J.C. asks from Las Vegas, NV on November 09, 2007
What Can I Do and How ?
I am a 23 Year old Mother of a three year old and married for 4 years , my husband is not around so it's just me and my son. well i have been battling with trying to potty train my son, we have used the potty together, wear pullup , ask him to tell me when he has to go(he doesnt), sing songs on the potty, showed him briefs and told him he doesnt have to wear pull-ups or diapers anymore, but he seems comfortable , i know boys are not the easiest to potty train, i have younger brothers that i had to help potty train with my mom. He started doing alot of things early, (like started walking a 7 mths), And has this thing were he wants to do things by hisself . Please if anyone is out there that can help with this issue i am having trying to get him to start using the potty.
Featured Answers
J.B. answers from Denver on November 11, 2007
I agree with the others - it doesn't sound like he's ready yet, and all the pushing may create problems down the road. I'd give it a break for a few weeks, then try again. from what I've heard about boys, when they are ready, it happens pretty fast, but they tend to be "ready" later
More Answers
A.J. answers from Reno on November 10, 2007
I've always heard you can't potty train a child until they are ready. If you push it they just resist all the more. But some ideas that have worked with me are as follows.
1. make a little chart and put it on the fridge. Every time he goes in the toilet cheer him on unbelievably and then go put a star on the chart. Tell him once the chart is full he can have a surprise. Now that can be you getting him a toy, or getting several small things he would like and letting him choose out of a box everytime he completes a chart.
2. Another thing that worked for my friend is that they would put their kitchen timer on and every 30minutes the child would hear it and they would say "ok potty time" and march off to the toilet. Try to make it as fun as possible. Maybe sing following the leader from Peter Pan or something.
3. If he has any friends around his age that use a potty ask the mother if he could watch them use the potty. They love to do what their peers do. My 2 year old started potty training herself before she hit 2 because she always watched her older sister.(My 2 year old is not potty trained yet by the way and is a girl)
Maybe all these things together can work. Their is also a book I think it's called a potty party where they tell you how to do it in a day given the child is ready. My sister got me the book when my daughter turned 3 but I barely started it when it started clicking with my daughter, so I never read it.
Hope this helps
A.
J.E. answers from Phoenix on November 09, 2007
It really is hard my 3 yr old did it on his own they are pretty stubborn but eventually will do it you just have to be patient and dont tell him he has to do it because he will do the opposite of what you say.I had bought him his favorite briefs and had some accidents here and there but my son is a clean freak and he noticed ever time he did that his undies were getting dirty so he would just run to the bathroom himself.My girlfriend told her son who is in love with girls that girls like boys when they wear underwear and go to the bathroom and he did it so try that :)
K.N. answers from Denver on November 09, 2007
Give it time----He's only going to do it when he's ready. My son was 4 1/2 before he figured it out. When I was initially concerned, my pediatrician said for some boys it can take until their 7th B-day to fully master urine and BMs. If you stress it too much, you are both frustrated, going nowhere and he feels like he is letting you down. "Once Upon a Potty" is a gender specific book and movie that I used to get the idea across but, again, it was only successful when BOTH of us were willing participants to the process.
Best wishes.
L. answers from Denver on November 09, 2007
Boys are harder usually because it mom doing most of the work. If you can get dad (have dad take him the bathroom when he's going to get the idea) to help when he at home, it may progress a little better.
A. answers from Albuquerque on November 10, 2007
You've mentioned all you've done, but not if HE seems ready? Is he showing any signs of readiness? Does he indicate when he's gone? Is he uncomfortable in dirty pants? If not, he may not be ready. If you really feel he is ready (not just that you want him to be!), try getting him around peers who are trained and he might be motivated if he sees them. Also, don't use pullups. Either keep him in diapers, b/c that's what pullups are, or put him in underwear and let him wet himself, at least at home. If kids can't feel uncomfortable and wet, what motivation is there to stay dry?! Try reusable training pants instead.
Do not make it a battle! Good luck!
K.N. answers from Denver on November 10, 2007
I pottytrained both of my boys at around 2-1/2 (one was 2yrs6mos and the other 2yrs 8mos). Both went straight from diapers to underwear. I just told them, there are no more diapers today, you get to go on the potty like daddy. They had a little piece of candy from the "treasure box" for going- something small for a pee and something they liked better for a poo (i.e. a small tootsie roll). Then they also had a reward sticker chart- 1 sticker for "trying" without success, 2 stickers for a pee, and 5 stickers (stars) for a poo. Once they filled the entire chart, they would receive the present that was sitting on the top of the fridge. By the time we got the chart filled (about a week) they were both totally day-time potty trained. You have to negotiate the nap time to fit with right after they have peed for max success and no accidents. At night I would put back on a diaper (they would cry b/c they didn't want it) but then I would put their big boy underwear over the top. Limit fluids after 5pm.
My first son was potty trained in 3 days and the second was potty trained in 1 week. The first didn't have an accident overnight right from the start, and the second was night trained in about 3 weeks.
I think part of it is that they need to be ready, but also that YOU need to be ready---ready to take the time to watch them constantly, stay home for a few days, etc. but if you can do it this way it goes much more quickly! Good luck! Oh, and by the way, they aren't ever going to tell you at first that they have to go... just set the timer and take him every 20 minutes until he goes. If he does go, then you could give him maybe another 30 minutes until taking him again. After even the first day or two you won't have to take him nearly as often because after a few successes he will start "holding it" without even knowing it. good luck!
J.B. answers from Denver on November 11, 2007
I agree with the others - it doesn't sound like he's ready yet, and all the pushing may create problems down the road. I'd give it a break for a few weeks, then try again. from what I've heard about boys, when they are ready, it happens pretty fast, but they tend to be "ready" later
J.D. answers from Las Vegas on November 10, 2007
with my youngest son we tried for a whole year!! We did stickers, potty parties, books, fancy potty seats, singing, playing, puppets and my husband showing our son what to "do". Nothing worked !!
Then finally (FINALLY!!) he went by himself. And it wasn't our magic tricks or juggling acts, he went because he was ready too. He was also nearly four, so after a year of pulling our hair out, horrid accidents (and oh my gosh we have some absolutely HORRIBLE stories, mostly involving a public place, far from our car or any sort of public toilet, and a complete lack of wipes, tissues or anything useful)
Basically, if nothing works, perhaps just give him a few weeks, then try again, but try not to make it a miserable experience for you. And I find girls to be heaven sent in terms of potty training to my boys.
Good luck :)
Email