M.R. asks from Riverside, CA on February 22, 2007
Pre K
I have a 5 year old daughter who is in a pre kindergarten class. I have been told by her teacher a few times that she has a hard time following and listening to directions. She does not have a hearing problem and she is not a disruption to the class. I have tried everything from talking to her to taking away toys and putting her on time out. It is not working. What exercises or activities can I do to help her? Has anyone experienced this behavior before and what did you do?
More Answers
K.J. answers from Los Angeles on February 23, 2007
Hi M.
I'm sure you've received tons of info but here's my two cents: it's NORMAL.
Pre-K is supposed to be the environment that prepares the child for Kindergarden... it is here that the child is introduced for the first time to sitting in a group and "following directions" which really means being told what to do regardless of if she feels like obeying. Pre K sets standards of behavior that are not always developmentally appropriate for ALL children. Some pre-Kers are ready for the "sit here and do this because I said it is time to sit here and do this" and some are not.
When is your daughter's birthday? If she is a young 5, birthday in the August-January range you might consider an extra year in pre K. My daughter had similiar problems (she is a November birthday) so we gave her a "grace year" and she is now performing WAY above grade level (she's in 5th grade reading and writing at high school level).
Something else to consider: does your daughter like her teacher? HOw does she get along with others in her class? Does she like the art and pre-reading that is introduced in pre-k? If she likes school but isn't clicking with the public school meat market approach to education check into Montesori schools or other schools that have a more organic flow, one that focuses on the child's developmental stage and encourages creative and independent thinking.
Not all kids fit into the generic mold of pre-k. Love your daughter and do some homework to check out what kind of school is right for HER.
T.L. answers from Bakersfield on February 22, 2007
Hi M.. Have you tried to work with her at home? Maybe a little extra TLC would help her. A lot of kids have trouble in class. I'm not sure exactly what is going on but maybe the discipline isn't what she needs.
Good luck with this. Best Wishes, T.
N.C. answers from Los Angeles on February 23, 2007
Hi, I have a son who is now going to be 10 in April. When he was in 2nd grade I too had this problem with him. I took him to the doctor and it was actually his nerves. I think it was a lack of interest in whatever it was that they were doing at that particular time. I do sometimes have a problem with it still from time to time, but I make it a point when asking him to do something I ask him to repeat what I just said, this way I know that he is understanding what I'm asking of him. This little system seemed to had worked out really well and even now sometimes I ask him to do something and once in awhile he will forget and come back and ask me to repeat what I said. You know when he was in pre-school he was doing it alot more, but I seen as he went to Kindergarden he was more excited and he was actually very interested in his new class. Maybe her class is not very intersting to her, I mean lets face it if you are asked to go to a play or the Opera and this is something not of your interest, would you really be paying any attention? I hope this helps you....Take Care and MANY BLESSING TO YOU AND YOUR FAMILY!
S.A. answers from Los Angeles on February 22, 2007
Have you ever had her tested for add or adhd? That could also be a possability.
J.M. answers from Los Angeles on February 23, 2007
MY DAUGHTER IS IN THE 1ST. GRADE NOW BUT WHEN SHE WAS IN K SHE JUST WOULD TAKE HER SWEET TIME TO DO EVERYTHING.THE TEACHER COMMENTED ON IT AS WELL.SHE ADVISED US TO GET A TIMER AND TO GIVE HER A CERTAIN AMOUNT OF MINS. TO COMPLETE EACH TASK.IT HELPS THEM WITH TIME CONCEPT AND HOW QUICK OR LONG SOMETHING TAKES.MY GIRL WAS EXCITED TO BEAT THE CLOCK.I MOSTLY USED IT WHEN SHE WOULD GET READY FOR SCHOOL.5 MINS. TO GET DRESSED THEN SO ON AND SO ON. IT ALSO MAY BE THAT SHE IS ADVANCED FOR PRE K AND IS BORED AND ZONES OUT TO HER OWN LITTLE WORLD....
J.K. answers from San Francisco on February 23, 2007
Look at: www.patsgarden.com - my mother works with 'flower essences' [not aromatherapy] but I believe she may be able to help. Its just a suggestion and it doesn't hurt to talk to her to see if she can help... the call is free! ###-###-#### Her name is Patricia and she has been helping children with everything from ADHD, ADD to numerous and various, mild to serious issues, including me, her daughter! I hope this helps...
Peace and Blessings,
J.
K.Y. answers from Sacramento on February 24, 2007
My sister has a son that was diagnosed with an auditory learning disability. He had problems following instructions because what he heard did not always get to his brain the way the teacher said it. He has had to have special classes to help him learn how to deal with this disability. He is doing fine now in school. This may be a possibility for your child. Maybe she is paying attention but having trouble with how the information gets processed once she hears it. I wish you and your daughter the best of luck with this.
C.N. answers from San Luis Obispo on February 23, 2007
Dear M.,
No discipline needed. Play a game with her in your everyday life together. Like, tell her to put on a piece of clothing and then show you that she did it. Tell her that you will help if she needs it. Have her go to get something easy for you, and then you praise her and give her a bit of personal time. Things like that - she will get into the habit of paying attention to an adult's voice and responding to it. I used to tell the children to put on their coats and then come to show me how they look. Stuff like that. You can do it, no discipling needed, just training. O.K.? O.K. C. N.
Email