28 answers

Struggling with Emotional Disappointment of C-section

Let me begin by saying that in no way am I casting judgement against c-sections, regardless of how I personally feel about them. Please know this in advance.

Having a vaginal birth has always been very important to me. I have always felt amazed that we as women are the only ones who can bring forth life into the world and when I got pregnant in May, I considered it an honor to birth my own child. My "birth plan" was to include a midwife, possible water birth, and a whole-hearted attempt at no pain meds. However, due to placental malfunction, fetal growth restrictions, and low amniotic fluid, I had to have what I guess you would call an emergency c-section on Jan 14.

Even though the most important thing is that Baby Girl is here and healthy (tho still in a Special Care Nursery), I am bothered by the fact that I wasn't able to "truly" birth her into the world. People have said to me: "You look great ot have just had a baby," and I think to myself: But all I did was lay there. Behind a sheet. I barely even saw her - they just lifted her out of me. I almost feel like I got robbed of the birthing experience. I didn't get to push life into this world and the emotional/ physical connection that comes with that. I just laid on a table. They did all the work and it still feels surreal that this baby is mine.

I am still struggling with this. I'm sure part of the problem is that she's still in the hospital and perhaps once she's home and the connection with her truly begins, this will subside. But right now, I'm still bothered by it. I would love a little emotional support in this if anyone has been through it and can relate.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

I am so pleasantly surprised by all of your wonderful responses. I was hesitant to post this because I feared judgement for my feelings, but you have all been so very supportive and understanding. I cannot thank you enough. I know that my hormones have me going in all different directions (and I'm paying close attention to them), plus having a preemie (she was 8.5 weeks early when her amniotic fluid dropped too low) with the special needs that come with that, and driving back and forth to the hospital every day are probably all factors taking a bit more of a toll than I expected. I didn't mean to imply that I hadn't bonded with her at all - I'm spending as much time with her as I can, we're both learning the ropes of breastfeeding (though she can only breastfeed once or twice a day right now due to her small size), and I kangaroo with her as much as possible - it's just that it all felt a bit surreal. But I love her dearly, she is an amazing miracle of God, and I know that you are all right: 50 or so years ago, she would never have made it.

I thank you all for you insight, kind words, and encouragement. You pointed out a few things that I hadn't thought of and confirmed the things I know are true. It was a good decision to post here - I am very grateful for such good people who are willing to help.

More Answers

I felt the same way after my first daughter was born. I had the same natural plan and was in labor for THIRTY SIX HOURS at the hospital, fending off nurses with drug suggestions bc I was, in fact, in pain and for nearly a DAY going full force with contractions 1 minute to 30 seconds apart and no sleep. I was a wreck. But so focused on this "dream birth".

My doctor was so understanding but my daughter was tired too. She finally couldn't handle this process anymore and the contractions were not doing anything. She was fighting ot get out but I was not 'opening up'. This caused her to squirm and fight and the chord wrapped around her 3x and she almost stopped breathing for a full minute.

They whipped me into OR and cut me open before you could say "sesame".

I was panicked and angry and frustrated and felt like a failure. I thought my body had betrayed me after all that hard work I did. IT SUCKED.

I worked HARD and in the end I get cut open? THEY get to bring her out?

that was a hard reality to face and understand but guess what, she was so beautiful adn alive and healthy and perfect and this is what I've come to learn.

you DID bring her into this world.
you DID work.
you DID birth her.
you DID prepare her.
you DID make her healthy.

and no one else COULD HAVE but YOU.

YOU DID THE WORK that no one else could have.
did she grow in a petrie dish in a lab until a doctor opened the cocoon and said "its time" and you guys went and picked her up?
NO!

that isn't the end.
my 2nd pregnancy I was determined to have a VBAC.
oh yes! i followed a strict diet, strict exercise program, stretches, the entire 100 + yards to get there.

when my due date arrived I never ONCE complained "ugh this needs to be over" bc I had this goal in mind and wanted a healthy baby. (even though I did really want to be done being pregnant lol!!!)

day after due date I had contractions and this was it!
same thing happened.
hard contractions, but nothing happened.

Turns out I have a hip condition where I could contract for weeks but nothing will happen. BC of nature the baby WILL try and come out with the contractions, and without medical intervention we could both die as a result (this happened a lot in the "old days").

I accepted that I'm not a failure.
I brought two babies to term and they are amazing kids and I thank my good doctors for being there for me.

Without good doctors, us stubborn women could make dangerous and silly decisions.
YAY doctors!
and YAY moms!

you are wonderful.
xoxo

5 moms found this helpful

Just remember this...a c-section...does not renege the 9 months you carried her, took care of yourself, loved her, and did everything to protect her. Nor, will it renege all the very hard work you will do as a parent, caregiver, and companion to your child. Does you question bother me? YES. To think a woman should feel bad about doing what was right for the safety of her child. Your c-section was valid, as was mine. You did what it required, to keep your child safe. You did your very important job as a mom, to make the best decisions for your child. The way your birth has NOTHING to do with how you will parent.

You know what...my friend...she got the birth she wanted. Water birth at home with a midwife. It didn't make a difference. It didn't make her feel more empowered then I felt to carry a child for 9 months and bring him into the world. It didn't make her a better parent, it didn't make her a stronger parent. She often comes to me feeling overwhelmed, not knowing how to handle her 20 month old. Sh calls me a few times a week lamenting about how difficult parenting is for her. Her birth didn't protect her from the same difficulties in parenting. It didn't set her up to handle them better. You have to understand, when we set ourselves up to think there is only one empowering way to give birth, you are setting yourself up for depression and failure. It DOES sound like you are a bit depressed and need to at the very least, speak with your doctor.

I had a c-section and I DID TRULY BIRTH my child. He came from MY body. The body that gave him protection, nourishment, and life for 9 months. The body that conceived him and did everything possible to insure he would be a safe, happy, healthy child. If THAT'S not empowering, I'm sorry I don't know what is. You need to change your mindset, because your worth, empowerment, and bonding does not come from the vagina. Excuse me, for being slightly offended by your post. I'm not trying to be rude, but it does get quite old when other mothers (the ones who should be supportive) insinuate one birth is better, more empowering, or more legit then the other, It's terribly sad, and in your personal case damaging. Part of the reason you could not feel as strong of a bond, is becuase you're spending way to much time on having a c-section.

4 moms found this helpful

I had 2 c-sections.
The first, was an emergency after about 15 hours of being in labor.
The 2nd, was planned.

To me...you are missing the process of 'birthing.' The feelings/ideals/hopes of it all. So it is a kind of feeling forlorn. But never forget... that the entire process of having a baby, is also that you carried that child in your belly for 9 months. That to me, is ALSO the whole 'process' of having a baby. Not just it being more real or better than the next person only because one had a vaginal birth and the other did not.

I was TOTALLY ready to give birth. But my 1st child, ended up having to be an emergency, if not, I and/or my daughter's life, could have been very compromised. And my Husband a Widow. Why risk all that?
I chose a c-section with my 2nd, because I did not want to risk, rupture etc. because of what happened the 1st time. It was common sense. It was not about me... but about me AND my baby AND my Husband.. and doing what was best/safest for all of us. And of course my baby.

The main thing is, that baby AND you are fine.
It does not matter if you pushed or not at birth.
Your daughter, will not judge you on that.
My kids, do not, to me.
I IMMEDIATELY... felt SO connected to my kids, when I gave 'birth' to them, even if by c-section. I saw them immediately after/heard them cry/and instantly felt so touched and bonded to them.
I carried my kids for 9 months in my belly.
That, makes me a Mom.

I think you feel let down by the 'ideals' of it.
Versus what actually happened.
But your baby is here, and she made it.
And, you made it.
That is the only thing that matters.
Whether a woman had a natural birth or a c-section... they are still, a Mom and had a baby. It just is.
And it is beautiful. Either way.

Once you see/hold/bond with your baby, you will feel better.
Concentrate on that, not 'how' she was born. But that, she is here.

3 moms found this helpful

Hi there New Mama!!!
First of all Congratulations. I am sure your daughter is absolutely beautiful and what a miracle. God bless your family. I completely understand and I am sending hugs your way. I have to tell you I had three C-sections. The first two were not by choice. While I opted for pain meds I truly wanted to have a vaginal birth!!!!! It wasn't meant to be. My first child DD after 22 hours just wouldn't come out. The med staff was concerned because there were issues that she might have swalled meconium (sp) in Utero as when they broke my water it was discolored. I was induced a week after my due date. After 22 hours and her heart rate issues etc...I had to have a C. With my second I told the doc straight up I wanted a VBAC. All was going according to plan when the little bugger decided to be a breech baby!!!! Ugh...So second C-section! Becasue I had two C's already I opted to schedule #3.....

So here's the thing while you feel very disappointed the benefit you have is your daughter is here safely and will no doubt get stronger by the day. You are alive and healing and no matter the method of birthing you carried her and your womb provided life. Without God's hand and you she would not be here!!! At the end of the day you are a mother just like the rest of us and the kind of mother you are is what counts! Will you love your baby, meet her needs and have her grow up to be the person God, you as her parents want her to be. I know you're sad. You've been through a lot! On the flip side while you had a C-section, you bypassed an interuption to your "plumbing" no tears, no episiotimy, incontinence and God knows what else can happen as a result of vaginal deliveries.

If you plan on having more children, there is no reason why you can't try again and aim for a VBAC!!!

Best wishes

3 moms found this helpful

First of all, congratulations on your new baby!

I'm a 2 time c-section mom. The first was an emergency, the second was a scheduled.
With my first daughter, I had eclampsia and extremely high blood pressure. I was induced for almost 2 days and never got into a regular contraction pattern. My choices were to continue to induce and hope that it was successful, stay in the hospital until I delivered on my own, or have a c-section. The few times I did have contractions, my blood pressure spiked dangerously high. The chances that I would be able to deliver on my own were very unlikely. So, I opted for the c-section. I didn't want to risk having a stroke while giving birth.
As soon as she was born, they rushed her off to the NICU to make sure that she was ok. The hospital I was in did not allow me to have my baby with me in the recovery room. I was so out of it that I didn't honestly even realize what had happened. It was almost 3 hours before I held my baby for the first time.
I had several other complications from my surgery, including severe hemorraging. It was so hard to focus on the baby when I was so out of it. I don't really remember the first few days of her life. It breaks my heart that I don't really remember holding her for the first time. It took me awhile to come to terms with it all.
In the end, I bonded with my baby just fine. Once I got over the medical issues, I could focus on the baby.
I had someone tell me that I wasn't a "real" mother because I didn't give birth vaginally. My response was that just because you give birth, it doesn't make you a mother. What makes you a mother is the way you love and nurture that child once it's out of the womb.
Don't focus on what could have been. Shift your focus onto that sweet little baby. I guarantee you that you're not going to love her any less because you didn't have a vaginal birth. Also, there are lots of women that give birth vaginally that don't bond with their child immediately. You are going through a lot right now. You're hormones are all wacky because of the birth, you have so much stress dealing with a baby that's in the hospital. Give yourself a little time and stop beating yourself up. Know, in your heart, that you did the right thing for your little girl.
I would also suggest that you see if the hospital has a therapist on staff that you could speak to.

I know this is getting lengthy, but I want to address the feeling that you just laid there and did none of the work. Did the doctors carry that baby for 9 months? Did they love and nurture her from when she was just a tiny little bean? Were they the ones that felt the first kicks? Or dealt with all the discomforts and wonders of pregnancy? I don't think so! That was YOU! You grew that little girl inside of your belly. YOU! So, please don't ever say that the doctor's did all the work.
(hugs) and congrats!

3 moms found this helpful

I have never had a c section so I can't imagine how you feel. However, having dealt with disappointment as everyone has the only advice I can give is to focus on the good and try not to dwell on the disappointment. The outcome was the same, you have a beautiful baby. Doesn't really matter how the baby got here just that it is healthy and safe. If c- section were not an option for you the turnout could have been unbearable for you or worse for your baby. So I think if you can turn into that God there was an option to help me and my baby. I do not mean to squash your feelings I am just trying to make you see you were not denied you were blessed. From what I understand this does not mean you can never have a vaginal birth. Enjoy your baby and give yourself time to heal. Good luck!!

3 moms found this helpful

I was bummed when my first was born by c-section too. I pushed and pushed to no avail, and when it was clear that without breaking my pubic symphisis she would not come out, it was c-section time. I pushed for 4 hours, so it's not like we didn't give it a real shot either. My water broke the day before so we were getting close to the 24 hours after that. I was at 10 cm for 6 hours, pushing for 2, resting for 2, pushing for 2. They used pitocin to up the contractions at first and then terbutylene to stop them and pitocin again to start them back up.
But when my daughter was placed on my chest, those hormones flooded me and it was love at first sight. Fierce, determined, absolute love.

When my son was born, also by c-section, this time by choice, since during the first operation they said nothing was going through there, and they put him on my chest, I didn't get those immediate love hormones. Fortunately I knew I loved him and that those flooding hormones would come later. They did. Now my love for him is just as fierce, determined, and absolute as it is for my daughter. It took two or three weeks for him, I have to say. It was very weird. Honestly, I'm really glad this didn't happen with my first child, because it would have scared me to death. I was confident in myself the second time around, knowing I loved him, and knowing that the hormone love waves would come, and caring for him with all my heart as though the hormonal washes were already there. They will come, I promise you that.

The emotional/physical connection comes from your heart, not your vagina. It isn't pushing her out that gives you that, it's your actions and your hormones. The manner of birth doesn't make you love her and doesn't make her love you. You are her mother and that is where the love comes from. I suspect you are missing some of the hormonal emotional flood that you expected, kind of like me with my son. Trust that it will come, maybe in a couple of weeks, and as long as you love her like you feel it, the feelings will come. Those hormones aren't missing because of the birth manner though, it's just your body chemistry. It might not be the same with subsequent births, whether c-section or VBAC.
It took me a while to accept that yes, I am genetically inferior and would die in the wild incapable of giving birth, but we are evolutionarily designed to give birth at 16 to 18 years of age and we aren't advocating that either, now are we? My first was born when I was 36.
My friend, also determined to have a natural birth, had an emergency c-section because the cord was wrapped around her baby's neck and he coded. He was resuscitated on the table. She wanted a spiritual birth, and she has framed her experience to say that it was a spiritual birth because everyone necessary to keep him alive was there. You had a birthing experience, we all did, it just wasn't the one we wanted. You have a baby now, get used to not being in control. The universe laughs at your plans.
And I mean it about the hormones. They are wild the first few weeks, but believe me, the oxytocin waves of love WILL COME. THEY WILL COME.

3 moms found this helpful

I hope this helps. I have had two c-sections. The first one was an emergency c-section after premature rupture of membranes and labor for over 20 hours. I had low amniotic fluid, the baby was early, she was stuck and failing, pain medication did not work. All in all it was not an ideal situation. But you know what? While it would have been nice to have everything go smoothly, it didn't and now, three years later, it doesn't matter. I look at birthdays like I look at wedding days. Yes, they are lovely but they are not nearly as important as all the days that follow.

As for things feeling surreal, I think that happens to a lot of new parents whether birth is vaginal or by c-section. You had this life in you for months and then one day it is just outside of your body. They hand you a baby and send you home (my daughter was in the NICU so I know the waiting is hard) and it is just strange and wonderful and scary.

Things will get better once you get your baby home and the blues pass (you are in prime time for the baby blues).

Congratulations!

3 moms found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.