J.L. asks from Brentwood, TN on October 25, 2009
The Talk - Brentwood,TN
Hi Mom's,
I am thinking it may be time to have the birds and bee's talk with my 8 year old daughter, but wondering what the general opinion is about if she is too young.
In my previous life before kids I worked in pathology for 20 years so I have no problem talking to her and explaining the anatomy and physiology of the male and female body. I'm just not sure how much detail to go into on the actual physical act, emotion and feeling of sex. At this point she has not asked any questions, but instinct is telling me it's time to get started with this.
What do you think?
So What Happened?™
Thank you ladies for all of your advice. We have discussed quite a bit already as subjects have come up. I especially take the opportunity when the subject comes up on tv. Kissing, boys, babies etc. She knows the appropriate body part names.
She is ready for the next step regarding what her body will be going through. I appreciate the books and sites all of you recommended.
J.
Featured Answers
N.G. answers from Fayetteville on October 27, 2009
Hi J.,
I think before that talk can happen, you may want to give her the talk about what's on it's way soon...the menstrual talk. My daughter's 9th bday is in a month. I've touched on it, but plan on going into a little more detail with her.
The sex talk has to be very general, very vague at her age. She doesn't need to know everything, just remember she's still really young to know all that goes on. I would focus on the importance of how special it is--that it is something married people share together to show they love each other. I'd wait for more details until she asks. Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
S.P. answers from Nashville on October 26, 2009
J., I think 8 is a little young. I recommend waiting until 5th grade (10 years old). Specifiying anatomy is great at any age - they definitely need to know what's what and the proper names. As far as sex though - I'd wait a little longer.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
A.M. answers from Asheville on October 26, 2009
Two great age appropriate books that can be found at the library are "It's so Amazing" and "It's not the Stork". Both are similar, one is for kids a bit younger (maybe preschool - 2nd grade) the other is for older grade school-middle schoolkids. Look at both and determine your comfort level. Both are by Robbie Harris.
My kids (5 and 7) loved them and it even has a narrator in one that is really embarrassed to learn about the topic and a good comic relief.
2 moms found this helpful
A.C. answers from Charleston on October 26, 2009
My nieces are 9 and 10 and its time to have the talk with your daughter. The stories they come home with would horrify you. They tell my SIL stuff we have had to google to find out what it is only to find out its a sex position or something like that. She had the talk with them last year about becoming a woman (starting their period) which led to more questions. So I suggest you start with becoming a woman then let her guide you with questions. Let her know its ok to come to you any time she has more questions and make her comfortable coming to you so she doesnt learn it in school and from friends. You want her to have facts not 1/2 truths. Also there's an American Girl book called "The Care and Keeping of You" thats a good book for girls, my nieces read it and Im keeping it for my daughter when she's older.
2 moms found this helpful
W.M. answers from Nashville on October 26, 2009
I remember we got 'the talk' in school in 4th grade. I asked some of my friends with older children and they told me it is still 4 grade and some states it is 3 grade. Maybe you can call the school and find out what grade they will have the talk and coordinate it around the same time....have your talk after the school does in case she has questions. There are some good books out there that can help you if you want to let her read one before your talk. Usborne books has a good one that is for ages 8 and up. On Oprah a woman took her child to a sex therapist and let her daughter ask the therapist any questions she had and the mom stayed in the room. The daughter actually knew more than the mom thought she did. Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
N.G. answers from Fayetteville on October 27, 2009
Hi J.,
I think before that talk can happen, you may want to give her the talk about what's on it's way soon...the menstrual talk. My daughter's 9th bday is in a month. I've touched on it, but plan on going into a little more detail with her.
The sex talk has to be very general, very vague at her age. She doesn't need to know everything, just remember she's still really young to know all that goes on. I would focus on the importance of how special it is--that it is something married people share together to show they love each other. I'd wait for more details until she asks. Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
C.R. answers from Knoxville on October 26, 2009
I think the talk is a good. At age 8, she may not need very detailed info. I was around the same age when my parents sat me down to have the talk. They went into details that I remember thinking, I don't even like boys that much, there okay for friends but I don't want to kiss one and if one of them came at me with that I would probably kick him right where it counts! Kids now days are surrounding by sex on TV, music, movies etc... Find out if she is really interested in the boyfriend/girlfriend thing. If she is not then just a general overview would do fine. If so then more details etc... Also if you want to teach her abstinence until marriage start that now. If religion is a mainstay in your home then you can start teaching the biblical reasons for abstinence, or whatever you feel is the right thing.
We (our church youth)went to a program called "The Silver Ring". It is a non-denominational program that talks to tweens-young adults about staying pure for your future spouse. I learned a lot. They give the facts about sexually transmitted diseases,pregnancy rates and information about condoms. I did not realize that most people who use them apply them improperly, that heat can damage them and that a shipment could be damaged because of heat but you would never know until it is to late. Abstinence is so much safer! If you want more info about it just contact me. They travel with this program and they also have videos.
1 mom found this helpful
R.M. answers from Nashville on October 26, 2009
My mom believed with us that if we could ask the question, it deserved and answer and a real answer, no sugarcoating or getting embarrassed. With my sister at age 8, it turned out that she could ask every single question you could think of when my mom sat her down for the talk. My mom was surprised but answered it all. And thank goodness, a few months later my sister got her period at 9, and just calmly went to the school nurse. She didnt want to go into the specific "how-to manual" of sex, but when she was asked, she figured she had to answer honestly. And my sister turned out to be very level-headed about it all, and very confident with herself, and safe later.
1 mom found this helpful
S.P. answers from Nashville on October 26, 2009
J., I think 8 is a little young. I recommend waiting until 5th grade (10 years old). Specifiying anatomy is great at any age - they definitely need to know what's what and the proper names. As far as sex though - I'd wait a little longer.
1 mom found this helpful
J.C. answers from St. Louis on October 25, 2009
Good luck on this one. I am not even wanting to think about that discussion yet. I think you need to judge the maturity of you child before you decide to have the talk, so kids are ready to hear certian things, while others it may just terrify. I would maybe tell her about the changes to her body, but no go into a full blown dicussion about the opposite sex. Good luck again!!
J. C
1 mom found this helpful
Email