C.V. asks from Mason, OH on September 25, 2008
Time for the Sex Talk...
I've recently learned that I may be behind in "the talk" with my 10-year-old daughter. After researching it a bit myself, it seems talking about sex to your children should actually start at around age 8, at least the preliminary discussions. I am behind the curve ball - as I have not talked at all about sex to my daughter, nor has she asked pointed questions. I wanted to see what others' experiences are with the "right" timing, and different approaches in your opinions, how best to initiate the conversation. I bought "Where Did I Come From" and another book called "Asking About Sex and Growing Up" - and have read them. Both seem pretty good, one more basic than the other. I thought maybe we could read them together. My mom drew me diagrams - and I'll never forget it. I have absolutely no issue talking about sex to my daughter - I was just taken aback that sex ed is suggested at such a young age. Any helpful tips on how to initiate the conversation/how much is too much for a 10 year old (homosexuality, masturbation, etc. - all of which are in one of the books) - thanks in advance for the discussion!
So What Happened?™
Wow, I am overwhelmed with such wonderful responses and such a great discussion! Thank you to all of you for your wisdom and guidance. It is very obviously a hot topic among all of us parents. Of course we all want to do the right thing for our children, and while some may believe it is time NOW at age 10 or younger to have the sex talk, others believe it is something that can wait. I think what many of you said is true about following our gut instincts as parents, and sort of honing in on what our child is capable of understanding. No one child is cut from the same mold, and while some can handle specific details, others may not (yet). I also appreciate your advise in making sex ed an ongoing discussion - not a sit-down-once-and-tell-all-and-move-on discussion. That totally makes sense, and that is the theory I will adopt (haven't started yet...). Thank you also for all the book titles/suggestions. I do sort of dread starting the discussion, only because it is another chapter in the life of my child that I don't want to close just yet. It would be nice to keep our children cooped up in their innocence forever - how I wish we could do that - but realistically we cannot. And you are right, I'd rather it come from me than on the bus where it is described as something dirty and scary. Thank you moms! You are wonderful!
Featured Answers
C.S. answers from Cincinnati on September 27, 2008
My daughter and I both really like American Girl's book "The Care and Keeping of Me" I gave it to her when she was about 8. She didn't really start reading in it until she was 9. She's 13 now and we still talk from it because she hasn't started yet. I think you need to start talking to her before her friends do. I do know some 10yo who are well into puberty.
Good luck,
C.
A.L. answers from Dayton on September 26, 2008
Wow!! I have a 10 year old daughter too. I also have a 9 yo son and a 4 yo old son. She has asked some pointed questions about sex such as "I know how the baby gets out mom but how do they get in there?" (due to the fact that she has such a younger brother) For some reason we seem to be in the car when the subject arises so I advoid them for the moment and tell her that is a conversation that we are gonna have to make a day and sit down and talk. I didn't realize that putting that conversation off was actually putting me behind everyone else. Honestly, I don't think many of the girls my daughter is friends with have had that conversation with their mothers yet either, at least not that I have heard. I can remember my mother giving us the "talk" and showing us books too. But I also remember talking about it with my friends and we were a couple of years older than these girls. I think my daughter, being very outspoken, would have told me if any of her friends knew something she didn't know first and would demandingly ask to know immediately. (She gets that bad habit honestly, I want to know all now too) I do think that this may be the time to have the talk with them though. For a couple of reasons. One being that children are becoming impregnated at such early ages these days and a lot of it is because of the girls being told of sex by the wrong person. Another being, they are going to start menstrating soon and they need to not only understand what is happening with their body but to understand the reason for their cycle. I thought about waiting for her to start her period but my luck says she won't start till she's 14 and someone else will have told her about the birds and the bees before she can get it straight and factual from her mother. I would like to keep in touch with you about this subject and see how things work out for you if you'd like. My email is ____@____.com, good luck and my name is A..
P.K. answers from Cleveland on September 26, 2008
Ditto on the American Girl books. They have all that "girlie" information in a easy to understand format. My daughter stills has hers and she is now 14.
More Answers
D.T. answers from Indianapolis on September 26, 2008
Good for the original poster to be ready for this talk. And for everyone who said it's "too early", you need to wake up and see what's going on in our country. It's not uncommon anymore for 11 and 12 year olds to get pregnant. Many 10 and 11 year olds have oral sex at school. Yes - at school. Or the mall or the movie theatre or whereever and think it's OK because it's "not sex". Last year my 8 year old neice came to me to talk because her mom wouldn't talk to her and told her she was too young. I'm soooo glad my neice came to me to talk (she was 7 at the time) because a few boys in her class were telling her oral sex was casual and OK -- like a handshake. She followed her gut instinct, said no, and found an adult to talk with. This year she is 8 and at least 2 of her friends are no longer virgins. Her brother is 13 and he says about half of his friends have had sex. Now get this... most of his friends aren't at his school - they are at his church! Their school system doesn't teach sex ed because of pressure from the parents. The parents insisted on teaching the kids themselves... but they have not. Or they do so way too late. My sister and others at her church just tell the kids "don't do it" but they don't really explain why or what "it" is. They assume kids know that oral sex is a kind of sex, but many do not. Talk with any teacher in a Jr High in this country and you'll know kids are starting MUCH earlier than we did.
Heck, my oldest is only 6 and we've been having this discussion (it's an ongoing discussion that lasts for years, not 'the talk') for more than a year. It started when I pregnant last year and he asked where the baby came from. Just give them age-appropriate info. We haven't had the "this is sex in detail" talk yet, but he does know a dad gets a mom pregnant.... which is more than my neice knew when she was 7!
2 moms found this helpful
D.Q. answers from Dayton on September 25, 2008
Apparently I am behind the eight ball, as well. However, I am not ready to have that talk yet. Especially about homosexuality and/or masterbation. She needs to be a child as long as possible. People anymore are too ready for their children to grow up. When she is ready to ask me questions I will answer them for her. Obviously if your daughter is not asking questions yet, she is not ready. I want my daughter to be innocent as long as possible. Everything is about sex anymore. Look at how many girls are getting pregnant at an early age. Way too many in my opinion. Girls on my daughter's softball team (8 & 9 year old) are talking about kissing their boyfriends. BET ME!! My daughter still thinks boys are gross. That is okay with me. Don't rush her. Other's may feel differently than I do, but when your daughter is ready to ask you questions then she is ready to hear about it.
1 mom found this helpful
C.W. answers from Columbus on September 26, 2008
I have 2 boys and have on going conversations with them concerning values, more than specifics.
Please everyone whose reading this, No matter how much you want to keep this away from them, our children are exposed to more than we realize. My boys aren't allowed to watch multiple tv shows/cartoons/channels, etc. They hear it on the radio in a friends car. They hear it from a tv that a church mate flips to out of curiousity.
I had a 3rd grade student and a min. of 2 4th grade girls start their period. There was fewer than 75 students in our 3rd and 4th grade. 1/3 of 5th grade girls are having some sort of sex, experimenting with more than just kissing the opposite sex/same sex.
Please talk to your girl, a little at a time so that she isn't pressured to do something she will regret or feel completely stupid (as I did) for not knowing.
1 mom found this helpful
M.M. answers from Cincinnati on September 26, 2008
I, also have a 10-year old daughter. She has asked a question here and there throughout the years, which I have answered as honestly as I thought would be appropriate for her. As far as starting so young, do it, or she will learn from her friends and schoolmates, which may give her incorrect information. You would not believe the things my daughter asked me about as early as 2nd grade-all because of things she heard on the school bus. I've been reading a book with her that is titled "What's the Big Deal?" It seems to be a good one so far. Good luck in your endeavors in sex ed!
1 mom found this helpful
R.C. answers from Dayton on September 26, 2008
C.,
Good for you, so many parents do not talk to their kids and they begin to learn about sex and their bodies from their friends. As a middle school youth leader I have used the parent guide book and 8 cd's offered by focus on the family called "Preparing for Adolescence-how to survive the coming years of change". It covers so much and helps guide you as a parent to talk to your son or daughter about the changes that will be taking place... physically, emotionally, socially, and it covers their struggle for independence. They suggest that you take your child on a weekend trip, listen to the cd's and have open dialogue with your child. Also, Dr. Kevin Leman has material out called "Running the rapids- guiding teenagers through the turbulent waters of adolescence" I have not read this one but I have read "A chicken’s guide to talking turkey to your kids about sex" by Dr. Kevin Leman and that is a really good one! When your daughter is a few years older I recommend a book called "And the bride wore white" By Dannah Gresh. This is also great material to talk with your daughter about purity, not just sexually but purity in all areas of her life. I hope this is helpful. R.'
1 mom found this helpful
M.R. answers from Cincinnati on September 25, 2008
Good for you for wanting to talk with your daughter about sex and do not feel badly about 'waiting too long'.
The most important thing you can do is demonstrate to her that you are open to communication about these potentially awkward topics whenever she needs it. Your daughters need to know that they can come to you with questions and answers without SHAME. I am willing to bet that you would rather have your daughter come and talk to YOU as opposed to 'learning from the locker room', so keep your door open!
By being honest and available for your daughter you are not robbing her of her innocence or making her grow up any faster. What you are doing is taking the opportunity to talk with her about what's important in her life, reinforce your family values, answer truthfully and honestly and questions she might have, and become her NUMBER ONE resource. Children who have parents who are available and willing to discuss sex issues are the ones most likely to avoid risky sexual behaviors, postpone sexual activity and remain abstinent until in a committed and loving relationship; conversely children who get no information and are taught that sex is bad, secret, or dirty tend to be the ones who experiment or participate in risky activities putting their physical and mental health in jeopardy.
I am a high school health teacher and the main class I teach is a quarter-long sexuality education course. It is all-inclusive and we cover everything. Our focus is on abstinence as the expected standard but because we know our students will not be abstinent forever (because most if not all students will, one day, be in a committed and loving relationship where having sex is appropriate), we do discuss contraception, infections, prevention and treatment. Additionally we cover identifying characteristics that are important in choosing a dating partner, recognizing personal values and goals and how decision-making with relationships/sex can align or be misplaced, identifying warning signs of a dangerous dating partner, and how to end an unhealthy relationship. Feel free to PM me with questions you might have. A great resource for evidence-based information is www.etr.org, although it is primarily curricula for teachers so it might not be exactly what you're looking for.
J.T. answers from Fort Wayne on September 26, 2008
Don't feel too bad - my daughter is 9 and I haven't had the "talk". They go with school in 4th grade (her grade) in the spring to a local health center that covers it - figured I would talk to her before then and be prepared for more questions after that. Let me know if you come up with ideas!!
T.H. answers from Terre Haute on September 25, 2008
My daughter is 9 and I have not had that talk with her. I feel she is not ready and she still needs to be a lil' girl. However, we have had the talk about what a females body goes through and all the changes the body will be doing around this age up til her teen years. What brought the talk on was she was concerned because she was showering one day and she could not understand why a hair was stuck to her private area. She now understands what her body is going through and why. I am so glad that she heard it from her mom and not a bunch of false information from classmates at school. She is only in 3rd grade this yr. So I will be asking the school when this subject will be taught in class. (Every parent has the right to ask for their child to be excused from class if they feel that they are not ready for this information. I know here in the county I live in there are permission slips sent home with the children and a parent has to sign saying it is okay for the child to stay in class) Anyways I will be the one teaching my child about the "birds and the bees".
good luck and you do what you feel is best for your child
Email