53 answers

Teaching Responsibility or Just a Mean Mommy?

I'm taking a little poll here:

I'll start of by saying my 10 yr old daughter acts like a spoiled brat. We have been working on not giving into her for a long, long time now, but she never stops trying to rule the roost.

Last night I took my kids to Subway before her softball practice. My daughter like to order her own food, so she ordered an Italian BMT, and asked for avocado on it. I then ordered for the rest of us and ordered myself a Turkey, Bacon Avocado sandwich.
Right after she heard me order, she said "Oh man, I really wanted to try that sandwich this time. Can I switch with you?" I looked and he had already made her Italian BMT with avocado (which did not appeal to me at all) so I said "No, I'm sorry. I can't stomach avocado with Italian meats." Naturally she starts crying, and told me "a good mother would trade with her daughter". I said "No, a good mother teaches her child to be responsible for her choices as big or small as they may be. You ordered that sandwich so you're going to eat it this time. Next time you can get the other one".

Later, after dropping her off at practice, I called my mom and mentioned it to her. She said that she would've traded with her and just scraped the avocado off. I said "first of all, you wouldn't have traded with me when I was a kid, but now that you're grandma it's a different story...And what about teaching her that she's not going to get through life by people fixing her mistakes all the time. She said "she's just a kid, and it was just a sandwich".

I hate second guessing my parenting decisions, and I do it all the time especially with my daughter because she's my oldest. She uses words as weapons, and although I know that, I still allow it to bother me.

Was I being a good mother in this situation or a mean one?

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thank you all for your responses! I am glad to see that nobody else would have traded sandwiches. And yes, my daughter is WAY too old to have tantrums in public. If she hadn't have had practice, I would have taken her home. I don't believe in having my child miss a practice or game due to behavior because we made a commitment to the team. The team needed her.

Featured Answers

Gosh, you are sooo mean!! Seriously?? Accepting no for an answer is a tough lesson for kids to learn. They only way they will learn it is for us to say no!! You absolutely did the right thing, IMO!

I must be REALLY mean. I wouldn't have traded AND she would have received a consequence for throwing a fit.

7 moms found this helpful

It may just have been a sandwich, and she's just a kid, but I would not have traded either. Good for you for teaching her to live with her decisions, big or small. The world needs more moms like you ;-)

7 moms found this helpful

You did fine.
It was just a sandwich - and it was perfectly fine for her to eat what she ordered.
Maybe NEXT time, she can order LAST so she has plenty of time to think through her order before she orders it.

7 moms found this helpful

More Answers

This is what my mother (a very good mother) would have done: she would have done what you did, but then she would have offered me a couple of bites of hers, so that I could "try it." I get the message you are trying to send, but this also could have been a lesson about sharing.

However, having said that, I wouldn't ever tolerate my child telling me what a "good mother" would do. What sass! Frankly, after such rudeness, I wouldn't be in much of a sharing mood either. That's an attitude I cannot imagine tolerating. There are lots of ways she can express her disappointment without insulting you. Rather than her inability to stick with a decision she made (a very common trait in children), I think that's your bigger issue right there. I wish you luck.

18 moms found this helpful

My 8 y/o and I went for ice-cream the other day. He ordered first then me. We sat down and he looks at mine and says "oh, that looks yummy! I should have gotten that!! Could I try it?" I said "sure, honey!" He tried a bite and went back to his. A few minutes later he asked for another bite, but after offering me some of his. When he had finished his and I had a little left I gave him the rest. He was ecstatic. I never would have given him mine if he had a tantrum, cried or spoke to me in such a way that your daughter did.

10 moms found this helpful

You dealt with her perfectly.

The one thing I would have said is "I do not appreciate you talking to me in that way. Next time you talk to me in a way that is rude and disrespectful, and show that you aren't thankful for the food you have already gotten, I'll let you sit at the table and eat nothing."

ETA: In response to her "A good mom would have..." I would say, "You aren't a mother, so don't try to tell me what a good mother would do. You're here getting a sandwich instead of at home, aren't you?"

And in response to your mom, I agree with you. It's NOT just a sandwich. It's about teaching your daughter to be an adult woman, not a whiny, manipulative baby.

9 moms found this helpful

Hi sweet!

First...I want the address of YOUR subway...OURS is SO S L O W that this never would have happened! lol

I think you did fine...but what stood out to me was your comment...'naturally, she starts crying'...

Hmmm...

At 10? Not in my world. I would have probably packed up all kiddos (and sandwiches) and gone directly home...allowing/having her miss softball practice.

Is she this manipulative with 'other' adults? Or just with you?

I would get ALL OVER THIS NOW.

If not, I will not envy you her teen years (only three years away...YITE!)

I would look at some of the books suggested below...stick with ONE philosophy (or a combo)...and then be GRUELINGLY consistent and firm with each and every incident.

Sending good thoughts your way!

Best Luck!
michele/cat

9 moms found this helpful

omg PLEASE don't second guess yourself.
yes, she's just a kid and it's just a sandwich. that's LIFE. and you calmly and lovingly gave her one more experience in how to handle it appropriately.
i am 100% with you on this one.
khairete
S.

9 moms found this helpful

Call me mean Mommy too! I would not have traded.

And your Mom, well you nailed it - Grandma's play by different rules and seem to be much more lenient with the Grandkids than they were with us.

Just an after thought here, but maybe in the future, in similar situations you all discuss what you are having before you all order. That way everyone gets a chance to consider something they might not otherwise have thought of...

8 moms found this helpful

You did the right thing. Only I would have added serious consequences for the tantrum too....like and extra week of chores or something. And I probably would have taken away her sandwich and let her go hungry. Crying and insulting her mom? nope. She sounds like she needs some serious reality checks over and above the actual items in the given moment (not getting to switch sandwiches). That's not tough enough to teach her not to act spoiled going forward. She still got to throw a fit with no consequence. If she uses words as weapons, there needs to be consequences from you for that, just like there will be when she leaves home and disrespects bosses, friends, and spouses. She'll end up lonely or only liked by bad people if she acts like a bad person. If she doesn't respect you, she won't respect anyone.

8 moms found this helpful

It may just have been a sandwich, and she's just a kid, but I would not have traded either. Good for you for teaching her to live with her decisions, big or small. The world needs more moms like you ;-)

7 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.