A.D. asks from Albany, OR on May 02, 2008
Sad over Not Having a Girl
I have one boy and just found out that I’m having another. My limit is two kids—I don’t have the stamina or money for more. And I A. bereft that I don’t get to have a girl. I know, I know, I should be happy I get to have kids at all! I should be grateful for my healthy son and a clean ultrasound on the second! I should just suck it up and all that. But I A. one of three girls myself and I desperately wanted a daughter. And not just for the toys and clothes, either; I wanted to teach her so much about growing up female. And of course I have this fantasy that a girl would be easier (and she would be stronger at birth, have less risk of SIDS, less risk of Autism, need I go on?). I had so many dreams and wishes for a girl, and now I A. in the low place of swallowing the idea that this is one big lifetime dream that will never be realized. It’s almost as if I’m mourning the baby I’ll never have. Has anyone else felt this way? And then felt guilty and selfish for feeling this way? Please spare me the platitudes about being grateful for what I have. I A. grateful, and I have a husband to tell me all the cliché lines about how it will all be fine (although even he admitted to being a bit disappointed; when we married we’d both hoped to have two little girls).
So What Happened?™
Thank you all so much for your responses and letting me have my pity party. I hesitated putting this one out there b/c of other moms’ heartbreaking stories of loss. Worse yet, I keep thinking that god is going to rain down terrible things upon me and people I love for whining about something like this when others have it so much worse. And yet…none of that could shut off the emotional valve that had opened up within me, and I needed to find someway drain it. So thank you thank you thank you for your candid responses—especially from the moms of all boys. That you are mom enough to admit that you still grieve the loss of that child-who-never-happened is courageous. All of your comments have helped immensely, and a special thank you to the mom who suggested the Gender Disappointment website. It’s funny: I struggled with compromised fertility before I even got pregnant, and then this second one was a total surprise. You’d think I’d be pleased as punch to get anything, much less two. More fodder for the guilt machine.
I’m glad I’m able to get through all of this yuck now, before the baby arrives. I don’t want to put any baggage on him. I’ve decided it’s not so much that I’m sad about having another boy, it’s that I’m sad about NOT having a girl. Does that make sense? Mourning something that never was, never will be? My sister, who lives 2,000 miles away, has two girls and was poised and ready to send me every last stitch of girl clothing in her household. I would’ve had a steady pipeline of girl’s stuff, not to mention I’m one of the last in my circle of friends to have kids, so plenty more on top of it. So it’s not like I had the “reuse it” issue. And I’ve always felt so powerful in the company of other women—sure, there can be catty-ness, but growing up in an all-female household taught me how to navigate it.
It’s funny: right after I had my first boy I thought I could totally have another boy and be fine. And then that first boy has grown into a toddler who is you quintessential rambunctious boy with all that tornado boy energy. The fantasy is that a girl would be oh-so calm and mellow (and the girls in my family are a pretty calm bunch; the men? alcoholic weirdoes) and that it would cut me a break from the hard work of chasing around not one but TWO boys. Now I’ll never know. And my sister with her two beautiful little princesses? Prepare yourselves for a collective eye-roll: she has NEVER childproofed anything. Na-da. Her girls just “don’t test anything.”
I’m not a shopper, heck I don’t even wear make-up, my hair is in a permanent pony tail, and I’m no slave to fashion. And I’ve always been a big fan of toilet humor. So I have these things going for me when it comes to raising boys. And yet…I was thinking that having a girl might make me a better woman. I have so much to offer a daughter…and secretly? I’ve always that that females are superior to males! I know, reverse sexism. All those women’s studies classes in college that I found so powerful; I’ll just have to hope that my boys find an interest in them (I’ve given my son a doll to play with, but so far he is only interested in cats and things on wheels.).
So this feeling will decrease in strength and hopefully dry up and go away over time. Maybe some day I’ll win the lottery and can adopt internationally—that’s always been a fantasy of mine. I do like the idea of getting an exchange student, when my boys are older. Thank you to the mom who suggested it. And to the Mary Kay momma who has a make-up set for her son? You are hilarious! That image will have me laughing for a long time.
Thank you all for helping me feel like I’m not some class of selfish monster for feeling like this. I promise you, I will love that little boy growing inside of me. I already do.
Featured Answers
R.S. answers from Seattle on May 03, 2008
I too have one boy and we only want one more child. I so badly want a girl, but dought that I will get it. My husband comes from a family of 6 boys and one girl. My husband and and 3 of his brothers all have boys.
I just look at it in the way that if I dont ever have a girl then my husband will just have to spoil me instead of the little girl. LOL
Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
L.M. answers from Yakima on May 02, 2008
Oh what you are feeling is normal...but when you see that little boy that needs you so much you will have your heart fill with love.
Grieve over not having a girl if you need to...but I can tellyou a little truth to the situation. Girl's are always Daddy's Girl's and Mama has very little to do except Prom..LOL
They get to an age that it is like having two women in the house...they are harder to raise as far as I A. concerned and I have raised four of them. I have a boy 16 that he and I are really thick and I have the best time with his girlfriends and helping him through life things. Boy's are always Mama's boys....
Do not think that you will never have that girl...I can tell you from experience that you will be just as thrilled when that granddaughter is born...the years fly.....
It is so nice to have a brother for your son and they will be so close....
Feel what you have to feel but as this child grows in you and the disappointment passes you will see that things happen for the best. I know you cannot see that now but it will be fine.
Is there a friend that is expecting that baby girl that you could be a God Mother to?
Cry your eyes out if you have to and then be prepared to love this new life with all your heart. Because he will win you over with that first look of needing you.
You sound like a wonderful person that has alot of love to give...things happen too...this may not be your last.Butthere is no guarantee unless you adopt that you would have the girl that you have the picture built upinyour head that it would belike. Personally I think you would be surprised...you will be closer growing up to your boys than you would to a girl.Not that you love them any different..to girls Daddy can do no wrong and Mama is always wrong! LOL L.
2 moms found this helpful
T.J. answers from Seattle on May 02, 2008
We have two little girls, and while I admit to feeling sad that our second wasn't a boy, I A. glad I have at least one girl, because I know I'd feel the way you do if I didn't. But there are days you could borrow mine! lol
You are definitely not bad or selfish for thinking this way, I still feel bad sometimes for wishing my youngest was a boy. I cried so hard the day we found out, and felt better when I went shopping and bought her some new stuff just for her, plus some matching big and little sister shirts.
We are still debating whether to try again just to try for a boy, but realize that could mean three girls, which we're not sure we want or can afford. It is a hard choice, plus we tried all the "methods" for conceiving a boy and it obviously didn't work last time.
You are SO not alone, and should feel better just for having admitted it! Don't let anyone invalidate your feelings, it's okay to be disappointed! Doing so doesn't mean you will love your child less.
1 mom found this helpful
R.S. answers from Seattle on May 03, 2008
I too have one boy and we only want one more child. I so badly want a girl, but dought that I will get it. My husband comes from a family of 6 boys and one girl. My husband and and 3 of his brothers all have boys.
I just look at it in the way that if I dont ever have a girl then my husband will just have to spoil me instead of the little girl. LOL
Good luck!
1 mom found this helpful
J.S. answers from Seattle on May 02, 2008
My mother in law was in your situation. She desperately wanted a girl and ended up with 3 boys instead. It was tough sometimes to have lost that dream... trips to the store were quick dashes instead of lingering shopping trips, the boys would be finished with their dinners before she even got the chance to sit down, etc... But she devoted herself to them and they grew up having a very close relationship to their mom. Because of that relationship, when her boys got married, they insisted on their families getting to know her as well. Now she likes to say that she has three boys and three daughters (everyone has a great relationship!). And as a bonus... she now has three granddaughters to love. It sounds like you feel as though you've lost your chance for a daughter, but maybe you've only lost that chance until the next generation.
1 mom found this helpful
L.L. answers from Seattle on May 02, 2008
Perhaps you can bring your focus more to bringing up your boys to be gentlemen. Teaching them how to treat a lady that is so rare in our society...the old chivalrous (sp?) ways. Teaching them how to do things like opening doors and such while still allowing their lady to be independent and her own person. Just think of the wonderful ladies they will bring home one day when they will give you grand children who may be girls that you can have even more fun with than you ever dreamed of. Good luck to you. I know life does not always give you what you expect...the trick is to make the most of what's given, as I'm sure you well know. Congrads on the healthy son and clean ultrasound!
1 mom found this helpful
J.W. answers from Eugene on May 03, 2008
I had a boy first and when I became pregnant with #2 we really wanted another boy. Of course the ultrasound showed a girl, and I was so sad. My husband was really upset too. what made it worse was the guilt, like you mentioned - how could we be so petty when there are people who can't have children or have kids who are sick, etc? And it is something you can't really talk to many people about because you do get lots of "be grateful" speeches.
Take time to grieve the loss of your fantasy. Be easy on yourself for feeling the way you do - you are human and we all have dreams for our families and futures.
In time you will feel better about it, though you will likely always miss having the little girl. However, you will probably be the mosT amazing mother-in-law to whoever your boys marry!
1 mom found this helpful
D.L. answers from Portland on May 03, 2008
I know how you feel - I had a boy and then we tried again and found out it was twins! I remember thinking that surely one had to be a girl, but I was shocked to find out that they were both boys!!I didn't want to have more kids than two, so now that I'm over my limit I probably won't try again. I really hoped for a girl too, but one thing that helped is watching my boys play together and realizing how great it's going to be for them to have brothers to grow up with - they can share toys and relate to one another. Plus it seems like boys always love their mommies, where girls often clash with their moms as they get older. One friend of mine who has all boys has fun (now that they are 8 and 10) by letting them take her out (individually)on "dates" and she teaches them how to be gentlemen. She gives them money before the date so they can pay,and they take her coat,and pull out her chair for her,etc - and they love this time together! You do have to mourn the dream of having a girl but you can think of fun new dreams for your boys. I have found that I really enjoy having boys. Best of luck to you!
1 mom found this helpful
J.R. answers from Portland on May 03, 2008
I wanted to have a boy so bad and then the ultrasound showed a healthy little girl. I cried and cried and then a good friend said ya know I think you have what you are suppose to have and that little girl picked you to be her mommy...I got over it, got excited and now can't even imagine having a little boy.
We are only having one child so me having a boy won't happen. I do however get to have play dates with my nephews and friends boys.
Love him love him love him and once he is born I think your feelings will change, mine did.
1 mom found this helpful
Email