S.C. asks from Bowling Green, OH on July 26, 2010
Returning Gifts
My daughter recently turned 1 and got a lot of clothes. None of them fit. People clearly either didn't listen or didn't care when I told them what size clothes she wears. I almost never return gifts. I think it's tacky, just the way I was raised. It seems silly to hang on to all these clothes that don't fit though. I was planning on exchanging them for some fall/winter clothes. Is that ok? Do I have to tell the people that I'm doing it? What if someone asks if she liked the outfit or if it fit her? I had thought about exchanging them for the same outfit, just in a smaller size but most of them are summer clothes and she doesn't need anymore of them. She NEEDS fall/winter clothes. I know this is kind of a dumb question, I've just never exchanged or returned any gifts before and I'm unsure of the etiquette.
Also, no one gave us gift receipts. I'm sure most of the stuff came from WalMart. They'll do exchanges for me with out receipts right?
So What Happened?™
Thanks everyone! I plan on trying to return them this week, so I hope I can get full credit for them.
I should have specified. The clothes are too big, but the time she grows into them it will be the wrong season. She's in 3-6 month stuff now, but most of the stuff was 6-9 summer. She'll probably be in at least 12 months by the time next summer comes. She did get some cute 12 month summer stuff that I'm planning on hanging on to in the hopes that she'll wear it next summer.
It's just very frustrating that people called and/or texted me and asked me sizes and seasons and then got the exact opposite. Oh well..not much I can do about it now. I'll just remember that next time they ask me :)
Featured Answers
S.S. answers from Cincinnati on July 26, 2010
you told them her size and they didnt listen, so i think you have every right to exchange it for what she really needs. If they ask you about the oufit i think its ok to lie a little to spare their feelings. say you really liked the outfit but unfortunatly it didnt fit, you went to exchange it but they didnt have the correct size so you had to get another outfit instead. oh and walmart will do an exchange without a receipt ,or even put it on a giftcard for you if it is under a certain amount. that is there policy and they have to stick with it
2 moms found this helpful
C.D. answers from St. Louis on July 26, 2010
my mil buys stuff for my dd a year before she needs it. She is 2yo. She has stayed right on track size wise with her age but my mil buys too small. Because she got it sooo long ago I can't get a receipt from her or the gift receipt she sends every blue moon is out dated and no good. Don't get me wrong I love that she thinks of my dd and gets stuff for her but please ask me what size to get. If I make the mistake on sizes then it's my fault and I pay the price.
I can no longer take back anything to walmart without a receipt because I have taken too many baby items back without one. Can't even get store credit. I was warned about a year ago by the walmart employee that I was on some list that shop lifters go on all because my mil won't ask me about sizes.
I have had to take clothes to resale shops with the tags still on them because of this. My dd gets maybe 2 outfits if I'm lucky for every 6 or 7 my mil buys. I have talked to her and she doesn't listen.
hope you don't have to go on the list too. I also hope that people will listen to you when you let them know a size or season to buy.
When people ask about the outfit they gave tell them the truth or you are going to have the same proble net year and every christmas.
More Answers
R.A. answers from Dallas on July 26, 2010
I don't think you need to tell anyone that you are returning their item. If anyone asks you can be honest and polite and just say it didn't fit so I exchanged for the correct size and it looks great! Or, when I went to exchange it they were out of her size so I had to get something else. I would not be offended if someone returned my gift. They bought you the gift for a reason and I am sure they would want you to be able to use it. I am sure they will all understand. Plus-maybe then next time they will truly listen to the correct size.
I just had to exchange an outfit at Walmart for the exact same reasons. It was very easy to do and they gave me a credit on a gift card. I just used it for something else.
Goodluck!
4 moms found this helpful
S.D. answers from Indianapolis on July 26, 2010
In your Thank You note, I's say "We LOVED the outfit you got her and were so sad it was too small/big. I'm hoping I can find the same one or something similar in the next size." Though if they are too big, can't you just save them for her to grow into?
3 moms found this helpful
S.S. answers from Cincinnati on July 26, 2010
you told them her size and they didnt listen, so i think you have every right to exchange it for what she really needs. If they ask you about the oufit i think its ok to lie a little to spare their feelings. say you really liked the outfit but unfortunatly it didnt fit, you went to exchange it but they didnt have the correct size so you had to get another outfit instead. oh and walmart will do an exchange without a receipt ,or even put it on a giftcard for you if it is under a certain amount. that is there policy and they have to stick with it
2 moms found this helpful
V.M. answers from Erie on July 26, 2010
I never really exchanged stuff until i had kids either. I think instead of you being the tacky one, the person that ignores your size suggestions and doesnt' give a gift receipt is the tacky one. If they ask about it and i hardly ever had anyone do that, just thank them so much and say how cute it was. If they specifically ask if it fit her, you could say "she is just growng so fast" and change the subject to talk about her crawlign or what ever.
Here is some advice though, i found that people would buy clothes on clearance and that when i tried to return it i would NOT get enough back to go buy fall clothes, Especially at Kohls. I had someone buy a sweet little white sweater from Carters and when i tried to return it with no reciept they wanted togive me 98 cents. So it was a better value to save the larger size summer clothes until next year. You could try to consign/resale some stuff if you have a place close to you As a place to get rid of what you don't want and a place to pick up what you need for fall.
People just don't think sometimes, and they really don't care about what she needs its their right when giving a gift to just pick out what they think is cute.
2 moms found this helpful
M.C. answers from Washington DC on July 26, 2010
Walmart will exchange gifts without a receipt up to a certain amount, but I believe that the tags have to be on them. Don't feel bad about having to return things. Its better to return them for something you can use then to have them just sit in the closet.
2 moms found this helpful
V.W. answers from Jacksonville on July 26, 2010
I wouldn't worry about anyone being offended. If the size/season is wrong, then return it for something she will actually get use out of. Most people are just guessing when buying clothes... or trying to buy something larger that will be "grown into"... and may not think about the season.
I wouldn't feel badly at all. In fact, I HATE buying clothing for infants, because it is so hard to judge sizes. One 9 month old might be wearing 6 month sizes, and another might be wearing 12 month sizes.... and different brands shrink more/less than others... If someone asks you later "did the outfit fit?"... just tell the truth... "no, it was a little big/small, and by the time she would've grown into it the season was too cold, so I took it back and got her a cute ___". They'll be glad you got something you could use and enjoy.
hugs!
2 moms found this helpful
P.W. answers from Dallas on July 26, 2010
It's not tacky to return or exchange. It's a gift meant for you and if doesn't fit in my mind it would just be silly not to return it, even if you decided to buy a toy instead. It's about your needs and wants.
If there is any type of tag on the clothing then I think there is a good chance you can return. I am betting you could even get all your money put on a walmart card so that you can use it as needed.
Please don't hesitate to return these items. I think when it comes to clothing people almost expect you to.
1 mom found this helpful
C.M. answers from Austin on July 26, 2010
No. They won't do exchanges without a receipt. At least, that has been my experience. You could try calling and explaining what your situation is to them.
It's not tacky to exchange kids clothes for the right size. I'm sure your friends would rather you do that than hang onto useless clothing that doesn't fit. If they ask, just tell them that the stuff didn't fit, but you went ahead and got some winter stuff for her.
1 mom found this helpful
Email