A.N. asks from Forsyth, GA on April 24, 2010
Sexuality?
8 year old and 6 year old girls were caught in closet exploring each others bodies. How do I explain how wrong this behavior is?
Featured Answers
K.M. answers from Boston on April 24, 2010
I don't think if it's wrong if it's not one sided, as Anne-Marie warns. It's important to find out whose idea it was and whether it was perceived as fun and interesting (or mean and scary) before deciding whether any crack down is necessary. If coercion is not involved, then it's just exploration, and that's normal. Too much squeamishness about the body isn't healthy.
3 moms found this helpful
S.S. answers from Atlanta on April 26, 2010
Why is this "wrong?" Kids do this and usually when they are not getting enough information from their parents. This isn't about sex just about their bodies how they feel and what makes them work.
Give you children a healthy attitude about their bodies and sex and you get a confident and sexually responsible adult.
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
H.A. answers from Dallas on April 24, 2010
Like a lot of Moms have said.. you don't want to come slamming down on them and cause a lot of shame for what is just natural curiosity. This wasn't hormonal, dirty, or perverted - just innocent curiosity about things that are kept covered. There are more nerve endings in the most private of areas - even to children they notice this.
This is best time for you to start establish open communication with your child. Maybe time to buy a book about body differences and answer any questions your child has honestly. While you're doing that you can explain to her that her body is her own. You could tell her no one else should be touching her body's private parts unless it's a doctor and Mommy or Daddy are there.
It's not wrong to be curious. If you make her feel awful and scream, yell or punish you are slamming the door on any hope of her coming to you if something else HAPPENS. She will have an established feeling of "shame" about bringing things to you.
Honestly I tell my son, 5 years old, when he touches himself, "I know that feels good - and it's okay to touch, but that's something you do in private." (You know boys, they start grabbing at Thanksgiving dinner -- whenever the mood strikes and my boys figured out where *that* was nearly as soon as they got the muscle control. Diaper came off and hand immediately went down.)
It's perfectly normal. :) Good luck!
7 moms found this helpful
M.H. answers from Atlanta on April 25, 2010
Amanda,
Just because something is natural doesn't mean it's right. Selfishness is natural but we try to teach our children not to be selfish. That is the way you explain it. It IS natural, but we have to have self control. You don't let a child eat 10 chocolate bars, but they would if left to themselves. You don't let them poop in their pants but unless you teach them to potty, they would.
Scolding is appropriate without embarrassing them. Hopefully they are embarrassed enough by being caught. If they thought it was okay they WOULD NOT be hiding in a closet. They already know. You just need to reinforce it!
God bless!
M.
5 moms found this helpful
A.F. answers from St. Cloud on April 24, 2010
I am surprised that so many are saying that this is not wrong! Self exploration is normal but "exploring" with others can quickly become a scarring experience to one or both parties.
They need to know to respect their bodies and other's bodies. There are body parts and experiences that are NOT to be shared with others. Often it's one sided, and can be very violating.
EDIT*** I feel that I need to add that I am not sqeamish about the body. I do, however, remember being the younger child and being the recipient of a neighbor girl's "exploration". I finally got up the nerve to tell her no, but I feel bad for those who are not brave enough or old enough to protect themselves.
I, for one, would rather talk with my kids and answer their questions than find them feeling up other kids in a closet.
5 moms found this helpful
K.B. answers from Cincinnati on April 24, 2010
Find out why they were doing it...where they got the idea from and go from there. This could help with your end as just starting that conversation out of the blue could be hard and you could be at the complete wrong end of the spectrum as to why. Let them do the talking, find out what they know and how they know it. Educate from there.
4 moms found this helpful
J.J. answers from Atlanta on April 26, 2010
I am shocked at the number of people who find this to be OK! Maybe yelling and scolding are not the appropriate action - the FIRST time - but they definitely need to know that it's NOT ok to go around touching other people that way! Like some moms said, get a good book and answer questions and form an open relationship on the matter because you don't want them to find out elsewhere. I was "explored" as a child at age of 7, by a boy the same age. That's something I will never forget.
Moms, would you have the same view if it was with an unrelated child? A child of the opposite sex? An older child? At what age is it not ok anymore? Boundries MUST be set now! Just because all or most kids do it does NOT make it ok! We are all "born in to sin" and it's our job as parents to correct their behavior. I think our society is constantly pushing the limits as to what's considered ok and what's not....when does it end??
Amanda, I would pray and ask for wisdom before addressing it - that way you can't go wrong!!
God Bless you and your family ;oD
4 moms found this helpful
C.T. answers from Denver on April 24, 2010
I wouldnt stigmatize them for this behavior. They inherently knew it was "naughty" or else they wouldnt be hiding in the closet and they were probably embarrassed that they got caught.
I would just explain to your daughter that it's natural to be curious but that her body belongs to her and no one else and it is the same for her friend's body. Just tell her that it's inappropriate kind of touching and to please not do it again.
4 moms found this helpful
P.W. answers from San Francisco on April 24, 2010
Don't say anything about it. It's not "wrong," it's pretty natural at that age. As one mom pointed out, they were hiding, so they have some idea of shame surrounding it.
I had an encounter with a friend at around that age, it was a one time event, and guess what -- I'm straight today, and so is the other girl. Let it go, no big deal.
Now if you catch them doing it a number of times - then it's time for a talk.
4 moms found this helpful
K.M. answers from Boston on April 24, 2010
I don't think if it's wrong if it's not one sided, as Anne-Marie warns. It's important to find out whose idea it was and whether it was perceived as fun and interesting (or mean and scary) before deciding whether any crack down is necessary. If coercion is not involved, then it's just exploration, and that's normal. Too much squeamishness about the body isn't healthy.
3 moms found this helpful
Email