T.W. asks from Grand Ledge, MI on January 10, 2008
Siblings of Friends
I would like lots of opinions on this:
There is a current trend in our small town that siblings do ALL things together--meaning when my children ask a friend over they have to include the sibling. Most are same gender, although not close in age.
I just don't get it!!! I would never insist on this. I feel they have a right to have their own friends and private time.
What do you think?
So What Happened?™
Thanks everyone for your responses. It's nice to know most everyone agrees with me. I was beginning to feel I was the only one not raising my kids this way. I do agree these younger siblings need to learn how to deal with disappointment, make their own friends, and not always get their own way! I am going to start letting my kids pick who they want to play with, and not let other parents dictate what happens!
More Answers
D.K. answers from Sioux City on January 12, 2008
I don't buy into that at all. I know the reasoning behind it. They hate to think anyone is left out, but I think its better to teach your children to be happy for other people. I don't want my children always feeling sorry for themselves because they didn't get invited. I want them to learn to be happy that their brother or sister were invited and get to do something fun. Later they will have a turn at getting to do something fun. What are you going to do when they are older and one is talented at swimming and gets on the swim team while the other isn't? Sorry swimmer you can't because you sibling isn't? I have friends that have seven kids. I couldn't invite them all even if I wanted to. I couldn't fit them and mine in the vehicle.
1 mom found this helpful
J.S. answers from Salt Lake City on January 11, 2008
Is it with all your child's friends? or just one friend has to have there siblings come over too. That is the wierdest thing I've ever heard (well, not ever but ykwim).
I'd be for starting a new trend too. It almost sounds like someone wants you to babysit. I've read articles where its not even good to have twins do everything together because they need to learn to associate them selves as individuals and not as a couple.
Good luck on this.
1 mom found this helpful
L.N. answers from Benton Harbor on January 11, 2008
I agree with you...some of these kids may have nothing in common and it becomes a burden to entertain them. You aren't responsible for babysitting somebodys 5 or 6 kids, just because your child is friends with one of them! I say put your foot down and start a NEW trend!
~L.
1 mom found this helpful
S.F. answers from Benton Harbor on January 11, 2008
We seem to have gotten into a similar trend here. Ours has also stretched to include birthdays.
I have tried to be specific when I extend the invite. For example, I would suggest that when she has a next dr. appointment for one, that we would be happy to have the closer firend come and play. Or that Mommy and the other kids can have a special day while one of them comes over. Anyway, I try to make it sound like I am doing them a favor. But honestly I haven't figured much out myself.
1 mom found this helpful
C.V. answers from Grand Rapids on January 11, 2008
Hi Tamamra,
I encourage my kids to have different friends and would never assume if one son went to their friends house that the other would to. Sometimes it's nice to have one on one time with my kids. When my older one goes to play I like to have that time with my younger one. I agree with Lacy and you should start a new trend. Good luck.
Chris
1 mom found this helpful
T.S. answers from Grand Rapids on January 12, 2008
I dont agree with siblings having to do all things together. I have a 2 year old daughter and 3 year old son and I think it is very important for them to get to do things without the other around. I think it will help build personal growth and confidence.
I agree that your children should get to have their own friends over and time with that friend...not their little sister/brother tagging along...espically if there is a big age differnce.
Also it will give the parents that special one on one time with the child that stays homes...I know I always appricate that time b/c it doenst happen often.
1 mom found this helpful
K.D. answers from Salt Lake City on January 11, 2008
I'm going to agree with the other mothers and say I think it's odd to require to that all their kids come over when you invite one. (Sounds like people want some free babysitting to me.) I think you are right that every kids has the right to choose their friends and have time alone with just that friend, not all their siblings, too.
This is one of those unfortunate times when you're going to have to bring it up with the mothers and it might be uncomfortable. But if you just say something like, "Tommy would like to have some time just to play with Billy and I'm sure Billy would like some time away from his siblings." then maybe they'll get the hint. If not, you'll probably just have to be blunt about it.
1 mom found this helpful
J.M. answers from St. Cloud on January 11, 2008
I agree with you. Children need to develop friendships and siblings need to learn that they will not always get to go. Even my 6 and 9 year old still get upset sometimes when the other gets to go to a friends and they don't. If a child or a mom called to have one of my kids play, I would never assume that all three of my children would be going to play. Siblings need to learn to thrive independantly so they can funtion that way as adults. I can't believe that is happening in your town. Tough one, good luck
1 mom found this helpful
Email