19 answers

Starting Solid Food

Hi Moms-

My baby is almost 5 mo's old and I'm thinking of starting her on solid food soon. My pediatrician says that there is no need to start her on baby cereal first b/c there is no nutritional value in it and that she should simply eat what I eat (just pureed) Any thoughts on this?? He says that babies should eat everything and that they get allergies to food b/c they weren't ever exposed to it. He says bring on the berries, peanut butter, everything but honey. I've heard that it's better to start w/veggies as opposed to fruits so that baby gets used to veggies, is that true? And what is the benefit of starting w/orange veggies? Is there any real benefit to start w/solids before 6 mo's? How did you know when your babies were ready?? I want to make my own baby food w/organic produce. Any suggestions on cooking? Steam or boil? What type of equipment did you use? If I have to supplement w/ jarred food, I'd like to try "Earth's Best" anyone used this brand? Sorry so many ?'s but first time mom, new at this and wanna get it right! Thanks!!!

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thanks so much for all the amazing advice! I noticed that when I was eating DD was staring intently at me and eyeing my fork. She couldn't look away so I think she is ready now. I'm going to start DD on Organic Brown Rice Cereal & see how she likes that. I think I won't be so strict on what I give her next in terms of veg vs fruit., will try a large variety of foods but will keep the harder ones to digest for later on. I don't think I'll bother to invest in a food maker (they are expensive!) sounds like they don't work any better than steaming in a pot / cuisinart method anyway. In any case, it will be fun to see her try new things! Thanks again!!!

Featured Answers

The exception that I've heard of and have followed is to wait to introduce foods where there is a family history of allergies to that food. Also, nut butters can be a choking hazard, so only spread them very thinly. Good luck.

i knew my baby was ready at 5 months cause how much i was empty cause she had a bigger apatite and how she never got full of my milk( or if you bottle feed how much bottles is she drinking?) i started her on fruit for a week or 2 then on veggies (beach nut cause thats the brand i like most) i gave her apple sauce and baby cereal mixed together, but its up to you and what ever you think will work for her and you

Updated

i knew my baby was ready at 5 months cause how much i was empty cause she had a bigger apatite and how she never got full of my milk( or if you bottle feed how much bottles is she drinking?) i started her on fruit for a week or 2 then on veggies (beach nut cause thats the brand i like most) i gave her apple sauce and baby cereal mixed together, but its up to you and what ever you think will work for her and you

More Answers

Hello! My son is 5 months today and I started feeding him solids at 4 - 4 1/2 months as I did with my daughter. My daughter took to solids like a fish to water. With my son it took a few trys until he got the gist of it. Your baby needs to have good head and neck support so they do not choke. If they show great interest in other people eating and no longer have the tongue thrust outward reflex it is a good time to start.

We added rice cereal to my daughter's food but I do not for my son. He appears to be a purest and prefers the food unaltered. I use Earth's Best and did for my daughter too (I LOVE IT) and my Mother-in-Law purees steamed squash, yams, and pears for him and freezes it in ice-cube trays for him. My sister uses the Beaba Baby Cook where you can cook/steam and puree in one machine (not cheap but she LOVES it) and has used it for her two boys to make all kinds of things. She supplememnts with Earth's Best as well and we have not had any problems.

The following links are for recipes and the Beaba cook system. You will know when you and your baby are ready and that is when you should do it. As far as peanut butter and berries...I would say 4-6 months is young for peanut butter as it is hard to swallow and I would fear choking more than anything and berries can be VERY HARSH on the digestive track of babies...their poop will burn their bottom skin due to the acid content...I steared clear of both until my daughter could sit in a high chair and eat table food. I plan to do the same for my son. As far as veggies vs fruit first...I started with veggies for my daughter because I had heard the same thing and I do not feel it did anything miraculous or had any real purpose. She was still partial to the fruits and grew up to be a picky eater anyway...I am not sure there is a way to combat that? Anyway....hope this helped!

http://www.wholesomebabyfood.com/stage1_homemade_baby_foo...

http://www.williams-sonoma.com/products/beaba-babycook-ba...

1 mom found this helpful

Ok, sorry this is gonna be long, and I don't have time to read everyone else's, but here goes:

I started my son at about 5 mos. He had been given the go ahead to eat solids because of showing all the signs of readiness. At that point I just waited until I could tell he was ready. This is one of those ridiculous but true statements, like "you'll just know when you are in labor versus braxton hicks". One day he was just starving, nursing didnt cut it, and after a couple of days of that, I started. He scarfed the food without spilling a drop and continued to be a wonderful eater. I had no plans to start him at any particular time, just waited til he was ready.

I did do cereal. At the time, that was what doc recommended. Now I have read you don't have to. I personally would follow whatever the doc recommends, he sounds like he is totally current on the latest science. I liked to have cereal on hand to thicken stuff, and you can also make your own for that reason or to give oatmeal, by blending whole or rolled oats (not quick cooking) to make them smaller.

As for the allergies- I read a lot about baby nutrition. No particular reason, I just read any article I see about it to be informed. The current research is what your doctor advised you. I read this when I was getting ready to start my son on solids. It made absolutely NO sense to me to say that food allergies are so rampant now because we feed them too early, when that is what they used to always do, and the allergies are pretty recent. And when you look at other countries that feed their babies spices and shellfish and peanuts at 6 mos but don't have near the problem we do with allergies, it made sense to me that the waiting to prevent allergies was a silly line of thinking. I fed my son everything that I wanted. I had a few things I avoided but those were about the ability to digest, not allergies. I didn't do milk until 12 mos because they can't digest it. But I did yogurt at 8 or 9, it is not the same as whole milk. I did peanut butter too, as well as ate it the whole time I was nursing. I did not do honey, that is about botulism poisoning, not allergies. I did berries and tomatoes and citrus, but I waited until about 10 mos or so just to give him time to work up to them because the acid can upset their tummies or cause diaper rash. Plus, making my own, it seemed to take forever to work through the produce section, I was never at a loss for what to introduce next. I swear it took me like 5 mos to cover them all. I gave mine seasonings early on, I just introduced them with the wait rule like everything else.

The veggies first versus fruit first is just a matter of opinion. Everyone tends to do what they want first, and baby usually does fine. I personally did the veggies first, starting with yellow/orange veggies, just because they seemed like they would be the easiest to digest. Green veggies are a little more difficult, as well as some fruits. I didn't follow any strict schedule and I did introduce bananas and applesauce earlier on.

A great book for helping answer all these questions and everything else you don't even know to ask yet is The Super Baby Food Book by Ruth Yaron. She gives really great info on what to feed when, how to choose produce, how to cook it. You can follow as much or as little as you want, but just the section on how to prepare the foods is invaluable. I still use it and my son is 2 1/2. She already figured out which ways to cook work best with certain foods. I did a lot of baking. I could put squash and sweet potatoes all on a cookie sheet, get it all cooked at once and then puree and freeze. My steamer didn't hold that much and it took longer. Steaming is better than boiling, but even with steaming you lose nutrients. I used my rice cooker basket that is a steamer, the oven, and a tiny Cuisinart food processor and a Magic Bullet. A couple of regular ice cube trays, some ziploc freezer bags, and lots of aluminum foil and you are pretty much good to go. Some things blended better in the magic bullet, and some in the cuisinart. Most things do not come out as perfectly pureed as storebought, but it seemed like that made for an easy transition to chunky stuff for my son. He never liked anything very thin.

I used Earth's Best but it was hard to find in my stores. I used Gerber and Beechnut too, usually organic. I so rarely used jarred food that I didn't worry about it much. I always had a few jars on hand to take to restaurants and that was it.

I think that was all your questions. Here are my favorite babyfood websites:

http://www.homemade-baby-food-recipes.com/ (has a monthly newsletter that is awesome -highlights a fruit or veggie, gives recipes, giveaways, and even news about recalls which is helpful)

http://www.wholesomebabyfood.com/

www.weelicious.com (a babyfood blog by a mommy, has a facebook page so you can get recipes daily on your facebook newsfeed if you have one)

The top 2 websites are full of great info on just about everything you might need to know about what to feed, or how, when, etc.

Sorry that is so long. Hope it helps, and good luck!

*Edit to add*
Here is a link that talks about the most recent advice on peanuts, from March of Dimes website, which is reputable:
http://www.marchofdimes.com/professionals/14332_1819.asp#...
and if you want to read the actual study results with all it's jargon:
http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/cgi/reprint/124/Sup...

If you want to give peanut butter to small babies and toddlers, thinning it with milk keeps it from being so sticky and possibly filling their throat. Also, if you use more natural peanut butters, they are no where near as sticky to begin with.

1 mom found this helpful

i knew my baby was ready at 5 months cause how much i was empty cause she had a bigger apatite and how she never got full of my milk( or if you bottle feed how much bottles is she drinking?) i started her on fruit for a week or 2 then on veggies (beach nut cause thats the brand i like most) i gave her apple sauce and baby cereal mixed together, but its up to you and what ever you think will work for her and you

Updated

i knew my baby was ready at 5 months cause how much i was empty cause she had a bigger apatite and how she never got full of my milk( or if you bottle feed how much bottles is she drinking?) i started her on fruit for a week or 2 then on veggies (beach nut cause thats the brand i like most) i gave her apple sauce and baby cereal mixed together, but its up to you and what ever you think will work for her and you

i have an almost-7 month old, and she's my second. i tend to be a little more cautious than your ped with food. first off, are you breastfeeding? b/c there is no extra iron in breastmilk, and the natural stores of iron are depleted by about 6 months, i think it's important to start with an iron-fortified cereal. rice tends to be gentlest, but neither of my girls really liked it, so we did about a week on it, once a day, then moved to oatmeal. now we do a new food every 4 days. i haven't made much baby food this time around, but there are some great cookbooks out there for blender baby food. the cooking technique will depend on what you're making, and most cookbooks can guide you through that. however, we do use earth's best, and i *love* it for the sheer variety and lack of additives. she gets the same new food every day for 4 days at breakfast along with a little baby oatmeal, and then whatever else for dinner. they used to say starting veggies was better to promote more veggies later, but it doesn't seem to make much difference, and i think experts are starting to say that, too. the benefit to orange veggies is that babies tend to like them more. i would start with either an orange veggie (milder flavor than green ones) or a fruit... we've been through pears, apples, sweet potatoes, carrots, peas, green beans, avacado (fresh), bananas (fresh), and pumpkin... next up for us is spinach! although we didn't go in that order. your ped is right in a sense about allergies coming from not being exposed to a food and then suddenly being exposed to it, but i think a little more caution when the possible side effect is (at least) misery for your child or (at worst) an anaphylactic reaction. also, cow's milk/ dairy products like yogurt and cheese should be later, closer to 9 or 10 months, even a year. in fact, i think really only yogurt and cottage cheese or other soft cheeses are suggested before a year old. i would definitely not do peanut butter until at least 18 months, purely b/c it's thick and sticky and hard for those little tongues to manipulate enough to swallow... plus the reaction to peanut butter tends to be a bad one. we started solids at 5 months b/c our little one was bursting into tears out of frustration watching us eat, kept trying to grab our food, etc. my first one didn't do that, so we waited until she was a good 6 months old. i think that hits most of your questions, good luck!

Hi J.-

We started on cereal first, less because of its nutritional value and more for what it teaches the children to do - open and swallow. The first cereals are pretty runny and general mixed well with BM. We have used rice first then progressed to oatmeal. Follow your baby's lead on this issue. My little girl was content to slurp her foods for ever. My prince on the otherhand has been a champ as we have "dried" things out a bit to almost paste. Signs of readiness include sitting up, reaching for your food, mouthing motions, and not being fully content on BM. Follow your gut, if you are asking this question, than the baby is most likely ready (even if you aren't! LOL!) We started my daughter closer to 6 months but our son started at about 4.5/5 months. Neither one appears to have a probelm with solids. My daughter nursed till about 15 months and my son is still nursing as a champ too so I would not be too worried about that.

The best time to introduce food is lunch. They are not famished. We did "lunch" for several weeks before moving the cereal into "breakfast" postion and continued with lunch. Dinner was the last meal we added both times.

We have fed both our children things that we eat. This time however, we are taking a little bit different approach. We are "making" our own baby food. We are still following the approach laid out by the baby food companies though and started on single ingredient items without any spices. Gerber published a check list of fruits and veggies and what "color" of the eating rainbow they fall into. I used that as a guide to what we are making and he is eating.

We would use the rice or oatmeal as thickener as needed. We did primarily fruits and veggies and only recently have introduced meats. We started with bananas and then added a veggie and then applesauce then a veggie and so on. I was unable to remove pea shells and green bean pods so we buy those from gerber but the squash, carrots, etc. we make ourselves. I have found that the carrots can be too dry and crumbly so I add a bit of applesauce. I think this makes them a bit sweeter too. I have since then introduced blueberries and strawberries but they were tastes mixed in with something I knew he liked and was not allergic to like pears or applesauce.

Our prince really loves his food and grabs constantly at my plate so we may be moving on to more complex tastes soon. We have reached a stage where sometimes the meat and veggie get mixed together instead of being fed seperately. His attention span on his own dish is not always so good so mixing it is faster. The first spices appear to be onion, garlic and parsleys so that is what we might begin adding in a few more weeks.

Food is also fun. Now that we have a tooth, we have started playing (and occassionally eating) banana bits (not dehydrated stuff, just pieces from an actual banana) and cheerios. I do not like the yogurt drops as those are a milk exposure and I feel that is still too early. He likes to squish things constantly! LOL.

As far as the allergies are concerned, I am not so sure about it just being an exposure issue. It think there may be genes and environmental factors involved so I would move a bit more slowly than the doctor is recommending. I was very careful not to exposure my daughter to wheat or eggs as much as possible until closer to 9 or 12 months. We avoided cows milk until she turned 12 months. We wait on peanut butter till closer to 18 months. My recommendation would be to take it slow, especially with an infant. Introduce one new thing once every two to three days at a time so you can watch for reactions - different bowls, irritation on the neck and face, etc.

Go and get yourself a small food processor. (We tried some of those steam and mash baby food makers and it was a joke!) We like our Cuisinart Mini-Prep® Plus Processor (DLC-2A) since it does not take up a ton of space and seems to hold just the right amount of food for making a few days meals. Use steamed veggies, canned fruits (in juice, not syrup), fresh fruits, browned/boiled meats with broth and mix it all up till you get the consistency your child is use to. We also splurged for a few BEABA Multiportion Freezer Trays. These I LOVE! And the portions are perfect for him right now.

Whatever you decide to do, have fun with it and keep a positive attitude. Eating is a new adventure every day!

~C.

Okay, so I know that when you start solids it is a confusing time. First of all calm down and know that we have all been there. I have always been a little wierd on starting solids with my 6 children. I have ALWAYS started with the fruits and sweet veggies with the them. My reasoning is this: if you want them to learn how to eat solid foods and start them on the things that don't taste as good, they aren't going to want to eat and therefore not eat. With that being said, I start them on the fruits (which are naturally sweet) and those veggies like sweet peas and corn and sweet potatoes. I have never made my own baby food, it was an issue of time for us ( and the fact that I don't buy/eat certain veggies myself, yet I want the kids to have that exposure to them---so we bought the jarred food. As far as the allergies go, be slow about starting a new food. Don't overload your child with a ton of new foods, because if they do have a reaction, you won't know what it is to. Start one new food and feed only that one for a week until you know how they will react. As the cereal goes I wouldn't feed that in the morning as breakfast, I usually waited until dinner time. It has more bulk to it and will fill the child up......hence they would usually sleep longer periods in between feedings. Good luck and just go with what you child seems to want. If they are having a hard time eating/swallowing the food, wait a while and then try again. There isn't a set age at where they will start the solids....they will eat them when they are ready.
J.---SAHM of 6 (7th due in July)

The exception that I've heard of and have followed is to wait to introduce foods where there is a family history of allergies to that food. Also, nut butters can be a choking hazard, so only spread them very thinly. Good luck.

I started my son at 4 months with Rice Cereal. And then at 5 months veggies, and at 6 months fruits. At 13 months, with the approval of our pedi, I gave him peanut butter on toast. After throwing up everytime I gave him peanut butter, we had him allergy tested. He is allergic to Peanut Butter (severely) and a whole list of other foods. Allergies do NOT run in our family, so I never thought he would have this issue.

My daughter didnt get anything other than breast milk until she was 6 months. She didnt have peanut butter until a friend accidentally gave it to her around her 3rd birthday. She doesnt have any allergies. We've had her tested.
My feeling is, Why rush it?

I used Earth's Best for both of my kids. They loved it, and I loved the simple organic ingredients.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.