they can easily see their money "grow."
For your son's age I would suggest between 4-5$ a week if you can afford that. If not, do what you can afford. I go to the bank and get a pile of 1$ bills and quarters each month. If all of the chores are completed each week they get their full allowance, but if not, they loose about a quarter per responsibility missed.
It has been very encouraging for my children, as well as a great way to teach our children about our money beliefs. Especially as it concerns giving and saving. It really just opens alot of doors for conversations revolving around their earnings.
Email