T.W. asks from Cortland, NY on March 26, 2012
Starting Organized Sports/activities So Young
I have a pretty athletic little guy who I've tried signing up for organized activities (soccer, sports class thru rec, swimming) but he just never seems to be that in to following along with the class. At home, all he wants to do is play soccer, shoot his basketball, play w/ his golfclubs, run, bike etc...and he does well at it. He's 3 and will be turning 4 soon. There are so many classes around here for 3 and 4 year olds and so many of the mom's sign their kids up for them, so I guess I do too because I don't want him missing out...but I feel like it's a waste of money when he goes and doesn't follow along. I guess he's just too young still? I've decided we will only be doing preschool for the rest of the year, 2 days a week, and the rest of the time he can just play outside which makes him happy. At what age did your kids start to get in to an activity? And, my real question is... Did you feel like they missed out by not starting so young?
Featured Answers
B.C. answers from Dallas on March 26, 2012
My DD is 4 1/2 and I just now got her into gymnastics. Any younger that that (for her) would have been a waste. She loves it and I'm proud of how well she's doing.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
J.T. answers from New York on March 26, 2012
Unless the child is kind of driving organized classes or you as the mom need a break, looking back I think they're a waste of money. If your son is happy just playing outside, you're lucky! He's happy and you're saving money.
4 moms found this helpful
M.J. answers from Sacramento on March 26, 2012
Our oldest is nine and has never participated in team sports. He hasn't been interested. Instead, we've signed him up for classes as things come up that interest him. He did karate for a while, lost interest, then Parkour for years, lost interest. He's now in a Japanese animation drawing class and it's only a month long ... perfect!
At three, it's hard for any child to stay focused and interested. It may be several years before he finds something he really wants to do.
I don't believe in overbooking kids. Ours are in one activity at a time. It's never felt like they were missing out on anything because they weren't interested in team sports or staying with one activity over the long term.
3 moms found this helpful
☆.A. answers from Pittsburgh on March 26, 2012
IMO, 3 and 4 are too early to expect "real" participation. 5 should be good. Let him play. Once the schedules and shuttling around really start-you'll wonder why you were in a hurry! LOL
3 moms found this helpful
A.C. answers from Savannah on March 26, 2012
I think that one cannot say "he's too young", OR that he's the right age, because there's not a magic number where everyone on earth is suddenly old enough to be into it.
It depends on your child's interests and ability to listen to directions, and it depends on your child's coach as well. There's so many different thoughts out there, so it really depends on the mentality of the coach, the other parents, the other kids, all that.
There's nothing wrong with team sports (I think they're SO important in many ways, if done well). But what we try to do is give team AND individual activities for them to be more well rounded. But you don't have to pay a league at 3 years old.....just look for other outlets. I'll tell you that my 5 year old can't really tell you much that he did at 3. We provide opportunities because it's fun for us AND them. The lessons learned aren't necessarily how to do a front right cross or to sweep the field. The lessons are more intangible at that age.....and can be made in other ways with family and friends. But don't accept a broad general answer of "he's too young" or "he's old enough". Only you, the parent, can see what's going on with him. But for our personal experience: our eldest was great at 4, our youngest is 2 1/2 and we are NOT shopping 3 year old leagues for him yet. He may be more interested in individual stuff, where our oldest loved the team stuff.
2 moms found this helpful
A.M. answers from Kansas City on March 26, 2012
This is coming from a HUGE sports fan! (adding that I also coach sports)
Our daughter started soccer at four...she wanted to, so we gave it a shot. She's now almost 7 and plays on a competitive team. We weren't sure about going competitive but she wanted to play on an all girls team...so she tried out made it. They were HORRIBLE last fall. This spring after playing indoor they are improving at a phenomenal rate.
Our son just turned four in January. He is not ready! He plays, practices with his sister...but he's not ready. We are shooting for the fall when he's closer to five.
You and your little one are not missing out on much. If you feel he's not ready hold off til he's closer to five. Many coaches at that age are just parents who got roped into it. They more than likely have no idea what they are doing. So your child is not missing out.
2 moms found this helpful
D.M. answers from Denver on March 26, 2012
I think he is too young. My son just turned 4. My theory is let them have fun for now. There will be plenty of time later. I won't start mine until about 6 or so I think
2 moms found this helpful
K.M. answers from Chicago on March 26, 2012
We tried my son at 4, just not ready for it - it is a personal maturity thing. I would stop signing him up for these things is you feel no one is actually getting anything out of it that you can not provide at home.
2 moms found this helpful
B.C. answers from Dallas on March 26, 2012
My DD is 4 1/2 and I just now got her into gymnastics. Any younger that that (for her) would have been a waste. She loves it and I'm proud of how well she's doing.
1 mom found this helpful
Email