50 answers

Stay-at-Home Mother or Working Mother

I have posted this question to the site before, but now I am at a point were I really need to make a decision that is going to be the best for my family. I have until the middle of July to make my final decision and then there is no going back. I will have to choose to become a stay-at-home mother or working mother. Please give me advice on how you really feel and what works best for you. Also please give me information on what you either enjoy about staying-at-home or what you enjoy about working. I know I have worked since my children were born and my oldest is almost 10 so I do not know how it is being a stay-at-home mother, but I would love to know. I not only want to know the positives but also the negatives. I already feel like I know the positives and negatives of being a working mother. And besides the extra income (which is obviously important) and the interaction on a daily with adults I find I do not really have time for my kids like I should, but maybe I am not using my time right. But then I think if I was at home my time would be filled doing the job that new step of my life would require. I just got finished reading this really good book by Dr. Laura Schlessinger called In Praise of Stay at Home Moms and it was really good. I really appreciate any and all advice that anyone can give me on either side.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

I appreciate everyones positive and honest feelings on this topic. I have chosen to not stay-at-home at this point in my life. My husband and are looking at options of possibly in a year. That will give us a chance to pay off more bills and put money into the savings account. I know it may sound trivial but I am very concerned in this economy about not having a job. I feel like everything is so uncertain right now I am very lucky that I have a job and not only just any job but a well paying job and one that I enjoy. That was actually another factor in my decision making; as selfish as it sounds I actually really enjoy working and I felt like I was letting my own guilt make me feel like the worst person in the world because I worked outside of the home. In my neighborhood I would go to the park if I had days off during the week and sit and talk to woman that were there. We began talking about our kids then I would ask them if they enjoyed staying home and what I found was most of then told me they wish they never gave up their careers and they wish they could find a way to balance a part-time job. Although they defintely said they loved staying-home with the kids and a few mentioned having to go back to work because of the economy and now they are not able to get a good job because they have been out of the workforce. When I was on maternity leave I stayed home for 3 months with three kids and I know that was defintely the hardest thing I have ever done in my life. I actually think now that when I go to work I get to have some sanity. I know it sounds selfish but for now I did decided to keep my job.

Featured Answers

Try network marketing. I did and it works well for me. I work with Market America and have been successful. We have 4 kids and make it work. The business fits around what I already do in my days. I am very interested in health and wellness and the goal setting and accomplishments are rewarding. Besides, I feel it is good for the kids to see me do something else. It's great when you can share a goal of helping mothers stay home too!

F.,

This is definitely a challenging decision, but what has worked for me for the last 10 years (which is when I had my first born) is to work FROM HOME! If you are interested in what I do (or if anyone else is) please feel free to contact me: ____@____.com

Best,
C.

I love staying home with my boys. It is nice to be able to take them for a walk in the cool part of the morning, play games, read books, go to the library and many other things. I love playing outside and just being with my boys. It can be stressful though. I don't get a day off. I'm always cleaning or picking up messes. It is hard to always be doing the same thing day in and day out but still a lot of fun. There are time I want to have a part time job or something to be around adults since I don 't get o be around adults much. I sometimes feel like I don't always relate to adults like I need to because I am around children all day. I wouldn't trade staying home for anything though. When my kids are old enough to go to school all day I will go back to teaching so I get home when they get home, but rignt now staying home is the best thing for me and my family.

More Answers

F.,
You are very blessed to have a choice in this matter! So many do not! I, too, had a choice and I have never regretted choosing to stay home with my children. Yes, there were some financial struggles, but we made it. More importantly, our children "made it!" The time we lose with our kids we never will get again. Many people feel that they will spend "quality time" with their kids. One thing I learned over the years is that qualaity time comes as a result of quantity time. You simply cannot orchestrate those special times with kids on your planned schedule. They happen as a result of doing life together. There are no "do overs" here. Also, as much as I felt it was important being home with them when they were little, I believe it was almost more important when they became a little older. There are so many things pulling at our children and what they need most is a strong, secure home base. It's hard to provide that to the extent it's needed when you're rushing out the door in the morning and coming home late in the day to dinner, homework, extracurricular activities, etc., and you're exhausted. I believe the best gift you can give your children is not your presents, but your presence! Be there. You be the one to help solve the issues of the day. You be there to offer the encouragement when it is needed. You be the one to show up for the school parties. I promise you, you won't regret it! You may not be making significant invenstments in a bank account, but you most certainly will be making a very significant investment in the future of your kids!

1 mom found this helpful

Hi F.,

This is such a loaded question and one that requires you to decide what you value in your life at this moment and what you'll wish you'd done down the road. That said, I appreciate so much the diversity of answers and the encouragement the women on this site provide.

Motherhood is often filled with so much guilt - and much of it we women do to each other. Whether you stay home or work, you're in for criticism from someone. Life is complicated and necessity often chooses for us. However, you seem to have a choice this time. Whichever choice you make, make it without guilt, knowing that whatever time you spend with your kids, you can spend giving them your full love and attention.

I can only speak to staying home with my kids, since it's all I've done, and share the challenges and blessings. The difficulties I've experienced are loneliness, financial challenges and a loss of identity (for a while). I've gone out of my way to remedy this by making connections with other women (moms and not!)through church, the local coffee shop and a small part time job. Of course, the little job helps us make ends meet as well.

The identity issue was a little more difficult to face. I had to let go of defining myself through my work and allow myself to be nurturer, teacher, doctor, counselor, adoring mom, household manager etc and know it's the ultimate role (BTW, it's the ultimate for SAHM AND working moms!). I enjoy this time of my life with little ones.

My mother died about 2 years ago and something she said to me before she died has radically changed my mindset. She said, "I've worked so hard all my life and thought I was finally going to get to relax and enjoy my grandchildren." She was only 55 when she died.

So, I have to say, while the above challenges - were very real to me and required my addressing them - the blessings staying home has brought me far outweigh the difficulties. Every morning, my oldest child wakes me with a brilliant smile and says, "It's morning time, Mommy! Let's play!!!" Instead of saying, "No, I have to go to work." I get to say, "OK!" She hugs and kisses me till I get up. Aaahh…..

I get to explore the world all over again through their eyes. I don't have much in the way of wardrobe or extras but I spend my days delighted by the antics of my babies and their sweet ways of expressing themselves. I don't have to hear about their latest accomplishments secondhand from a sitter. I wouldn't trade that for anything.

I know I get a little mushy talking about my children but I make no apologies for it. I'm in love with them!

F., you have to figure out what is best for you and your family. Make that choice from desire, not guilt. Whatever choice you make, be in the moment you're in. If you're at work, get it done. If you're home, enjoy every minute. I know you'll make the choice that's best for your children and you.

M.

1 mom found this helpful

Please keep in mind that most of the responses you get from this site will be from Stay at Home Moms so we have already made this decision and decided to stay. We may sound a little biased. I am a SAHM. I made my decision because I found that when my children were little I was rushing to get my work done so I could leave work on the deadline set by daycare or extra curricular activites. When I was with the kids I was more tired and had to worry about feeding them and cleaning the house in my off hours.
This way I am there for them when they need me and even when they don't. My daughter is 15 and I am sad that she will be leaving me so soon. Your ten year old will soon be leaving too. I treasure all the time I spent with my daughter. I have also been able to spend time in the classroom with my 2 kids. When they are sick I don't have to feel guilty about not coming into work. They can do all the extra curricular because I can drive them. A big consideration on my part is that I did some things I shouldn't have as a teenager :) My mom worked and I was home alone. I promised myself that when I first got married that it was more important for me to make sure that I could monitor them while at home. Even more important that I be there for them when they were teenagers. This is a time when many of my friends kids have changed paths and done things that you would never have expected from such good little kids.
I say stay at home and enjoy your time with them. Make them feel valuable. Try your darndest to keep them busy and out of trouble. Have a messy home with hot dogs for dinner if need be. When they're gone you wont have the luxury of being able to make this choice because it will be made for you. That's when you will go back to work, even if the new job you go back to isn't as good as the one you are now considering.

1 mom found this helpful

I am not sure of your kids age, but when they are older than 3 you will have them in preschool=kids not at home=more money you have to invest in them. At the older age, you will need to start monitoring your kids activities, carpooling for sports etc etc....it's tough. I do miss working ft though, and if you're having too hard of a time deciding, you should really look into part time. If you can't do it with your current employer, find a different company right now while you are still marketable.

I am a pt sahm, and I have a great part time daycare situation and bring in enough to pay for our summer vacations. That's good enough for me. Good luck with this.

First, you need to figure out if the loss of your income will be a hardship on the family. There's always sacrifices to be made. If you need the money for necessities, then you might consider working from home, or a part-time job that allows you to be home when your children aren't in school. If your income has been a nice padding for extras, then you may have to exercise restraint on the number of times you eat out or see movies or luxury purchases, but there are creative alternatives.

I worked full-time before I got married. After marriage I was a full-time mom. (My husband has a son from a previous marriage, and we have one of our own.) It was difficult not to have "my own" money, and it also meant that my husband had to pick up a second job so that I could stay home. I've thought about getting back into the work force, but the more time spent being a stay-at-home mom, the better I get at it, and the less I'm enticed by working for an income. I may review that when the youngest is in school. The challenges of staying at home are outside social contact. My husband and I will double date with other friends. I have hobbies that I pursue, such as crafts and art projects. My husband will watch the kids for awhile, so that I can have "me" time. I like the fact that the values that my husband and I have are the ones that our children are learning. I also get to see the little things that happen everyday. I'm there when my kids need someone to talk to. I have more time to devote to managing the household (cleaning, meal planning, cooking). I do have to say that I couldn't do this without the support of my husband.

I hope this was helpful. Good luck!

Hi F.-I think part time work is the ultimate situation. It gives us JUST enough of a break. I feel like working days/wk helps me be a better mom as I'm not as overwhelmed with the day to day tasks. I appreciate my kids AND my husband a little more. Good luck!

My husband and I decided that I would stay home after we had our second and third children (twins), and although we've had some lean times. I know with all of my heart that this is what God intended for us. I wouldn't trade these years home with my children for anything, those are something that you will never be able to get back. The work force will still be out there if and when you do decide to go back to it, your kids will be grown. We've had to change some priorities, for example going out to dinner a lot, new clothes, new cars....but I also feel that the Lord has provided for our every need, we've never had to go with out the basics. I just feel that we've been blessed in our decision. I'm not sure why you feel that you can never go back once your decision is made, but just follow your heart. Another thought would be to find something you can do part time from home while your kids are in school(not sure how old all your kiddos are). I do Pampered Chef(not intended to be advertising or promoting, its just what I do) on the side....helps to earn a few extra bucks without sacrificing my family for it. Best wishes in your decision.

I just wanted to encourage you to try coming home! It has rewards beyond what I can describe, and all of the research backs of the fact that kids of SAHMs are healthier emotionally and physically.

Being a SAHM is not easy, but it is worth it. Challenges I face: (1) Having to schedule my time - having a plan helps. (2) Feeling isolated - make sure to have outside fellowship, like with a women's Bible study or a MOMS club. (3) Less money - not really an issue because staying home is so much cheaper than working in terms of the extra expenses of working (clothes, gas, food out, etc.).

Good luck! Blessings!

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.