D. asks from Greenwell Springs, LA on August 23, 2006
Problem with Ex-husbands Girl Friend
I have a serious issue. I have three daughters from my previous marriage. My ex-husband has been absent for years but decided this summer (after moving back in with his parents... yes that is sad... along with his girl friend) to be more involved with their lives. So, they spent some time with him and his new girlfriend (I only allowed it because they are living with his parents and I love his family!!). Anyway, I'm remarried to the most wonderful and patient man in the world who loves my girls. I was hoping that this other woman would be a good influence on my ex since she is also a mother. Her and I got along fine... until she started telling me how to parent my children. Now, I don't like being told how to parent my own children by anyone much less someone I don't know and someone that my ex-mother in law is telling me doesn't even know how to parent her own child. But the real issue is that this woman bad mouths me to my 10 year old (the oldest). She is trying to convince her that she needs to come and live with them (1000 miles away). My ex bought the girls their own cell phones because I don't want him calling mine to speak to them... and has told my girls that I cannot take these phones away.... but the other night I walked in to hear this woman tell my daughter (she had it on speaker phone).."Your Momma is a liar..she doesn't care about you and you can come and live with us... but she will not let you".
She has also told my daughter that I am not a good mother, that her new step-dad could never love her the way her real daddy does and etc. etc. My daughter is now in therapy because all I hear every day all day is that she wants to go and live with her Daddy. I tried taking the phones away... but when I did that my ex called the police on me and told them that he wanted to do a 'welfare' check on his children because he hadn't spoken to them in three days. This from a man who just 6 months ago was living in a car somewhere in Texas!!!
So What Happened?™
Okay... I don't know how to respond to everyone at once, so I hope this works.
First of all... I thought that my situation was unique..hahaha... unfortunately it is not. Everyone has been VERY helpful. The first thing that I did this morning after reading all of the responses was to start a log of everything. Thankfully, I've saved every single e-mail that I've ever gotten from the ex and his 'flavor of the month'. GAWD, I HOPE she is a flavor of the month!!! But I can't count on that.
Unfortunately, I cannot tape the conversations because they are in California and I am in Louisiana. It would be okay here, but because it crosses state lines I have to follow the law for both states and in CALI you have to have the consent of both parties. My ex (crack head, homeless loser) is a former Police Officer and HE knows the law (doesn't follow it, but knows it). I've also finally got it through my THICK head that I do not OWE this person ANYTHING! She is not his wife, or my girl's stepmother and I DO NOT HAVE to allow her to speak to them. If he wants that, then he needs to marry HER and take me to court. After being 11K behind in child support he is finally paying (like someone said... brownie points for the new girl) so that is why he feels like he can be a part of their lives. I will not stop him, but I'm also not going to 'help' him either. It is so amazing the difference in my two oldest (10 and 8) girl's attitudes when they go a couple of days without talking to them on the phone... doesn't take a genius to figure out what triggers their bad attitudes. And someone else said.. that it sounds like jealousy!!! NAIL ON THE HEAD. I am remarried to a wonderful, financially secure man. We have a beautiful home and a wonderful family and my ex has absolutely NOTHING. He is living and mooching off of his parents, owes the IRS over 25K, can't keep a job and the only thing he owns is a $500 truck! He is so jealous that he could spit nails and the only way to 'get back at me' is to attempt to make my life miserable!!! But I am not going to let him!
Thanks again for all of your advice, prayers and well wishes!!!
More Answers
C.W. answers from Denver on August 23, 2006
Get a lawyer they know the laws and could guide you in a better direction. Continue to love your children, talk with them, ask them about their day and such- keep your communication with them positive. With a situation like this you need to be patient with your girls - As far as the cell phones goes- it's your home, set some rules. Let them use the phone at a certain time of day. I wouldn't let them take their phonee to their rooms personally. Your ex husband and friend could be just wanting to stir up problems for you- jealiously perhaps? Will say a prayer for you and hope that Your given strength and guidence.
Blessings, C.
1 mom found this helpful
C.A. answers from Houston on August 23, 2006
I am sorry you have this to deal with. My advice is to get a lawyer. Your child's therapist would be a good witness to testify that the interactions between father/girlfriend are not therapeutic. You can request that his visitation be supervised by the courts if you feel that he needs visitation. let him do all the welfare checks he wants. Just keep accurate records when he does it and what reason he is giving. I would personally mail the phones back to him as soon as possible. As their mother you have a right to know what contact they have and with whom. If he can contact them through the home phone there is no reason for them to have his cell phones. BTW mail them certified, return receipt requested or ship them where a signature is required to accept the package. You can even do restricted delivery to him so that he must sign for the package. I would consider Fedex or UPS with signature required. That way they can use them while they are with him if he chooses to let them.
As for you children, I would make it a point to never speak badly where they can hear about the father or girlfriend or his family. It will come back to bite you in the butt if you do. As they mature, they will realize who is doing to back biting and bad talk. I know that is no consolation to you right now but long term there will be an awareness of it. Now, you must love your children. Check with the therapist and see if there is any damage control you can do. Work closely with them because if you go to court, you will need them to state you are doing everything they recommend and the outcome of that. They will also testify to the damage that the ex is doing to the kids.
Another option, and this is a dicey one, is to meet with your ex and your daughter's counselor. You can tell him what you see and have a witness to the fact that you are attempting to work this out. That goes a long way in court. You can also see if the counselor will meet with you, your daughter and him. I don't know if this will help, but you can tell him you want him to have a relationship with his kids but you can't allow this contact to be a detriment to them. You can also appeal to your ex's family to intervene if they will.
Good luck,
C.
1 mom found this helpful
C.S. answers from Baton Rouge on August 25, 2006
OH MY GOD. I seems as though thing have gotten a little out of control. You must try and speak with your ex and his girlfried. If you have any friends within his family that can set some type of meeting set up for you. DO IT. Don't involve the girls in that meeting. You need to get across to them how they are hurting the girls and you need to assure them that you will never cut communication bewteen them and the girls again. Never badmouth either of them in front of the girls no matter how much they may deserve it. Your girls are a part of their father and badmouthing him will make them feel that there is something wrong with them. Your 10 year old is dealing with that right now with the ex girlfried badmouthing you and you need to point that out to her, your ex and his family.
Sit down with your girls and talk to them. Tell them that you are sorry that you took the phones away and cut communication with their dad. Tell them that you made a mistake and that sometimes mom's do make mistakes. Tell the 10 year old that you do not know why the girlfriend dislikes you so much, that you love her(daughter)very much and that you are the best mother you know how to be.
Tell the 10 year old that she may not live with her dad right now and that at 10 (I do not believe she can legaly make that choice)find out and tell her that. Tell her that you will not discuss it again and that if she brings it up you will ignore the topic. In otherwords put that subject to bed. Tell her that when she is much older and if she still feels she would like to live with her dad, you will consider it.
Finally, hire a lawyer and find out what your rights are so there are no suprises for you in the future.
1 mom found this helpful
J. answers from Houston on August 23, 2006
Who has custody of the girls. If you have custody and you don't have any papers that give your x-husband visitation then I would not allow the girls to go and visit. Make him take you to court. Does he pay child support? If not you need to put that in place. You are in charge of your children, if the girlfriend is not a good influence for the kids I wouldn't allow them around her. Let your x know he can visit them at your house or you can meet at a park without the girlfriend. If you can, tape any phone calls you get. To my knowledge the police won't do "a welfare check" out of the blue. I agree with what the other person had to say about the cell phones, YOU ARE IN CHARGE, NOT YOUR X-HUSBAND OR HIS GIRLFRIEND.
1 mom found this helpful
W.P. answers from Houston on August 23, 2006
Dear D.:
If she had it on speakerphone, she obviously wanted you to hear it. In Texas you can record a conversation, if one party agrees to it, the other does not have to be informed. And it is your phone, so I guess you are the party in case of your daughter. Depending on the equipment you have, you can record a conversation with it directly or you need an extra piece (usually under $100) for the computer or a tape. A VCR should work, too, even if it is just sound. That should give you evidence you may need. Also take lots of notes with dates (if needed times) and what happened. Get legal advice, but start doing this right away. Try to remember as much as you can with as much detail, possible witnesses, etc. You did not mention your custody arrangement, but either way they seem to be out to paint you as a bad parent.
If your daughter cooperates, try to get her to ask for more detail during such a phone call. If that woman says you're a liar, have her ask: "What do you mean, when did she lie? What makes you think that?" The more ammunition and detail, the better. And be there while the speakerphone is on. A taped phone call is legally valid, if backed by a witness.
I am not a lawyer, but I read the Texas Penal Code regarding that due to similar issues here. My lawyer told me that keeping a log is good, because likely the other side does not and then they cannot object to details you mention because it was too long ago. And ALWAYS stick to the truth. You can write: "I was under the impression that..." if you felt that way. If it turns out that the 'fact' was untrue or ambiguous, your impression was still true. If you heard someone say something, quote or relay indirectly, listing that person, so they know it did not come from you.
Gear up for an ugly one...
W.
(father of 8yo boy)
P.S.: My ex took two of the three prepaid cell phones for my son away. Well, they got 'lost'. Would appreciate more info on your rights in a private message...
1 mom found this helpful
E.J. answers from San Antonio on August 23, 2006
It sounds like your problem is with both your ex and his girlfriend. I have been through something similar and you actually have more options than I did, at first. Because your ex was out of your kids lives for a long period, you can make it to where he can only see the girls in your presence and with no overnights. Even if he called the police, they cannot force you to let the girls go and you can tell them that you have serious safety concerns for your daughters because he had not seen them for so long. My ex skipped visits all the time because he thought he could and at one point weeks went by without a call or anything. When he did show up I explained to him that he was no longer allowed to take our son over night, but he could see him anytime in our home or I would meet him someplace public. Ultimatly, you need to do this for your daughters well being because it is obvious that things are being said to make your job as a parent harder and that mess with their minds. You should also sit down with the girls and be gentle but honest about what you are going to do, so they understand and do not feel left out. My son was 4 and 5 when we were dealing with his dad and girlfriends, but I told him that his dad could see him whenever, but I could not make him do it. I told him that the things his father was saying and doing in front of him (bad mouthing and cussing at me) were not okay for him to have to deal with and he was not going to be spending the night with his dad anymore. He actually took it pretty well and he did have a lot of questions, but he dealt with it better because I was honest and I did not trash his dad in front of him. Your ex and his girlfriend are not considering your girls feeling or their relationship with you and your husband, who they spend most of their time with. You need to encourge your girls to look at the whole picture-you have been their one constant parent and that will not change, they should try to remember that when they hear negative things about you-they know you and are with you all the time.
My son's father is now relinquishing his rights, my husband is adopting my son, my son knows what a real father looks and acts like, he is very happy, and his father has not been an active participant for almost 2 years now. Wish you the best!!
J. answers from San Antonio on August 28, 2006
D.,
If you have full custody of those children and you are providing a nice, sound and stable enironment for those kids anything that your ex and his girlfriend says is really obsolete, it is very childish and unhealthy for him to sabotage you to those kids and she really has no say in the matter at all....besides she is just a girlfriend there is no permanence in the word girlfriend she can be made to exit this relationship just as quick as she entered it. What you should remind your children is to beware of those you makes a conscious effort to try and ridicule, destroy and point out flaws in another person, mainly you. This type of behavior always carries behind it a hidden agenda, no matter how anyone looks at it, if he were a real man and role model to those kids the last thing he would try to do is destroy their mother by bad mouthing her to them, this is very wrong to say the least! It may eventually back fire on those two morrons, I feel for you, well stay humble and don't ever stoop to their level. good luck with your children~!
J.
T.F. answers from Houston on August 24, 2006
I know you want to do the right thing and not keep your children away from their father but if it jeopardizes things you must do it. If he is paying child support he probably want the kids so you can pay.
Talk with your ex-husband and the girlfriend together and discuss this first. Warn them and say if this continue, and my kids will tell me, the visitation rights will cease.
Personally, little kids are too young to have a cellular phone it enables them to get into too much trouble, easy access to trouble. For example, what happened on the loud speaker.
T.
Email