M.L. asks from Brooklyn, NY on December 03, 2008
Switch to Soy Milk at Age One
Our pediatrician says to give our daughter soy milk instead of the soy formula now that she is one. (Dairy allergy). But she doesnt eat much table food--some rice, banana, sometimes chicken--but not consistently and sometimes just a few bites a day. So her main source of nutrition will continue to be from the bottle until she warms up to the food more. Does soy milk really have enough nutrients? What about toddler soy formula?
Featured Answers
D.N. answers from Albany on December 04, 2008
Is it possible to make the soy formula WITH soy milk, using a little less formula mix? That way she's still getting some formula along with the little bits of food that she takes in. Just a thought.
More Answers
M.T. answers from New York on December 04, 2008
Hi M.,
I can't remember where I read that soy formula should be continued to age 2 and soy milk not given until that age so I don't know whether that was really valid information or not. I don't believe that there's any research that discusses the benefits of "toddler formulas" since these products are really just a marketing ploy to get people to spend more money. If you're unsure about the right diet for your child with her allergy and lack of food, I would go for a consult with a pediatric nutritionist.
Good luck!
M.B. answers from Rochester on December 04, 2008
M.,
Keep trying new foods of course, and water is a good thing to have also.
Soy milk can be found in enriched formulas - but I don't know whether adult enriched will be enough for her. (found out adult oatmeal has iron, but not enough for an infant). You will have to find out from charts or your pediatrician what levels of nutrients you should be looking for. Soy milk alone will not do it, of course.
Good Luck finding soy that fits the bill. An organic soy company is 'Soy Boy'; they have a plant in Rochester NY, and others elsewhere. You might try them (calling might yield more info, too).
M.
D.N. answers from Albany on December 04, 2008
Is it possible to make the soy formula WITH soy milk, using a little less formula mix? That way she's still getting some formula along with the little bits of food that she takes in. Just a thought.
A.S. answers from Albany on December 04, 2008
My daughter as well has a dairy and egg allergy. The allergist recommended rice milk vs soy. Said that rice milk had a lot more nutritional value to it. Look at them both and compare. My daughter is doing fine on the rice milk drinks more then the formula. We were on a specail formula too. Sometimes they react to soy if they have a milk allergy, so we stayed away from soy. This is all from a pediatrition allergist. Good luck.
G.C. answers from New York on December 04, 2008
Like the previous mom said, soy milk has less fat than cow's milk so it'd be good to get your daughter eating good fats like avocadoes and olive oil. Another nutrient I always worry about for my little one is iron, which milk doesn't really have. I give her vitamin C fortified apple sauce mixed with Earth's Best baby cereal. The C helps them absorb the iron. If you stayed with the formula, it probably has iron in it.
I need to do more research on soy too, but as far as I know it's healthy. The only place I've read bad things about it is Mothering magazine, which tends to be highly biased. You can get extremely sick from drinking raw cow's milk.
B.E. answers from New York on December 04, 2008
If she is taking the PolyVitamin (ask pediatrician), that will give her anything she might be missing. My kid was on Rice milk (enriched) after age one (milk and soy intolerance). I put olive oil in a lot of his food to give him the healthy fat he was missing from milk, also avocado is a great source of vitamins and healthy fats.
J.C. answers from New York on December 04, 2008
My son has a dairy allergy as well. At age one i started similac isomil level two formula. Its for toddler so it has more vitamins and minerals that a toddler needs that regular fomula. Soy milk is low in fat about half what regular cows milk is so i was concerned about him not getting the amount of good fat for brain development. I was only able to find the level two isomil at target but this was two years ago so you might have an easier time finding it. I kept him on level two formula until he was two by then he was eating better that i felt okay just giving him regular soy milk. hope this helps.
-J.
____@____.com
C.S. answers from New York on December 03, 2008
I dont have any experience with toddler formula, so I am no help to you there... :)
But I can tell you that we only drink soy milk in my home. My kids have been drinking it since they turned one.
We only drink Silk PLUS Omega-3. Silk has other PLUS varieties. A Bone Health and a Fiber. I like the nutrients in the Omega-3 the best. Its not plain flavored but not Sugary Vanilla, either. Actually has less sugar than regular milk.
Compare the nutritional content side by side with whole milk. Its got a lot of great stuff. More vitamins than you find in regular milk. :)
Oh, the price can be a little high in the grocery store. I find it in Target for almost $2 less a 1/2 gallon, than I see in the grocery stores. Good Luck!!!! :)
Email