B.H. asks from Annapolis, MD on August 01, 2006
Smile's Diapers
Has anyone tried the Smile's brand diapers from Sam's Club? I was recently shopping there and noticed that it's a $15 difference between the box of Smiles and the box of Pampers Cruisers. I've been a Cruisers fan for the past 3 1/2 years and ended up going with them but I'm wondering if the Smiles are adequate substitutes. I've got 2 in diapers right now and just thought it might be more economical to try a cheaper product ~ I just didn't want to end up with 160+ diapers that I hate.
Featured Answers
A. answers from Philadelphia on August 03, 2006
Hello B.,
I personally like the cruisers and find that even though they are more expensive, in the long run they are cheaper. My girlfriend however says she used them in the past on her little girl and they gave her rashes and would not recommend them, but that was 10 years ago, they might be better now, but I would just stay with the ones that you are more comfortable with.
Good Luck,
A.
Mother of a 3 year old and one on the way
1 mom found this helpful
L.S. answers from Philadelphia on August 09, 2006
Hi B....My daughter is past the diaper stage, but the best diapers I've ever used is LUV's. The quality is great and the price was even better.
J. answers from New York on August 02, 2006
hi B.,
i haven't tried the sam's club diapers...but when I was using diapers (about a year ago) I started to buy the walmart brand...white cloud I think...I never had a problem...and they are cheaper too.
Jen
More Answers
A. answers from Philadelphia on August 03, 2006
Hello B.,
I personally like the cruisers and find that even though they are more expensive, in the long run they are cheaper. My girlfriend however says she used them in the past on her little girl and they gave her rashes and would not recommend them, but that was 10 years ago, they might be better now, but I would just stay with the ones that you are more comfortable with.
Good Luck,
A.
Mother of a 3 year old and one on the way
1 mom found this helpful
R.G. answers from York on August 02, 2006
Hi B.,
I'm also a mom of 3 recently under 4. They are now 4, almost 3 and 8 months.
I am a cloth diapering mom but have used disposables on many occasions and have never used the name brands (I've tried samples of them), always the discount ones. I wouldn't see an issue with the Smile's brand ones, and as many have said you can return them if you're not happy.
One thing I have found regardless of what brand I have used is that performance has more to do with how the diaper is put on than the quality of the diaper itself. Except for a very few, all diapers now have an elastic piece just inside the leg. Once the diaper is securely fastened, it's always best to take your finger and run it along the inside of the diaper from the back to the front at the leg and gently expand the elastic as you do that with a finger and "activate" the no leak barrier. LOL. Sounds funny to say, but it always seems to work for me with any brand of disposables, and I have tried just about ALL of them. Since I don't have a Sam's club membership I can't try the Smile's though.
Also, I have found being a cloth diapering mom I think I tend to change diapers on my little ones a lot quicker than most even when using disposables, so I'm sure that in some cases it has made a big difference in the smell factor that some have talked about.
Give them a shot, it couldn't hurt. And I too HIGHLY recommend the White Cloud brand at Wal-Mart. Even the ones in the yellow packaging, I forget what they're called. Very inexpensive and worked great for us.
Good Luck!
Rolinda
J.M. answers from Washington DC on August 17, 2006
Well, it has been a few years since we used the Smile's diapers but you may still want to hear about our experience. We tried them because as you noticed they were a whole lot cheaper than the "brand names" however, after using them for about a month our daughter developed an extreme reaction to them and experieced a rash that required antibiotics to cure. It was not due to lack of parenting, we changed her almost hourly it seemed, and as soon as we switched to another brand (Huggies Supreme I think)the problem cleared up and we never had another experience like that. It turns out our daughter does have sensitive skin, like me, and according to our pediatrician, the more generic the diapers the less skin protection they have. Hope this helps!
A.L. answers from York on August 01, 2006
Hello, I used Smiles for my kids. I would recommend them.I thought they were just fine and easier on the budget for sure.
A.
M.G. answers from Harrisburg on August 02, 2006
Depending on the age of your children. With my son, it seemed like he was pooping like an adult so the cheaper diapers couldn't keep things in. Not until he was almost 3 did I use them (my kids are 10 mths apart so I did the double diaper duty also!).
A.C. answers from Boston on August 02, 2006
I also use the White Cloud brand from Walmart. I had used them and then used Huggies and Luvs and actually switched back to the White Cloud because I liked them better. They have a nice stretchy waistband and I have never had any leaks. You can get smaller packages and also a bigger box (i believe it is about 15 dollars for the bigger box). Hope this helps.
~A.
M. answers from Providence on August 01, 2006
Hi B.!
I have not tried the Smiles brand, but BJ's has a Berkely and Jensen brand which is their generic brand, and they are 8-18 dollars cheaper than the brand names. I used to be a Huggies Supreme only person, but now I won't even look at the brand name stuff.
They might be worth a try, even if you don't like them, you are still losing less than you would trying one of the name brands.
Also, just a suggestion, check to see if Sam's has any coupons at the front desk. Sometimes BJ's does.
Good luck!
H. answers from Washington DC on August 02, 2006
I haven't tried the Sam's club version but the B&J version from BJ's is probably the same. I have twins and anything amount of money I can get saved is worth it....but after using Pampers or Huggies I did find that these "generic" were very generic and that they leaked which neither Pampers or Huggies did. The hassle of dealing with leaking and a less fitting diaper outweighed the cost to me. Also, I know someone who bought a box - tried a couple - hated them and returned them back to BJ's without a problem. Good luck !
Email