A.G. asks from Corinth, NY on January 06, 2012
Teen Daughters Having Sex
Hi, I need to ask a question coming from the viewpoint of a father trying to raise my girls the best way I can. I have a big problem nowadays with this whole theory of allowing teenagers to do things just because other teens are doing it. My daughters are at that age where having sex is encouraged by their peers, but me and their mother don't want them too. The problem lies in how we're handling making sure it doesn't happen. My wife wants to put them on birth control or other things to protect them, she believes that if their gonna do it, they should be protected. I say that if their still living under our roof, they should go by our rules and we have the right to make sure they follow them rules. Also, there are teens who do go without having sex until their older, and what are their parents doing any different to make sure they don't have sex.
2 moms found this helpful
Featured Answers
C.O. answers from Minneapolis on January 06, 2012
Just because you tell them it's the rules does not mean they will follow them. I think you need to talk to them be open and honest and make them comfortable enough so they will talk to you. Tell them why you want them to wait. Also inform them on how to protect themselves if they do decide to have sex. You can't watch them 24/7. My parents never really talked to me or made me comfortable enough to talk to them about sex. I went on birth control pills when I was 16 (medical problems mostly) and got information by talking to my doctor. I had a boyfriend at the time and we had sex even though my parents made it perfectly clear they did not want me to. Luckily I ended up marrying him. So the best thing you can do is talk to them and give them information so they can make the right decision.
7 moms found this helpful
J.C. answers from New York on January 06, 2012
Keep the lines of communication open. Let them know that you would hope that they decide to wait, but if they don't, they must come to you for advice and guidance on birth control. No judgements. Just guidance.
Good job, pop.
4 moms found this helpful
A.P. answers from New York on January 07, 2012
My kids are still young, but believe it or not, I think about this ALL the time. Also my nieces are nearing that age...it's a very difficult thing. I feel uncomfortable with the idea of putting a teenager on birth control--call me old fashioned, but but I feel two things about this...one, I think it sends a message that you are giving the green light, even if you say you're not. And two, that you EXPECT them to NOT listen to you, and to make poor decisions. That you don't trust them to do what they should (and shouldn't) be doing.
Now, will I change my point of view when my kids are teens? Maybe, but probably not.
I am religious, and grew up religious, and did not have sex in high school or college. I am definitely in a small minority. I don't think my parents handled it in the best way, but I guess something worked, lol.
The best non-religious advice I've ever heard on the subject was an Oprah show a few years ago, with two 14 year old teens who were thinking of sleeping together, their moms, and Dr. Berman. The dr. asked the teens questions to get them thinking, and they came to their OWN conclusion NOT to have sex, based on the convo. You can probably Google it and find more info. Maybe something like this would stick more, because it's not really the parents telling the kids not to do something, but it's getting them to work through the ideas and consequences themselves.
Good luck!
More Answers
W.. answers from Chicago on January 06, 2012
well, call me crazy but I would start with a conversation with them, rather than making these decisions about THEIR sexuality FOR them. They aren't 3.
I don't know how old your "teens" are - 13 is very different than 16, and so warrants a different conversational strategy. But if you think you can just tell them not to have sex and they will listen to you..... How has that worked out so far? when you told them to pick up their coat, did they listen? How about when you told them to eat their veggies?
The average age of 1st sexual experience for a girl in America is 16. It has been 16 for 4 generations. How do you get your kids to be on the older side before they have sex? In my opinion you get THEM to understand WHY it is to THEIR benefit to wait.
You ask them why they want to have sex. You ask them what is good about sex. You ask them what they want out of the relationships they have with men. You ask them what are the benefits and consequences of having sex too soon, or with the wrong partner, or in the wrong way, or for the wrong reasons. And then what are the consequences and benefits of having sex when it's right and with the "right" partner and for the right reasons.
Dad - I think you can be key here. You can tell them what a "teen" boy wants from the girls he has sex with, vs what an older more mature boy wants. (I know, not all teens.... I'm not boy-bashing). You tell them what sex meant to you when you were 16, 17, 18 and 19. vs 26, 27 and then 40 and then 50. (don't know how old you are..... point is it's different at different ages)
Talk to your girls about what THEY should be getting out of sex... as women, as individuals, as partners. If they aren't at the point to have these conversations with a partner..... then let them know it means their wants and needs may not be met.... and talk with them about what the consequences of that are.
If you treat them like children and take away THEIR accountability (ie - putting them on birth control instead of letting THEM make that decision and OWN the consequences or just "telling" them what to do) then you aren't allowing them to grow up and show you that they are young adults.
Good luck
12 moms found this helpful
J.S. answers from Jacksonville on January 06, 2012
Talk, talk, talk about it. Seriously, my parents tried to sweep it all into the "Don't have sex before marriage." end of subject. End result, my sister was sexually active at 14, me at 16. Yes, peer pressure had LOTS to do with it.
Looking back I wished my parents, ANYONE, would have said this to me.
"Look, what you see on TV and what your friends think of sex couldn't be further from the truth. Sex isn't just about a cute guy and a cute girl getting together for a little fun. Sex is a very intimate thing, you will never forget a person you have sex with." I will be telling my daughter this, when she is old enough, and let her know that even all these years later, there are sex encounters that I had that still make me cringe. Stupid, stupid things. Uggh. Just be honest.
10 moms found this helpful
A.M. answers from Kansas City on January 06, 2012
My parents forbid me to date a certain young man. Do you know what I did? I dated him behind their backs for 3 years! There are rules that can be under the "my house, my rules" that can be enforced and there are rules under "my house, my rules" that have loop holes and can be avoided.
Yes I got caught a "hundred" times...but the more they said "no" the more I saw him.
Watch yourself. Honestly I agree with your wife, birth control does not give them the permission to go have sex, it gives them the responsibility to make the decision, as I'm a firm believer that if they are going to have sex, they will with or without. At least with BC they probability of me becoming a grandma and her a mom early is less likely. Doesn't mean I'm going to cheer her on and said "YES, GO HAVE SEX! I AM OK WITH IT", just means I know the choices she is going to have to make and I've equipped her with tools to make those choices.
I am also a firm believer is talking about sex, and not making it a "sin"...but then again I'm a "radical" and am open and honest about such things.
Good Luck!
9 moms found this helpful
P.S. answers from Grand Forks on January 06, 2012
Grew up with sisters, I am glad my father started open discussion during dinner times. We were allowed to ask any question, any subject. With out reprimand. I don't remember asking too much my other sisters did though and . . well, lmao. But I did learn a lot and it gave me the opportunity to understand my parents' view. We were not taken to the dr for birth control. But my mom did have a stash of condoms that she didn't ask what we used them for, pranks, sex etc. She just made sure they were available. Plus having to put a condom on a banana in front of your dad was enough to put me off of it. I applaud you for being proactive, keep the communications open and be honest, your daughters will return the favor.
7 moms found this helpful
C.O. answers from Minneapolis on January 06, 2012
Just because you tell them it's the rules does not mean they will follow them. I think you need to talk to them be open and honest and make them comfortable enough so they will talk to you. Tell them why you want them to wait. Also inform them on how to protect themselves if they do decide to have sex. You can't watch them 24/7. My parents never really talked to me or made me comfortable enough to talk to them about sex. I went on birth control pills when I was 16 (medical problems mostly) and got information by talking to my doctor. I had a boyfriend at the time and we had sex even though my parents made it perfectly clear they did not want me to. Luckily I ended up marrying him. So the best thing you can do is talk to them and give them information so they can make the right decision.
7 moms found this helpful
E.J. answers from Lincoln on January 06, 2012
I think knowledge is power.... part of the reason I had sex earlier than I should have is because I was curious. I knew nothing about it. My sex talk consisted of Sex, don't do it. End of story.
I think by them knowing the risks such as STIs and pregnancy and other information the only thing you can do is hope they will make the choice to wait. It really comes down to helping guide them to make their own choice. Because if you forbid it and they want to they will find a way. It's their choice in the end and so I think educating them is the key.
I hope some other mamas give you some great tips about this and good luck. I love that you care so much about your daughters to want to guide them to a good life! Good luck!!!
7 moms found this helpful
R.M. answers from San Francisco on January 06, 2012
Does your wife have a reason to believe they are having sex or are going to have sex? Birth control pills have an effect on the body, so your wife shouldn't just randomly put them on the pill without having any concrete reason to do so.
However, if they are having sex, safe is better than sorry, although STD's are a concern too, so your wife might want to discuss the additional protection of condoms with your daughters.
The best prevention against teens having sex is being loving and communicative parents who listen to their kids. However, if your daughters get boyfriends, there is a good chance sex will happen, so don't have your head in the sand.
7 moms found this helpful
A.S. answers from Iowa City on January 06, 2012
A....you know this to be true: You cannot stop your daughters from having sex if they want to do it (makes you mad/sad, doesn't it?). All you can do is encourage them to wait until they are in a committed, loving relationship and ready to handle whatever consequences may arise from having a sexual relationship. Talk to them. Educate them about how and when a baby is conceived and about STDs and how both of those things can be prevented. Forbidding something causes an automatic challenge. Teens are stupid when it comes to this so when you are adamant that they not do something, they become adamant that they will do it.
Ultimately, I'm with your wife on this one. She doesn't want to be a grandmother.
I have a friend who waited until she was 19 to have sex for the first time. It had nothing to do with her parents. She made that personal decision because it was the right one for her. I also have a friend who's dad strictly forbid her from having sex until she was married...she had sex with A LOT of people (starting at age 16), had a few abortions, and currently has two children and lives with a man 20 years her elder. She isn't married and doesn't intend to be any time soon.
7 moms found this helpful
Email