53 answers

To Moms of Only Boys

I have a 4 yo and 1 year old, both boys. Last night I was at a wedding and a woman was commenting on how wonderful the relationship is between a mother and a daughter, after she was watching my mother and I having a conversation filled w/ laughter. I mentioned that I had 2 boys and that I likely would never have a daughter, since my husband and I are probably done having kids. This woman would not let it go. She proceeded to go on and on abt how I needed to have a daughter (and should keep trying until I got a girl) because there is nothing better than the bond between a mother and her daughter. This woman has 3 adult children, 2 girls, 1 boy.
I was so offended by this conversation, it brought me to tears. I love my boys w/ all my heart and would never change them for anything. At the same time, pre-children, I always wanted a girl. Part of me still does and gets sad thinking that I will likely never have a daugther. I'm just curious if any of you moms with only boys ever get comments like this one that I received last night? How do you respond? It seems like often I hear comments from people like "are you going to try for your girl?" or "oooh, 2 boys? good luck w/ that?" It's like people place girls on a pedestal and that your life is not complete if you do not have a daugther.

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

"Actually, I was hoping for 5 or more boys. 10 would have been perfect"

The stunned silence lets me easily exit stage left and find someone who has more on their mind than my vagina.

8 moms found this helpful

Yeah, I got the comments... but now I have a beautiful daughter in law and a beautiful granddaughter.
Don't let those dumb remarks get to you, raising sons is very pleasant and they take good care of their mommas when they get older ;)

5 moms found this helpful

Hah!! I am not close with my mother, but and very close with my dad. There is no guarantee. In fact, I have met MORE girls who butted heads with their mothers, then were close with them.

I have one boy. I don't WANT a girl. I am happy. I am complete. I typically say, "I'd rather have 15 boys, then one girl." It's true, and it shuts them up.

4 moms found this helpful

More Answers

"Actually, I was hoping for 5 or more boys. 10 would have been perfect"

The stunned silence lets me easily exit stage left and find someone who has more on their mind than my vagina.

8 moms found this helpful

I have 3 sons. And 3 daughters. In that order. My youngest son was 4 before I had my first girl. So, I know that odd perspective that you heard. Yes, there can be special bonds between mothers and daughters. They are it guaranteed. I am incredibly close with my sons also. My oldest will be getting married soon. We are so close. We text daily. He shares most everything with me. His future wife shares most everything with me also.mshe is already a daughter to me. I love her so much. If I didn't have a daughter of my own, I would certainly feel like that role is fulfilled in my relationship with her. I've known her for years, and we were close before my son started courting her. So, my point is that you are not necessarily missing out on very close relational bonds just because you don't have a daughter. Make sure your relationships with your sons are close, purpose to love their future wives, and ignore the people who project their own problems on you. We are not cookie cutters of each other in our relationships. We are unique, and we can learn from each other. Ask her what she thinks she did wrong with her son to have the heir relationship not be as close. ;)

7 moms found this helpful

OMG I have one boy and two girls and let me tell you I often wish they were ALL boys!!!
A daughter does not a best friend make.
I am closer to, and have more in common with, my son than either of my girls.
And how stupid is the comment, to "try for a girl?"
Like you have ANY control whatsoever.
Pure ignorance, I'm sorry you have to deal with it :(

7 moms found this helpful

People are the same when a family has all girls, too. I usually just smile and shrug and say something about "the secret to having what you want is wanting what you have!" And if that doesn't work, tell her that that's God's plan for our family. It's hard to argue with God.

I love my three boys and I'm thrilled to be their mom. And our family is complete, no matter what some old biddy says!

7 moms found this helpful

I wouldn't listen to her, or at least take her comments seriously. She has some issues that are her issues not yours.

I know you asked for mothers of only boys, but I had to comment on this. I have one of each. I agree that there is a special bond between mother and daughter, but there is a special bond between mother and son, too. One bond is not better than the other; the bond is just different, not better. She obviously never found that bond with her son that you have and many other mothers have.

The bond between my son and I is very special. He is a Momma's boy and has no qualms admitting it, even at thirteen years old. My bond with my daughter is equally special but different. The difference has more to do with the fact that my children have very different personalities and are different people than the fact that they are a different sex.

Again, I would not worry about women like that. You are happy with your two boys, done having children, and that is all that matters. To be honest, I really feel sorry for her son. If her philosophy is girls are better than boys, then she has sorely short-changed her son.

5 moms found this helpful

Yeah, I got the comments... but now I have a beautiful daughter in law and a beautiful granddaughter.
Don't let those dumb remarks get to you, raising sons is very pleasant and they take good care of their mommas when they get older ;)

5 moms found this helpful

I had a feeling the question was going to be geared in this direction and even though I do not have a boy felt the urge to read it. (So I apologize if it bothers you I answered this)

I am a mom of 2 girls and I get similar comments but about the fact I don't have a boy. I think it doesn't matter what you have, some insensitive person is always going to have something to say.

My mother in law made an offhand comment thank God she never had girls because all the do is whine (after a day of watching my girls). My husband and I were pregnant with our second girl and his friends told him they could not imagine only have girls that they HAD to have a boy. I also get told how horrible girls are to raise and how easier boys are.

So....take the comments with a grain of salt.

4 moms found this helpful

Hah!! I am not close with my mother, but and very close with my dad. There is no guarantee. In fact, I have met MORE girls who butted heads with their mothers, then were close with them.

I have one boy. I don't WANT a girl. I am happy. I am complete. I typically say, "I'd rather have 15 boys, then one girl." It's true, and it shuts them up.

4 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.