L.C. asks from Virginia Beach, VA on September 13, 2008
Too Much TV
This is going to sound bad, and that's because I know it is. But my 3 year old daughter watches entirely too much TV. Between 8-12 hours a day. I know that sounds horrible, but here's the situation. My husband works full time. I work part time, but I also go to school full time. We absolutly can not afford day care of any kind, so I go to school online from home so that I can be here with my daughter. But my school work takes up easily 8-9 hours a day (like I said, full time) for class work and homework. It is very hard for me to manage my time to even deal with my daughters basic needs like meals when I am trying to do school work. I don't have the time to sit and play tea party or to get out of the house and go to the park. We try to be much more involved on the weekends, but honestly after my husband has worked all week, all he wants to do is sit in front of his computer on the weekends, which I understand because sometimes I need to unwind from my week too. But because of all of this, my daughter watches TV just about all day while I am working. I do the best I can, and restrict her to educational shows, which she loves, and has really learned a lot from. But my question is, are there any activities I can use to entertain/stimulate my daughter during the day that require little supervision, so that I can still get my 8-9 hours of school work done every day? I want to get her out from in front of the TV, but I don't know what else to do to keep her occupied so I can work. I don't have time to chase her around the house or let her do messy crafts since I can't watch her every second when I'm working. You all have been a great help in the past, so I'm hoping someone has some ideas that will work for me. Thanks Moms!
P.S. I want to make a side note here, because a lot of people have said that I should put my school work on hold, or back off, but this is not an option for me. Because I was in the Navy, my GI Bill pays for me to go to school, and actually pays me more than working full time. Because of our financial situation, if I quit going to school, or back off, I don't get paid. Then I have to go to work full time, for less money, and still can't afford to put her in day care. So while I agree that school shouldn't be the priority, it really isn't. But getting paid for it is. My husband doesn't make enough to support me not working, so I have to make money some how. That means either working full time and paying for day care (which we tried and almost lost our house), or going to school full time, and getting paid for that.
1 mom found this helpful
Featured Answers
L.B. answers from Washington DC on September 16, 2008
I know how you feel!! I used to swear I wouldn't let my kids watch a lot of TV, but yikes! They took in a lot! Have you thought about getting some special coloring books/activity books, or even downloading printouts from the internet? You could set up a little desk or table next to the computer desk and she could have "school" when you do!
More Answers
S.R. answers from Richmond on September 16, 2008
L.,
I am a mother and grandmother and I must admit that I was saddened to think of your daughter sitting in front of the TV all day alone. I know you are in the same house, and you say you want to spend time with your daughter, but it sounds like she is alone. I understand the fear of financial loss, I understand how important it is to get an education and to provide a good home for your daughter. Do you understand that she is only going to be a child for such a short time. Now is when she needs you most. She needs you to spend time with her. Children learn so much at this age, you want her to learn from you, not a TV program. Educational programs are great, but they do not replace Mom. I assume there is no family that can help provide day care. What about a friend or someone from your church. If you cannot spend time with your daughter,then she deserves to at least have some other caring adult providing care.
I can tell that you care about this and that it is weighing heavy on your mind or you would not have bothered to ask for help. I do not know anything about your financial situation. Sometimes we feel that we must provide a certain standard of living, (nice house, nice car, nice clothes etc). Perhaps you and your husband have set your expectations too high for right now. You say that even the weekends are time for you and your husband to unwind, so when does your daughter get the love and attention that she deserves?
We all make choices in our lives, every day, some of them can be life changing. The decision you make will impact your daughter for the rest of her life. Make sure you choose wisely.
2 moms found this helpful
A.S. answers from Washington DC on September 15, 2008
Hi L.,
I just want to start by saying I sympathize with your situation. I hope that among the criticism and hopefully helpful suggestions that you find what you are looking for. Sometimes "you gotta do what you gotta do."
I am married and have a two year old daughter. I have been home with her this entire time, but will be putting her into full-time childcare/school at the end of the month. I have re-started my doctorate work recently with two courses one day a week and will be working full-time outside the home in addition to that.
I understand that childcare is not an option for you, but there are definitely several non-television options that I would suggest. At three years old I would think that your daughter can entertain herself for longer periods of time. My daughter is 2-years old and does a pretty good job of it. I would just make sure that you are stocked with different interactive options. My daughter's toy collections include lots of coloring books/crayons, building materials, pretend play options (i.e. tea sets, kitchen, costumes), stuffed animals/dolls, paints, kid-friendly music cds,books (including audio, interactive books). My daughter has a castle/tunnel system in her room that gives her physical exercise going through and around it. It also serves as a sort of clubhouse she retreats to with her favorite toys.
I would try to introduce new books and/or a toy regularly to keep her collection fresh and interesting. It doesn't have to be expensive. My daughter loves stickers, so I always keep a constant stash of stickers that are associated with books and learning skills much of the time. If you can arrange your schedule maybe you can dedicate some time at least once a week where you are taking your daughter to a kid friendly event like storytime at the library,bookstores, some coffee shops or even your local Whole Foods offer these events for free, museums (sometimes free), the park, or a class of some sort if you can afford it (i.e. gymnastics, gymboree, swimming, etc.). A website you can check for free activities happening in your area is gocitykids.com.
I would dedicate a short amount of time to her favorite television shows, maybe an hour to an hour and a half, which is about 3 shows or so, or maybe one movie. Aside from that I think spousal support is ESSENTIAL.
I am balancing my situation by dedicating evenings after my daughter is asleep and weekends to focus on my school work. I understand that I have to schedule time for my entire family together so I make sure that I am carving out time on the weekends where we are all doing something together. It's usually a few hours on either Saturday or Sunday, but not both days and dinnertime of course. I know that my husband is tired at the end of the day and I am as well having spent the entire day with my daughter and working on school work, but your husband is an essential part of making your current situation work.
2 moms found this helpful
A.B. answers from Washington DC on September 15, 2008
This is a very difficult situation, one that many parents are facing daily, unfortunately. The irony is you chose online courses full-time so you could be with your wonderful daughter, but, you're not with her. You wrote that going to school part-time is not an option as it effects your pay, right? Do you have access to relatives or affordable daycare providers who can watch your daughter during the daytime? No? Then, you might have to sacrifice the cleanliness of the home if you really want to cut down the television time. You can do crafts at home by getting an old sheet or blanket that you can place on the floor before she starts working. Finger paints, Wonderpaint and Wonder markers by Crayola (no-mess) are great!! You must use the special paper for the Wonderpaint and Wonder markers, though. Drawing? No mess. If she's been watching educational shows, maybe you can have her write her letters, make up her own stories, and/or practice spelling three- or four-letter words she heard on a program. Playdough is also not too messy. Use cookie cutters to make shapes from playdough. Teach her to clean up after herself. Another suggestion, Legos. Believe it or not, some girls enjoy Lego sets. Visit the store in Tysons Corner or Potomac Mills for girl sets. Coloring books, sticker books, scissor projects online, and easy-reader books should take care of your morning time. Plan to take breaks (not just for her, but also for yourself) to go on a walk with her, pointing out various leaves, rocks, and insects along the way. Spend maybe 30 minutes having a tea party and then cuddle with her and a good book. That's 2 hours. Show her how to set the table for the tea, and then let her practice it. Use pots and pans to let her pretend to cook while she's sitting beside you. Add to this music on the radio, books on tape, and possibly dress up outfits, and that might help some. But, if there's not even 1-2 hours in the day, you really should re-evaluate the plan. Yes, you get more pay, but you might be sacrificing the relationship and educational needs of your daughter in the process. Fathers tend to make that choice, but it's so much harder for Mom to do that. If it's really that hard to focus and make time for her during school hours, you might have to shop around more and see if there are any pre-school programs, like HeadStart or daycare options if you fit the financial profile. She might fare better at daycare until you are finished with school or can at least get through this semester.
2 moms found this helpful
J.F. answers from Richmond on September 15, 2008
Wow, do you have your hands full. I've been the sahm. I've been the single mom working full time AND studying. It's all tough no matter what you do. First off, dad needs to spend less time vegging on the weekends. Period. Not to say he shouldn't get his down time, but there are things he can do during the weekend that can make things easier for you during the week, like cooking in large batches for your daughter's meals during the week and freezing it so all you have to do is nuke it for a couple of minutes. The time saved preparing meals can be time you spend with her. Also, taking care of other children in your home is a great alternative to working that part time job. Taking care of just 2 other children can earn you enough money to possibly replace the part time job, they will occupy each other for socialization (and no tv) and that time can be spent with your daughter instead of away from home (it's how I managed to quit my part time job to be a full time sahm with my son). Though cutting back on your course work would be your best bet, if that's not an option (it wasn't for me), studying or doing homework at night after your daughter is in bed gives you more time to spend with her and really allows you to concentrate better. As for activities, give her the toys, the coloring and activity books, dress up clothes, whatever, but just simply turn off the tv. She needs to get used to using her imagination, whether she's alone or not. And now is the time to get her to do it. Since she's accustomed to the tv being on all the time, she's going to get bored and probably cranky at first. She'll get over it. Once she realizes she has no choice in the matter, she'll learn to entertain herself more creatively. It'll build character.
Even if you had all the time in the world to spend with her, as a mom, it's not your job to keep her busy and entertained every waking moment, so don't feel bad when you're doing everything you can. And for the love of God, take some time for you, even if it's only an extra five minutes in the shower to meditate. Taking care of you is the best thing you can do for your whole family.
As a final note, I'm rather saddened to see all the moms who sound so critical. We all have our sacrifices to make and no one has the right to judge when they haven't walked in your shoes. Keep your head up, you'll get through this!
1 mom found this helpful
K.B. answers from Washington DC on September 15, 2008
Since I had my son 2 years ago, I have worked from home. At first, it was hard to get him to play independently, but once he knew the routine, it was much easier. Here's what I would advise...only let her watch her very favorite shows. My son watches TV from 11-12. The rest of the time he plays. I have crayons and blank paper. He also has all of his toys in his bedroom. I find that when he comes into the office looking for attention, I do give it to him. It's usually just to talk for a few mins, or help him with a toy, but once he receives my attention, he's good to go and continues playing. Now, the house does get messier this way, but when I am finished working, we clean everything up together, then go outside and play until dinner. The hardest thing is going to be to get your daughter use to playing independently. Try it out on the weekends first. Start out by playing together, then tell her to keep playing while you go the bathroom (or make lunch..whatever it is, just get up and leave her to play alone). Slowly decrease the amount of time you play with her, and make sure you praise her for playing well by herself. Also, I give my son tasks, like can you put all of the marbles into the basket? He loves showing me he can, and usually does it over and over. Your daughter won't need big, extravagant activies, just guidance on how to play by herself. I also find it helps to rotate his toys. I have one toy box in his closet and one out in his room. I swithc them up every few weeks so he doesn't get bored with is toys. I also explain to him, no Mommy is working right now, when I'm finished I can play with you, in a calm voice, so he knows why I can't play with him. Let me know how it goes or if you want more suggestions.
1 mom found this helpful
W.S. answers from Norfolk on September 15, 2008
Since we don't have all your details, we have to guess about some things. Do you work every night at your part time job? Perhaps you can cut back on those hours, do your schoolwork on those nights when your daughter is asleep, and free up some daytime hours for one-on-one with her. Also, what does your husband do when he gets home at night? He should be spending lots of time with her, not on the computer all the time. There will be time for him to do that in 2 or 3 years when she is in kindergarten and you are done with school. If he is as wonderful as you say, you shouldn't have to do much to convince him. I remember from my college days that a full time student was at least 4 classes, so if you are taking more than that, then perhaps you could drop one and still meet the GI Bill criteria? Have you contacted the Navy to see if there is any assistance for you? I know that Navy childcare is based on what you make, so maybe a day or two a week would be feasible. I live not too far from you, and I know that good daycare is not always easy to find, but there are some church-based preschools that allow you to bring your child 3 days a week for half a day, I know because I did that. What about hiring a baby sitter to come to your home a few hours a day, one or two days a week? Maybe there is something you could cut out of your budget (cell phone, reduced cable bill, etc.) that could allow you to send her to a half-day preschool for about the price of tank of gas. I know it must be hard, but she will be past those oh-so-impressionable and moldable years, and you may have missed some golden opportunities to steer her in the right direction, and give her the best earliest memories of the fun you and she had togther. Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
A.K. answers from Norfolk on September 15, 2008
I think you've gotten some good advice. I also think you need to change your priorities. No child should be left to fend for themselves 8-12 hours a day, especially at 3. Excessive television has been linked to obesity. The longer she spends watching television this way the harder it will be to break her of the habit later. You need to think about what you are working so hard for. If it is to give your daughter a better life, than I think it should start now. She will care more about the time you spend with her than any material things you will be able to purchase if you finish school & get a high paying job. Excessive television also promotes materialism. Your daughter is being bombarded all day by commercials for toys & crappy food.
I don't think that you should quit school & start again later. Right now you are in the swing of things & it is hard to start back up after you stop completely. I do think that you need to cut back to part-time & then do your school work early in the morning or after your daughter is in bed. You need to look forward and see what you project your life to be in a couple of years. Will you be working full time & your daughter in school/daycare all day? Will you finish school & then spend time with her? When will she be the priority? It sounds like you have the financial means to make her the priority now. I don't know how much you pay for your classes each semester, but could it be enough to put her in preschool for the mornings while you work on your school work (part time classes) and then you would have the afternoon free to focus on her?
I don't think taking another child in would be a good idea. I would never want my daycare provider to put my child in front of the tv all day. It sounds like your daughter is well behaved & doesn't tear up the house. There is no guarantee that another 3 year old would have the same temperament. I think you'd be doing someone a disservice.
I know that this is probably not what you want to hear. I looked at your previous posts & you mentioned that you are a Buddhist. I have been interested in buddhism for awhile and one of the principles that speaks to me is mindfulness--living consciously in the moment, bringing awareness to all aspects of your life. You don't seem to be applying mindfulness to your daughter. Are you making her life better by mindful living? You need to accept the reality of what is in front of you. It is obvious that you are uncomfortable with the current situation.
ETA: I just saw your update that you are getting paid for your schooling (so basically it is your job). Have you thought about moving somewhere where it is cheaper to live? Or maybe moving in with a relative while you finish school so that you can afford to put your daughter in daycare. How big is your house? Maybe you could trade free housing to a single mama who works weekends in return for her watching/entertaining your daughter during the day. You don't say what your husband does. Is it easily transferable to another area? Are there any teenagers in the neighborhood that you could hire to come over after school to play with your daughter?
1 mom found this helpful
J.O. answers from Washington DC on September 15, 2008
I wrote before, but I was thinking about your situation more. I completely forgot the obvious. Tell your husband to get the part time job and quit yours. You've already got 2 full time jobs (school and child rearing). He's not going to want to hear that but, to quote a very bright 7 year old I know, "too bad, so sad." It's time to step up to the plate.
I think it might be our generation to assume that if we're working full time, that's enough. Well, obviously it isn't. My parents weren't educated and were raising 4 kids in the midst of the late 70's early 80's "economic down turn." My Dad was laid off of his living-wage factory job and had to get work which paid significantly less. He could have said, "I've done my 40 (or 50) hrs this week, I should get some me time." But, he didn't he got a full time and a part time job to make up for the lost wages. I realize this may be old fashion thinking, but I think it's the husband's job to step up when needed. It's not like you're sitting around watching soap opras and eating bon bons. You seriously have 2 full time jobs right now and they are both (you didn't say this, but my guess is you aren't doing as well in school as you could be) suffering right now.
1 mom found this helpful
Email