R.L. asks from West Hills, CA on October 14, 2010
Value of College Preview Day Visits
Hi Mamas of high-academic teens,
I have several questions for you:
1. Did you take your son or daughter go to any college preview days in their senior year?
2. If so, was it helpful in terms of them making a decision about school choice, and also in terms of the schools recognizing their interest, and maybe giving them an edge for acceptance?
3. Instead of going to preview days, did you wait to visit schools until after acceptances were received?
4. If you did both, do you think one approach was more or less helpful than the other?
My DD (a senior) is very interested in programs offered at UCSC and UOP, although she really has her heart set on going to Yale, Vanderbilt, or Northwestern. Even though she's in the top 5% of her class, her GPA is only 3.96 (weighted: valedictorian has a 4.5!) and she only scored an 1820 on her first SAT and 670 on both of her SAT II's, so Yale, Vanderbilt, and NU are definitely stretch schools: we see UCSC as her prime safety school (plus it's ranked 6th in the country in Global Econ) and UOP as either a safety or mid-range school, and, given our limited economic means, where she is most likely to end up. (This is not to brag. If you have teens like this, you know how important this info is in looking for colleges and making decisions!)
Both UCSC and UOP are offering a preview day in the next few weeks, but both of the days conflict with dance team competitions. As smart as she is, I cannot seem to get her to understand that her priority right now should be her college search and application process (and of course, her school work!), and NOT the dance team! She's not planning on a career in dance -- it's a hobby. She wants to pursue international business and global economics.
I know she works very hard, and I know she wants to have some time for fun (which she deserves), but her team participation is getting in the way of a lot of what I see as far more important activities right now. I'm almost to the point of making her quit the team for the fall, but I don't think that's going to be very effective, plus it wouldn't look very good on her applications. She knows this and plays it against my advice, but honestly, 3.5 - 4 hrs/day of practice is ridiculous on top of 4 APs and a required elective. I can't tell you how frustrated I am with her right now! We usually have a very solid relationship, but the last few nights have devolved into yelling matches that aren't helping anyone. The coach is no help -- she wants all of the team members there all the time so that SHE can win competitions, even though she claims "academics first." Most of the girls on the team are not highly academic, and none of them has my daughter's work load.
I know I should probably back off and let my daughter make her own decisions for better or worse on this issue, but she has so much potential, I hate to see her throw away good opportunities. So, in addition to the 4 questions above I have one more -- any advice? Actually, make that two more -- how did you go about helping your teen find safety and mid-range schools? The Fiske Guide seems to have mostly top schools listed in it, and using the Princeton Review search engine hasn't pulled up anything that looks particularly interesting.
1 mom found this helpful
So What Happened?™
I want to thank all of the mamas, coaches, and high school counselors for your sage advice! My husband, daughter, and I had a nice, calm family meeting on Saturday. I apologized to her for being so heavy-handed in my insistence that she attend two upcoming preview days, and explained to her why I was so concerned. I told her about the advice I received from everyone here, and asked her to think about what help she felt she needed/wanted from us in her college search. She asked to read the comments, so I let her.
Later in the day, we regrouped and decided to take a flexible approach, led by her suggestions. Since Laura is so overwhelmed with schoolwork and team activities, my husband and I agreed to do as much preliminary footwork as possible to find safety and mid-range schools that might interest her (also, scholarships). Once she's looked at the programs and each school's application process, if she thinks she wants to see the school before deciding to apply, we will make every effort to do so within the constraints of time and budget. If we can't get to a campus physically, she's found that she can email college department offices directly and get good information beyond what's on the website about majors she's interested in (plus, the advisers will also get an opportunity to see that she's really interested in their school and program). Also, there are a lot of schools that will have live chats available through CollegeWeekLive.com that she will participate in depending on her level of interest and time. We'll forego visits to any school that she's going to apply to regardless until after acceptances have been received. She's visited a few campuses already (that she had no interest in) with a friend, and noted that it doesn't really matter whether or not classes are in session -- she feels she can still get a good enough feel, since there are always students around-- so we will try to visit several CA schools over winter break. Since I have to work and my DH is at home, they will probably go on many of these tours without me, which is probably a good thing! All-in-all, I think a very reasonable compromise.
I want to pass on one of her comments which I felt was particularly interesting. She feels like she and her classmates who are serious about academics and college attendance are, in a perverse way, penalized by the entire process. Because they are so loaded down with homework and activities necessary to be attractive to top schools, they have much less time available to research schools and visit campuses. I wish there were a good way to address this!
Featured Answers
S.L. answers from New York on October 14, 2010
Colleges look at so much more than grades. My daughter was accepted everywhere she applied and we can only guess it was based on her essay because friends with higher GPA's and sports stars weren't accepted. We visited schools which helped her get an idea of what setting she wanted but in the end she chose a school we didnt attend an open house. so just visit when it works in her schedule!
4 moms found this helpful
More Answers
J.E. answers from Tucson on October 14, 2010
I know that dance is not as important as college but I also know that this is the time in her life that she has the time and energy to pursue a passion without the restraints of adult responsibilities. As a competitive cheer coach, I also know that when a performer is missing often the entire routine has to be reworked which is frustrating for the team. If the coach communicated the dates with you at the beginning of the season then the expectation is that she fulfill the obligation to her team. Just a viewpoint from the other side of the bench...best of luck to her in her endeavors.
5 moms found this helpful
M.K. answers from Stationed Overseas on October 14, 2010
If you have the opportunity to go and visit any of the schools go. In my own experience I visited several different schools that I was applying to. A few I said no way once I got on campus and got the tour. One stood out for me, felt good, talking to actual students and teachers helped so much and really made a difference in my choice. I don't think I could have made the decision by just looking at pictures and reading about them online. I do agree with the other moms I think you might need to back off a bit. She's going to have to realize on her own what she can handle and what she can't. She's going to be doing it in a year anyways on her own. And forcing her to quit a team sport might really damage your relationship.
5 moms found this helpful
S.L. answers from New York on October 14, 2010
Colleges look at so much more than grades. My daughter was accepted everywhere she applied and we can only guess it was based on her essay because friends with higher GPA's and sports stars weren't accepted. We visited schools which helped her get an idea of what setting she wanted but in the end she chose a school we didnt attend an open house. so just visit when it works in her schedule!
4 moms found this helpful
S.B. answers from Dallas on October 14, 2010
Yes, we took my son on visits to several of his top schools during the summer prior to his senior year and during school (they were allowed 2 days off for documented college visits). We didn't attend previews days, but called ahead and made an appointment at the admissions office and asked for a tour of the campus. At the second college, he found everything he was looking for and was ready to apply. We visited a third campus he expressed interest in earlier just to make sure that it wasn't better than the #2 visit. It reinforced his interest in attending campus #2 visit and he successfully graduated and then earned an MBA.
Ok, now on Team Dance competitions--if your daughter has made a commitment to participate, then she needs to attend unless there are many subs. Otherwise, the rest of her dance squad will miss her participation in events.
Mom, she is growing up and will have to make a lot of decisions on her own. Offer guidance and support, but let her take the lead on which schools she wants to visit. If you have limited finances, help her put together a list of schools (even some stretch schools-both academically & financially) and let her research them before scheduling a visit. Many school districts have college nights and have representatives from many colleges on hand to answer questions and to recruit highly respected students. Check into these opportunities.
4 moms found this helpful
L.A. answers from Austin on October 14, 2010
Ok after speaking with lots of moms at our daughters school and our situation.We had a. very busy fall.. We decided to have our daughter apply to the colleges she was most interested in and wait until her acceptance letters arrived.. I had her apply to "Pie in sky" dream schools too..
She applied to 9 and was accepted to all 9.. These letters did not arrive until after the new year.. 1 arrived at the end of Jan. Many came in March and early April.
This way we could look at what they all offered her financially.
Then she made a list in order of where she wanted to attend and once again we looked at the offers..
We then plotted out special events these colleges were holding for accepted students and started making trips to these different events.
One trip we saw 2 colleges in the Atlanta area.
One weekend we drove to San Antonio to see another campus.
Then we took a trip to see 2 colleges up East.
So we saw 5 and in this time she found her perfect match.
I was beginning to get worried and thought wow are we really going to end up looking at all 9? But the moms that had advised me kept saying.. She will know it the moment she is there and you will too.
Our daughter does NOT LIKE to be pushed.She shuts down and will become mute if I push too much. . so I held my tongue so much, I thought I would choke..
I would hold back and let her lead the visits. I asked mom type questions and let her ask student type things she was concerned about or wanted to to know about.. These trips were great.. She began to feel like I was really on her team and I was getting an idea of exactly what she was looking for.
A few of the trips included interviews for the Presidential Scholarships she had been awarded, because they also qualified her for other scholarships available at these colleges. These are the trips that were the most stressful, because our daughter is painfully shy.
What I did at each college we visited was at the end of the visit I asked her, "Would you like to purchase a tshirt?" She always answered "no, thank you"..
At her "Pie in the sky school" I asked her would you like to purchase a tshirt? She said "Yes, I want a shirt.. But I actually want to attend.. the last school we saw."
I was thrilled. I KNEW that the school she had chosen was so perfect for her.. And we would not have to visit any more campus's. I was worried she was going to run out and just settle on one.. .
I hope this helped.. you can message me any time for any more info..
L. A.
3 moms found this helpful
T.N. answers from Albany on October 14, 2010
Hi R., I would say AIM HIGH! And yes have at least one safety.
With an 1800+ on her SATs she will be getting MANY MANY offers of short application process. My son had the same score, he got many offers for no application fee, essay waived, automatic consideration for Honors Program, just sign on the dotted line (interpretation, PLEASE bring your huge scores and giant SATs to our school!)
He applied to mostly mid-range schools, RPI, MIT, Drexel, (not sure if that means anything to you on the west coast), Clarkson, and 2 state schools. He was offered a substancial Merit Scholarship to all except RPI (pssht).
WE had planned to visit the ALL of the campuses if only for the day, until we spent a weekend at the RIT campus. With their outstanding Engineering programs, co-op programs in mind, the campus itself was PERFECT for my exceptionally bright, very focused son with, uh, somewhat challenged social skills.
After we started receiving the offers, I wished we'd aimed higher, as a general rule the merit scholarships were larger with the more expensive schools.
Still I did not want him beyond driving distance, we would not have the money to be flying back and forth.
As far as the dance comp is concerned, colleges look at involvement outside of academics as well, it shows commitment to be a competive dancer, and involvement, and leadership.
Most schools offer private tours anyway, which can actually be MORE informative the open house type visits.
Don't stress too much, as long as her grades stay up, she still has a little time to narrow it down to 5 or 7.
It's more about who's got the best program for what she's into, you know? And the 'feel' for the campus.
The MOST important thing for her college success is HER perception that she is in the RIGHT place for her, that SHE decided (even if you don't agree)
It very overwhelming isn't it? I just got one off a month ago, and I also have a junior so I have to get started on that one right away.
In the end, SHE needs to be happy with her own decisions.
Go for the GOLD!!!
3 moms found this helpful
S.W. answers from Amarillo on October 14, 2010
Mine didn't go to college but you might have to back off a bit. She is trying to decide what is important to her which might not be to you. This is her life and she must make the ultimate decision.
Visiting a campus lets you see the campus layout and where all the buildings are located and well as the surrounding town/cities. Some cities have a vibe that you know is a campus town and others where I am don't. The education is important but so is the area in which she will live -- on campus in dorm, apartments -- or downtown and such and the security issues. Will she need a car to get around or can she walk or take a bus?
Yes, we mothers all see what our child can be but it is the child that must also see and believe on their own what they can be. Shouting matches get nowhere except anger and frustration on both sides. As one poster said her daughter shuts down and won't speak. Do you want this to happen with you and your daughter? What does she want to do? Will it be relevant in the next 5 to 10 years? A few other questions to ask you both. Don't compare your daughter to the other members of the drill/dance team and their academic abilities. Be proud of her that she has gotten this far in life and has not had any screw ups.
It's a big step and leaving the nest. The best to her and momma, take a big deep breath, it will be alright in the end.
The other S.
PS Once she gets to college on her own there will be another change in your relationship for better or for worse. A former co-worker is going through this right now with her daughter who is 400 miles away from home.
3 moms found this helpful
D.B. answers from Charlotte on October 14, 2010
R., I'm in the middle of this with my son too. I'll tell you what I've found so far. The college campus visits have been VERY helpful. My son knows whether he feels comfortable or not, I know whether what I hear from the people speaking makes sense for my son, and being able to drop a school before applying saves a lot of time and effort in the app process, since many of these schools require an additional essay in addition to the one accompanying the Common App.
There ARE things you can determine before traveling to the schools you're interested in: since she wants to major in Business, find out if the colleges she is looking at have business departments she can get into by virtue of the fact that she is admitted into the college at large, OR will she have to apply to their business school her sophomore year, having to compete against other candidates. That is what my son wants to avoid, because he is partly choosing the colleges he's applying to BECAUSE of their business program. It would be a real disappointment to find out that he can't major in business there because there are too many applicants to compete against and misses getting a space. He'd either have to change his major or transfer to another school.
I recommend reading with your daughter the book "Colleges That Save Lives" by Pope. It details 40 colleges - my son is interested in 3 of them.
The college essay is one of the most important things she has to do - get some advice about what she writes from someone who has some experience with writing (like an English teacher). Get her to type out a "resume" to help her fill out her Common Ap - it collesces it all in her mind and helps her not to forget what she has done. Read tips about how much to include in the app if she has tons of stuff - there are some things they don't want to hear about.
You mention whether or not to let her work on this on her own, but the truth is, it depends on your daughter's personality. It sounds like she isn't gung-ho about doing it on her own - neither is my son. He depends on me and my husband to guide him. I have helped sift through colleges, but don't want to tell him which school to pick. Either he'll go to it because I said so, or NOT go to it just because I like it. Not sure which LOL! Anyway, I recommend staying with the process so that you know that the apps get sent in, the recommendation letters get to the schools, the transcripts are received; you want to make sure nothing falls through the cracks.
Regarding her dance, really and truly, you don't have to go to the open houses on THEIR dates. You can just set up a visit. That's what we have done with several of our visits. She shouldn't miss the dance competitions. You say these aren't academic, but what you don't see is that they are VERY important to the colleges she is looking at. They want to see this kind of activity, showing that she is multi-faceted and well-rounded. Dropping this activity during her senior year would be a mistake that would cost her a stretch school. If you don't believe me, just ask an admissions officer, without giving your name. They'll be honest.
She makes good grades. She is a good student and a good kid. Let her enjoy her senior year. Don't be a helicopter parent (that's what the schools call parents who try to call all the shots.) Do stand by her and make sure all the deadlines are met and that she keeps organized. This is a daunting process for student and parents. My husband will have to be the one to work on the financial aid part. After all the application process is finished, I AM DONE with my part! Then it's his turn with the tax forms and the money stuff! Whew!!!! And it will be my son's job to keep his grades up, and when he hears from the colleges in the spring, to make his decision along with an understanding of the costs for each school. (Hopefully we'll get some financial help!)
Good luck, and all my best to both of you,
D.
2 moms found this helpful
Email