A.H. asks from Burton, OH on August 12, 2008
Suntan Lotions That Don't Stain?
Help! Today I found myself strenuously AVOIDING my 20 mo. old daughters advances toward me for a hug. WHY? Because I had just applied sunscreen to her and did not want to get any on my white shirt. I have tried at least 10 different sunscreens and have successfully ruined at least 2 dozen pieces of my dtrs. apparel and/or mine. I am so frustrated. The clothes always get an orange stain on them wherever the sunscreen rubbed off. I always try to put the lotion on before dressing her, but then there is the issue of reapplying. Any suggestions would be great. I'd rather find a sunscreen that doesn't stain in the first place, but suggestions as to how to get the stains out would be welcome too. Thanks so much!
So What Happened?™
So, hopefully noone thinks I am some kind of super vain monster for skipping a hug to avoid a stain on my shirt. I know the days of these unsolicited hugs are short lived so that is why I needed to ask for help! Thank you for all the suggestions, I will definately try the different stain removing techniques. As an FYI, I did call customer service at Banana Boat and they freely admitted to the stain issue. They suggest rubbing Oxiclean into the stain well and then soaking in oxiclean for 24 hours, wash as usual, then AIR dry. They say for some reason the heat in the dryer only makes the stain a lot worse. She said you would see the best results after two cycles of doing this. She also said the supposed ingredient that causes the stain is Avobenzone, which is a sunscreen stabilizer. I went to Walmart tonight and the only sunscreen I could find that did not have this ingredient was Bullfrog. I will try that next and see if we have any better luck! Thanks again Mamas for the input!
Featured Answers
P.Z. answers from Cleveland on August 13, 2008
We use Arbonne Baby Product, and have for a couple of summers. I have had no stains at all. And they are pediatrician tested and approved!
K.H. answers from Columbus on August 13, 2008
I use Waterbabies (both the creme and the spray) on my 2 girls and it's nothing but wonderful. Never stains.
S.D. answers from Indianapolis on August 13, 2008
This may not be what you wanted to hear, but I would worry more about how good the sunscreen is and less about the clothes. Clothes can be replaced, skin is for life.
Here's a website that rates brands:
http://www.cosmeticsdatabase.com/special/sunscreens2008/
Good Luck:)
For the record, Arbonne is rated badly, as are most of the common brands people mentioned.
More Answers
S.C. answers from Indianapolis on August 14, 2008
BullFrog. It's the best, get the gel, or the spray. It will absorb before your daughter has a chance to hug you, and if you do get it on your clothes, you wouldn't know. It works great, and is the only thing I use for myself and my 10 month old. I don't know where you live, I found it in the south (Alabama), but I live in Indiana, it is hard to find in the Midwest, K-Mart is one of a few places that carry it here, but it is everywhere in the south. Give it a try, I think you will really like it.
1 mom found this helpful
L.L. answers from Evansville on August 13, 2008
A. -
I recommend using Arbonne's ABC Baby Sunscreen -- botanically based with nothing that will harm your child or that would create stains. If you would like a sample to try, feel free to contact me.
L. L.
C.B. answers from Lafayette on August 13, 2008
K.Z. answers from Cleveland on August 13, 2008
Hi A.,
I commend you for trying to make sure your daughter wears sunscreen!
I confess we're kind of lax about it but my kids are teens now. For myself I use a moisturizer with sunscreen from Yves Rocher, "Protectyl Soleil" and have not had this problem. It may be too low of an SPF for little folks, but check their other stuff.
To get stains out, I would try an enzyme cleaner like Totally Toddler. If that doesn't work, and the sunscreen had a greasy/oily component, I would try Lestoil and wash in the hottest water safe for the fabric. DON'T dry in dryer, that tends to set the stain. (Lestoil is a household cleaner, not sold specifically for laundry but it works.)
You can also try, on white items, putting lemon juice on the stain and leaving the item in the sun. On colored things, this may fade the color as well as the stain, but if they're ruined anyway....it may be worth the risk.
Oxyclean (or its generic equivalent) is also worth a try, using it as a pre-soak as well as in the wash (again, in hot water).
Or you could just wear the old shirts around home so you can get hugs from your little one without worry! ;-) It may be hard to believe, but there may well come a day when she doesn't want to give/get them--enjoy them now! Good luck!
K. Z.
M.H. answers from Cincinnati on August 13, 2008
Hi A.,
I too have used Coppertone's Water Babies, and it DOES stain my daughter's swimsuits. One of her suits is a pink suit that is piped in white, and now the white is yellow from the Waterbabies (which is the only sunscreen I have ever used on her and is from 2 different bottles). I have tried Shout, Oxyclean, etc, but nothing has worked for me. I haven't tried to soak it Oxyclean clean like was suggested, so I am going to try that. If you find something that works, let me know too!! :-)
For your t-shirt, if it's white, have you tried using color safe bleach? I use that on white's that can't be washing with regular bleach.
K.S. answers from Cincinnati on August 13, 2008
Like others, I have never had regular sunscreen stain anything. I use the store brands and/or Coppertone, it comes out of the bottle white and it disappears into the skin.
If it is leaving an oily residue, try pretreating the oily area with Dawn dishwashing detergent. Actually, that works on all kinds of oily stains on clothes!
P.Z. answers from Cleveland on August 13, 2008
We use Arbonne Baby Product, and have for a couple of summers. I have had no stains at all. And they are pediatrician tested and approved!
J.F. answers from Canton on August 13, 2008
I am an independant consultant for BeautiControl and we have a fabulous sunscreen for body and wonderful sunscreen and anti-aging moisturizers for face. I have never had any staining issues when using our products and clients are very happy with them as well.
Contact me for more info about BeautiControl and I would be happy to help.
I live in the North Canton area and would love to show you the wonderful and affordable skincare.
Email