D.B. asks from Salt Lake City, UT on August 11, 2008
Should I Have a Sibling for My Son?
my husband desperatly wants us to have another child. i have A LOT of reservations:
1. my age
2. my energy level (LOW!!)
3. i'm trying to finish Masters program & new child will further delay career hopes
4. all that comes with new baby: lack of sleep, lack of sleep & lack of sleep
5. population! uugh! bleh!
6. post partum depression
7. oh my! this list of drawbacks could go on & on
the main reason i have actually agreed to concieve is for a sibling for our three year old son. is this ridiculous? i just don't think i 'have it in me' at this point im my life & i'm not too sure of my mothering abilites for a second child. my husband also refuses to consider adoption. i don't want to wait too long & the age gap to be too great between my son & a possible other. i just don't want to regret going through with conception.... and i really don't want to regret having an only child & never having tried to change that for our family.
really want to avoid sounding too negative & i know if i go into it just hating the idea it will be a miserable experience.
i had a terrific pregnancy, quick natural delivery & i'm successfully raising an awesome three year old! he has been a total joy in my life! i think we're great with just our one son!
any opinions or feedback or experience is greatly appreciated!
So What Happened?™
Well, i just gave birth a week and a half ago to a wonderful second son. The delivery was quick and natural as with the first, i find myself with more energy than i ever had before & the sleep thing isn’t bothering me as much as i had anticipated. As far as post partum depression, well, i’m dealing with that—it’s showing it’s face earlier than with my first son, however, at least now i know what it is and how to remedy the condition. I’ve decided, school will be completed eventually and with our nation's current economy, what’s the rush anyway? ;D
During the pregnancy my husband took a second tour through his early twenties-- that was very stressful and rough on our little family. We were (are) very near divorce save for the couple’s counseling along side the anger management & s. a. courses he has to take. The past four days he seems to have decided to be a husband and father again... i can only hope this lasts.
My first son just turned four years old! It’s truly amazing just how fast time flies-- i know the two boys will grow close & be great friends & brothers! i am now happy about my decision-- at first i felt stupid & i was embarrassed to tell anyone about the pregnancy-- especially considering my husband's pass times for the duration -- but by the time i was showing & didn’t just look like i was gaining weight (six months or so) i was beginning to get excited about the baby & decided to forget about my husband's poor choices and focus on my children. The crazy thing is, it was my husband who had been practically begging for a second child for more than two years! We’re still trying to figure out what led him off the deep end.
Anyway, i'm sure everything will work out beautifully, even if it ends up being just me with the two wonderful children.
Thanks for all the fantastic advise on this topic... i requested almost a year ago.
Featured Answers
S.W. answers from Denver on August 13, 2008
I wouldn't jump the gun and say that you absolutely don't want another child or you wouldn't even bother with this question. No one here can give you a magic answer. All I can tell you is that with either decision, you can find something to regret about it...or focus on why you don't regret it. I have 3 children and I have had thoughts about having them on each end of the spectrum and everything between. That's just life and that's just being human.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
S.F. answers from Billings on August 12, 2008
hi D.,
this is such a personal decision for each of us.
let me say this, though: if you are concerned about your age being a factor, my second child was born when i was your age. and yes, i was always tired and i also worked numerous jobs. but i could not believe the tremendous wonderful change in my 4 year old son once he became a brother! the entire way that he embraced his world changed and he told me then and tells me to this day (now he is 23) that he no longer felt alone in the world. as soon as his baby sister was born, he felt connected/confirmed. his sense of security, self-esteem improved all for the good-and it wasn't like he had been suffering in those areas. he had done a good job (yes, even just at 4) of hiding how alone he felt compared to "everyone else".
the tired years of having two kids goes away eventually, if that is a big concern. (and oh my gosh yes i was always soooo tired for some years)
age span between two kids? a good friend of mine years ago decided it was too late to have baby #2 since her first born was already 8. and another friend thought the same thing with first born already 13. both went on to have baby #2 and for them, this turned out to be a blessing all the way around (for parents and for siblings). i have siblings just a year, two and three years older/younger than me, but the sibling i am closest to as an adult is 9 years younger than me.
however, my bigger concern for you and this contemplated child #2 is- there are children born to parents who do regret their birth. they may not vocalize this, but still it's tough to watch a child grow up if a parent regrets or resents in any way the "extra workload". thus, in the end, you and your spouse are the only ones who can truly determine where your hearts are.
in answer to your "population concern"-well that is universally valid. but my answer to that concern is that as we all age, we need support with the trials that life brings us. visit some health facilities or any other place that deals with people struggling with issues and watch how family support becomes important at that stage of life. someday i won't be "there" for my kids, but i know they will be there for each other. they will have family connections. in my book, that is a tremendous gift to your first born, but you need to determine if that is also a value in your own book. we each have different values, different strengths, and different coping abilities.
best to you,
S.
2 moms found this helpful
C.M. answers from Colorado Springs on August 12, 2008
"...all jobs take 2nd place to the full time privileges of wife & mother..."
If this is how you really feel then you should naturally be open to recieving children.
Live a life giving love and leave the planning to The Planner.
2 moms found this helpful
T.W. answers from Salt Lake City on August 12, 2008
Well, I don't know if you are a person who believes in God. But this is my advice:
Before, during, and throughout this process, be prayerful. Ask for help to be clear minded, ask for help to really consider all important factors, ask for help to make the best and most right choice.
1) Make a list of pros and cons
2) Based on how you feel in your mind and heart, make a decision.
3) Pray about it. You should at that point either feel you have made the right decision, because you still feel good about it after praying. Or, you will feel unsettled and confused, because the choice you have made is not the one that is part of a grand plan for you.
I hope you don't mind some spiritual advice. I still think what all the mamas have to say can be good and part of your consideration. Ultimately the decision is up to you and your husband. The future ramifications really do matter, and that's why your prayers will be answered. Good luck D.! By the way, I bet kids just love your name! : )
1 mom found this helpful
K.M. answers from Missoula on August 12, 2008
Boy that was a long list if made up excuses. I do think that there should be at least 2 children so they each learn to share with others more (some parents don't teach to even share with mommy & daddy). I think the time frame as you say is better to have one now. Is your career more important than your family? If yes, then there is your answer. If no, then there is your answer. Only you can decide to be happy, but if your little guy is so happy and a joy, so will one more. It will be different only because all babies, pregnancies, etc will be different, but that is the experience that makes us grow and how we watch them helps too. It also helps our little ones to grow and learn too. I hope your husband is a helper in this children thing, so you can study. It will work out better if your heart is in it. Your choice! Kay
1 mom found this helpful
S.W. answers from Denver on August 13, 2008
I wouldn't jump the gun and say that you absolutely don't want another child or you wouldn't even bother with this question. No one here can give you a magic answer. All I can tell you is that with either decision, you can find something to regret about it...or focus on why you don't regret it. I have 3 children and I have had thoughts about having them on each end of the spectrum and everything between. That's just life and that's just being human.
1 mom found this helpful
M.P. answers from Grand Junction on August 12, 2008
Well - this is a totally personal decision and what other people might have to say in response should be considered - but not used to make your final decision. That is completely up to you and what you truly feel you want to do. Here are my two cents:
Last night my oldest daughter had her best friend over - whom is an only child. I was cooking dinner and kind of watching my three children play around. I noticed that our baby - who is 2 1/2 was tickling my girls with a feather. They were laughing and rolling around and it was so so incredibly heartwarming to watch them. My daughters friend was sitting off to the side and didn't want any part of it. When the baby tried to tickle her she didn't want to be touched. She wanted to sit alone, eat alone, play alone...... I absolutely ADORE this little girl. She and my daughter have been best friends since they started school. But you can definitely see how being an only child "affects" her. I would much rather hear and see my kids laughing, loving, arguing :(, and sticking up for one another - than the silence of an only child.
Now, don't get me wrong, there is absolutely nothing wrong with the decision to have only one child - and feel absolutely blessed that you were given the opportunity to be a mom. But - in my PERSONAL opinion, there is not a greater gift that you can give your child than a sibling. As much as we may have disagreed growing up.....I don't know what in the world I would ever do without my brother and sister.
Remember this when making your decision: EVERYONE wishes they would've spent more time with their kids while they were growing up.....NOBODY wishes they could've worked more. Family is the best thing you will ever be blessed with in your life.....consider not denying this from your child.
Best of luck in your decision.
1 mom found this helpful
A.H. answers from Salt Lake City on August 12, 2008
Tough call. Certainly only a decision you can make. I just thought I'd throw in my $.02 because we basically decided to have a 2nd child for pretty much the same reason as you - so that my son would have a sibling. Our kids are 4 years apart in age, and I was 34 when I delivered my 2nd child. I hated being pregnant - both times, had a horrible labor/delivery - both times. I of course love both my kids though, and don't regret my decision. They play awesome together, and I am glad they will always have each other. However, it is hard, and sometimes I wonder what it would be like if we only had the one. I feel like I've missed out on the last couple years of my oldest's life, because we've been so absorbed with the 'now almost 3 yr old'. Suddenly, he's turning 7 this month, and I'm wondering where the time has gone.
Admittedly, Harvey Danger's comment "only stupid people are breeding" was a part of our decision as well. But I do have concerns over the future of my children - huge national debt, pollution, global warming, etc.
Unlike your situation, I had already completed my masters by the time DS#1 was 2. Can you focus full time on finishing your degree before a 2nd one comes along? I ended up quitting my job temporarily to bang out my remaining credits in one semester (instead of dragging it on for 3 while working full time).
Either way, good luck with your decision.
1 mom found this helpful
S.K. answers from Denver on August 12, 2008
This is a tough one, there are pros and cons to each. I agree the whole baby stage is tough, I have two and they are the best buddies and how protective my son is over his little sister is amazing. I couldn't imagine either one without the other. However, if you are not wanting one right now like others have said you could end up resenting your husband for having to delay your career since you will be the one loosing sleep. The baby stage is just temporary though, very tiring but temporary. Sit back and look at what you have, do you feel that your family is complete or are you missing that one little thing? All I know is with one child to two you go from being a playmate to a referee. Do what is in your heart.
1 mom found this helpful
Email