T.B. asks from Catskill, NY on May 18, 2009
Teen Step-daughter Failing School and Coming Between Us
Hi Ladies-
I have been reading and responding at mamasource for sometime now, and now I need your help!
How to summarize the last five years?!
I am the mom of two wonderful boys, ages 4 and 10 months. I live with their father, who I have been with for eight years. His 15 years old daughter has lived with us for five years. Her mother lives in another state and she visits her 7-8 weeks a year. We have struggled with her in many areas for the entire time she has been with us. She has had an unstable childhood, but has been well loved and supported for the entire time she has been with us. We have always made sure she had a therapist to work out her childhood issues and the stresses of her mom living in another state. School has always been difficult, but when she really applies herself she is a B student. This last year (9th grade) has been horrible. She refuses to participate in gym and is failing, she is also failing 3 main subjects. Her report cards and 5 week updates have comments like; need to study harder, is missing assignments, has zero's for not handing in work. Basically lack of effort, not inablility to do the work. Bottom line is she always says she will try harder and her father says he will stay on top of her and help push her. Neither of these two things ever happen. The only time he and I fight is over her. I have cried wolf and threatened to leave, but have not. We have tried everything with her, she just doesn't seem to care. Ladies I need help, I want to leave, I am not happy, my home is not happy. I am scared, and don't want my boys to be without their dad, but the environment they are in is not good for them. HELP........
2 moms found this helpful
So What Happened?™
Ladies-
I just wanted to thank everyone for taking the time to respond. As I said in my request, this was my first time, and I learned that you have take the time to tell the whole story. I was trying to summarize and I apparently left out some important info in the scheme of things.
First, my step daughter is in therapy, always has been, and her Dad and I are as well when we can afford it, she comes first. I do contact her teachers weekly, and speak with her guidance counselor at least once a month. I am very active in her schooling. She has been tested for ADD and is currently undergoing psychiatric evaluation that I arranged through our local mental health. I have tried everything I could think of to help her or find out what is going on. Her Dad of course supports all my ideas, but in all honesty I am the one who arranges these things.
We have tried the usual teenage punishments, and nothing seems to make a difference. She tries for a couple of weeks at school then that is it. This is why I finally posted to mamasource. I was hoping to receive new and different suggestions, which I did, thank you all again.
Anyway, I am just frustrated and have tried with all my heart to make up for the absence of her mom, but there are some days that it all seems impossible to me. I do not hold my children in a better light, and I did not mean to come across that way, my boys often take a back seat to my step daughter. But I still do strongly believe that the boys deserve a happy, healthy environment, that is also my job as a mom. Being a step mom can be a very difficult position to be in, as some of you well know. Keeping a balance is not an easy task. Thanks to you all, T.
Featured Answers
D.N. answers from Albany on May 19, 2009
Has she been tested for attention deficit? If she has it, she cannot help it and cannot focus without the necessary prescription meds. Just a thought. Looks like you have gotten some other good advice here as well. Best of luck to her and to all of you.
D.
M.K. answers from New York on May 19, 2009
You have known about the existence of this child since she was a little girl and you had children with her father. You have had many years to embrace her in a blended or extended family. People often have difficulty with their teenage children. She doesn't owe it you to do well in life. Maybe family counseling is in order.
More Answers
V.M. answers from New York on May 19, 2009
I have had teen daughters and I feel your pain, my first one hit 14 and became a nightmare. Here's how we coped: First, family counseling is very important because it teaches all of you to speak and listen to one another. Also, our counselor taught us appropriate punishments for a teenager. Secondly, a teen is not too young to realize that you have to work to earn things (or the money to buy them). Take away her stuff. If she is not "working" ie doing her school work then no ipod, no cell phone, no TV, no computer except for school work. Be "mean" about it and stand your ground. But, the counseling should come first because you and your husband MUST work as a team or she will play both of you like a piano (teens are good at that). Oh.. find a good hairdress because your grays will start popping in too!! LOL! Good luck, it isn't easy but you can get her straightened around and have your peaceful home back. We did.
1 mom found this helpful
S.S. answers from Binghamton on May 19, 2009
T., please try not to see this as critisim, but I find your personal information very revealing: "A working mom with 2 beautiful boys".
You are a working mom with 2 beautiful boys and a beautiful daughter. Have you really opened your heart to this child as well as your home? Does she hear you arguing with her father about her? Is she feeling rejected and angry, a second-class citizen with respect to her half-brothers?
Perhaps you need to consider speaking with a therapist yourself to figure out what your role is and what you want it to be. None of this is easy. It can be a hard, painful struggle. But if what you want is the joy back in your home, then you need to take action. The only person in this equation you have any real power over is yourself. Make sure that whatever happens, you can honestly say you gave it your very all.
1 mom found this helpful
T.B. answers from New York on May 19, 2009
Call me...seriously anytime.....email me and I will send my phone number......CALL ME!!!!!! I must start by saying I have read the responses and I would like to respectfully say to Sarah S - you have no idea how hard it is to be a step-mother unless you are one. I don't believe that you should advise someone on a situation if you don't have any experience - you wouldn't perform brain surgery if you weren't a brain surgeon. I am not T. and I was shocked at your opinion and I truly must disagree. I have a 13 soon to be 14 year old step-daughter - a 12 year old step son and two little girls of my own that are 5 and 2. My husband and I went through a 6 month period preparing for a divorce which thankfully didn't happen. We have had his children with us since September 2001.....it has been very hard on our marriage and on MY little ones. My step-children have only seen their mother 4 or 5 times in the past 9 years and most of those visits were for long weekends some were for a day. They both call me Mom and my son treats me as if I am his Mom and my daughter hates me. Until you have walked in the shoes of a step-mother raising someone elses daughter I don't think you could ever understand how we as step-mothers feel. With that being said - we also don't understand how the step-daughters feel. As a mother in general you need to have control of your children - who must respect you and honor the rules of the house. I must say, T., I am jealous that you get 7-8 weeks alone.....LOL We have been through bad grades - I hate you's - suicide watches and the drama just gets better all the time. She has been in therapy since 2001 - but it doesn't matter. We have her with a great therapist now and I believe we are really starting to resolve issues. My husband and I are a force to be reckoned with - we stand united on all fronts when it comes to her - he tells her no to every request and then I get to be the hero and tell her yes - which helps.....when it comes to school work - she is the same - my husband says he is going to be on top of her and call the homework hotline everyday but he never does - I have explained this to her - but really and truly - there is nothing like talking to someone who is experiencing the exact same things you are......it will make you feel so not alone and will most definitely improve your relationship with your husband. We did some therapy ourselves to learn how to be more effective parents in a blended family (hence the united front and the hero job being mine).....There mom lives across the country...barely calls and barely bothers - oh and she has two more children.....please email me and I will give you my phone number - CALL ME.....we can trade war stories.....Hold your head up - it does get better - then worse - then better - then worse.....LOL
1 mom found this helpful
T.E. answers from New York on May 19, 2009
I don't have a teenaged step daughter, but I do have a teenaged daughter who will be 16 this June and she had to go live in another state with her dad b/c she was failing pretty much all her subjects in school (9th grade) and she wanted to hang out with kids who were not motivated about anything except parties, music, sex and clothing. I used to go up to her school all the time; her teachers as well as the guidance staff and the asst. principal all knew me on a first name basis. I tracked her attendance, had her go thru an intervention counseling program, and even had her in extra curricular activities. I laid out rules for my home and when she continually broke them, her dad and I agreed that a different environment would be worth a try. She's been doing much better in her new school, although we have some ways to go. Now she's in an environment where she doesn't have as much freedom, but it has helped her to focus more on her academics as well as her issues. With all this stated here, I can kind of relate to how you're feeling, and I was dealing with all of it by myself, with no help from anyone, plus I have other children at home. My daughter and I though had a close relationship, despite all the things I've written here. Teenagers can be very complex; they're caught between childhood and adulthood, so we tend to expect so much from them. I encourage you to get family counseling for ALL of you, not to exclude this young lady b/c she needs love and support, and talk with her as much as possible. Find out what she likes, what motivates her, etc. Believe me, it is not an easy task, but it is worth the try. She will change as she matures and feels more confident in herself. Maybe an alternative education program with smaller classes would be helpful to her right now. Explore your options and get all the support you can. Communicate with her mom about what you all can do, if you're able to talk to her. I wish you all the best and I know it will get better. Take care.
1 mom found this helpful
K.P. answers from New York on May 18, 2009
I'm sorry to hear that you are going through this. It sounds like there are two separate issues here and they are making eachother worse- the first being your stepdaughter's lack of respect for your expectations and the second being your husband's inability to parent his daughter.
When you say that you are unhappy, do you mean that you are unhappy with your decision to be with your husband or are you unhappy with the current situation? If it is the first, then maybe you should consider a short-term separation and see if it makes a difference. If it is the second, then some drastic changes need to be made.
I will preface my suggestion with the fact that I am a child psychologist and a behaviorist meaning that I believe strongly that significant behavioral change comes about only through significant changes in the way you deal with the individual.
If I were you, here is what I would do (you may have already done so):
1. Write out your expectations (reasonable) for your stepdaughter. If she is capable of "B" work, then expect "B" work from her. This should also include your expectations surrounding effort and homework completion.
2. Next to each expectation, write what the consequence will be if the expectation is not met as well as the reinforcement for compliance. For example...
Expectation: Homework will be completed before dinner each night for three continuous nights.
Consequence: Cell phone gone for 2 days
Reinforcement: whatever she enjoys... $$, extra texting minutes, whatever
3. Meet with the teachers to express to them your support for them and your child and come up with an easy way for them to keep you in the loop. For many teachers, this is email. Just ask them to send you a quick email regarding her effort, work completion, attendance at the end of the week.
4. Have a meeting with your daughter, husband and yourself-no little ones. Discuss this plan and the need for it. Be honest with both of them. Tell them that their lack of respect (b/c this is what it is) for you and the little ones is not acceptable and that it needs to get better. DO NOT THREATEN TO LEAVE unless you mean it- they know you won't and neither take you seriously.
Her early childhood may have been quite challenging, but this cannot become her life-long crutch and it will not be an accepted excuse later in life. She needs to learn new behaviors while she still has the support of your family. She will be "on her own" in a few years and a lack of respect for expectations will not serve her well.
If you don't want to take this on yourself, then get the therapist involved to help you. Make it clear that there will be no more "promises" only genuine effort. Anything less will result in mom and the little ones finding a healthier place to live.
Good luck- this is a really tough one.
1 mom found this helpful
K.I. answers from New York on May 19, 2009
T.,
You're being a little overdramtic and I said this kindly.
I think you need to take a step back a little in this situation and not run to the divoice court because you step-daughter is failing her grades.
It is an issue and a very important issue, but do you really want to seperate or pretend to leave over this?
No? Ok. This is between your husband and his ex-wife.
In the end its the girls life and if she wants to ruin it
she can. But the both of you can make it tough for her in your home. If he refuses to set boundries than it is time for her mother to get involve. If her mother and your husband do not want to take action. Your action becomes non-action. Take care of your sons.
Good Luck
1 mom found this helpful
B.D. answers from New York on May 20, 2009
T.,
I feel for you but I also feel for your step-daughter too. I really dont think shes failing on purpose I think shes failing because she feels neglected from her mother. That itself is a HUGE issue. Arguing and fighting with your husband isnt going to change how her emotions are. I strongly suggest counseling. If not for the family then at least for your husband and your step daughter. If you think about it being a teenager is hard enough but combine those crazy emotions with rejection from a parent. Thats enough to make me "throw in the towel" and not care either.
Since shes in the 9th grade- most HS have direct emails in the classrooms. You can send the teacher an email requesting the "homework" or you can talk to her guidence counselor and have he/she create a schedule of assignments for you. Wonder if she can join a group/ sport in school.
My daughters freshman year was a nightmare- but we both got through it..theres a light at the end of the tunnel !!!
I wish you lots of luck and positive thoughts :0)
E.S. answers from New York on May 19, 2009
Well it sounds to me like she may need something in her life to give her a boost! My whole life growing up I did not do well in school. I always was a C,B student.I studied so hard! My parents soon realized that my strengths were not in academics but in my hands. Unfortunately socity as a whole teaches us from kindergarten til 12th grade that if you do well in math, spelling, history, etc. that that's what makes you smart and you will be successful in life. The truth is, a person who is smart with their hands is as intellgent as the next. Schools don't emphasize that enough. If we had all accountants or lawyers in the world there wouldn't be enough positions open. Thank the Lord that we have carpenters, photographers, cake decorators, etc. What if she just needs loving support. Maybe encourage her to seek out what she may love!
Email