24 answers

Potty Training My Three Year Old.

I've been trying to really potty train my little girl since September last year. She turned three on November 4th last year. She's been doing #2 in the toilet since September and telling me most of the time that she has to do it, but the other times she wines and I have to ask her if she needs to do #2. I've been taking her and taking her to tee-tee and sometimes she goes and sometimes she doesn't. I have her in pull-ups and I can't get her to tell me that she needs to tee-tee. She really doesn't want to go to the bathroom at all. Am I doing something wrong, I'd love some advise. I asked her Pediatrician and she advised I be patient but how long is this going to take?Some people advise the thick underwear and plastic liners- done that and she still wets them and doesn't tell she needs to go even after I take her all day to the bathroom. Please help me, I'm almost ready to give up trying.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thank you all so much for the advise. I forgot to tell you before that she has been sitting on a Sesame Street toddler toilet seat since last year, when she refused to sit on her Princesses potty seat anymore and I have been giving her rewards for going such as M&M's, which we call potty candy. Last week when I submitted my request for help, as soon as I got offline and went to check on my little girl to see what she was doing, since it was awefully quiet, she was sitting on the toilet in her bathroom with her pull-up down and saying to me "Look mommy, I tee-teed!" I was so happy, we did the potty dance and I rewarded her then on the spot. I already had her some Big-Girl underwear that she liked, Dora, Little Mermaid and I aked her which ones she wanted to wear and I put them on her with plastic underwear over them. She only made two mistakes that day and I started timing her with my kitchen timer. She did pretty good Sunday, Monday and then Tuesday she started messing up all day, I think she went through 6 pairs of underwear with accidents, so, I was pretty discouraged and so I let her run around bottomless the rest of the day and she shocked me by taking herself to the bathroom everytime she had to go. She didn't mess up any that day when she was bottomless. She kept asking for a pullup though!! I put a pullup on her at night like you all said. Today i have put underwear and plastic underwear over them and she has kept them dry all day. She only made one mistake today. I think we are getting somewhere now. I have to be the consistent one here and that way she will be too. You were right by saying the pullup is practically the same as a big kid diaper. No more pullups, only at night. I sure appreciate all of your responses. They have helped me tremendously!! Thanks again!!!!

Featured Answers

A wise mom said to me, "if they are in pull-ups, they know it, why would they go on the potty when they don't have to". I loved her advice and took it straightaway! She was right. Best of luck to you. Potty training is very very frustrating! : -)

You have gotten some great advice here. If you do find that you still need to use pull ups at night, please try to use the Cool Alert ones so that she will still feel that she has gone. The Learning Designs ones and others do nothing to help her know.

Good Luck

As many other said, put real underwear on her. I tried the pull ups and it was like a big girl diaper for her and she never wanted to use the potty. When I went potty I would make her come with me. She sat on her potty and I sat on mine. I would use her belly button as the "potty Button" there were many accidents, but she hated feeling wet. it took 3 long months for her to be potty trained with no accidents day and night. I started when she was 2yr 3mo old and by October she was trained which made her 2.5yr old. Good luck to you.

More Answers

It may be messy for a couple of days but... take her pull ups away and put on panties only during the day. She will wet herself at least the first couple of times. Let her take off the panties, put hem in the washer, put on dry ones and towel up her mess (yes, you will obviously want to clean it with disinfectant or carpet cleaner later but let her do the initial clean). Once she realizes the feeling that proceeds getting soaked, she will try to make it to the potty. If she is reluctant at the start, set a timer to remind her every hour just to get her used to listening to her body. Then give her a small treat (a skittle or m&m - potty candy) for making it to the potty appropriately.
I love the ease of pull-ups for toddlers who still use diapers but they are so absorbant that they disuade real training.
My youngest daughter was most reluctant to train, and I was so used to diapers at that point, I did not push her when she was younger. Just after she turned 3, I put her in panties. She all over the 1st day, she had 2 accidents the 2nd day, and she was completely trained on her own within 3 days. By 5 days, she had started waking at night to night train herself completely.
Take care,
mommy to 3 (son 7, daughter 5, daughter 3)

1 mom found this helpful

As many other said, put real underwear on her. I tried the pull ups and it was like a big girl diaper for her and she never wanted to use the potty. When I went potty I would make her come with me. She sat on her potty and I sat on mine. I would use her belly button as the "potty Button" there were many accidents, but she hated feeling wet. it took 3 long months for her to be potty trained with no accidents day and night. I started when she was 2yr 3mo old and by October she was trained which made her 2.5yr old. Good luck to you.

Hey, I was having the same trouble with my three-year old. She will be 4 in September. About three weeks ago I bought two movies that seem to have made the difference: "Elmo goes potty" and "Potty Power". I got them on Amazon for about $12 each. I would tell her she had to be a big girl and she would say "I want to be a baby" but since we started watching these movies I think she realizes that big kids can do a lot more than babies. She hasn't had an accident since and is even getting up during the night to go potty.

Hi J.: My name is L. and I'm a grandmother. I hope I can help you. My daughter bought some rubber pants. The kind we use to use with diapers to keep from getting wet. She put training pants on my granddaughter who is 3. She put the rubber pants over her training pants and when she wet her pants, it had no place to go. She wore it. Not long, but long enough she didn't like it. Limited the accidents.

My son did the same thing! What I did was just ditch the pull ups except for at night and just use normal underwear. Thee is a lot of cleaning up in the beginning but he slowly got used to it. Then getting wet was uncomfortable and he started going potty. He was completely potty trained within 2 weeks. I am not going ot lie it was a rough two weeks but it was worth it. Good Luck!!!!

Your 3yr old may be regressing because she sees the 16mnth in diapers. I don't know how patient your dr. Wants you to be. I use to work with preschools & at 3 they were all potty trained by then & even taking spanish & learning & speaking it. There is hope. It could be you waited to long to start her.

A wise mom said to me, "if they are in pull-ups, they know it, why would they go on the potty when they don't have to". I loved her advice and took it straightaway! She was right. Best of luck to you. Potty training is very very frustrating! : -)

I tried the thick panties with plastic over them and my daughter would just tee tee in them anyways and I would have a puddle to clean up. It seems like I tried all sorts of combinations of panties and plastic and pullups with or without the "cool alert" and the ones that were cheep (thinking they would be more uncomfortable) and everything in between. Finally I just let her go naked from the waist down at home. She seemed to not tee tee in the floor that way. She would tee tee in her panties but not on the floor when she was naked. Go figure!?! I kept a little potty in the living room and put her on it every hour or so. Eventually I bought her some princess panties and told her that Cinderella doesn't like tee tee on her, so don't tee tee on her. And eventually it finally clicked. :) I also bought a small poster board and hung it on the wall in front of the big potty where she could see it. Every time she tee teed she could pick out one sticker to hang up and if she poo peed then she could hang two stickers up. She could do this if she used the little potty or the big one. Oh - I bought a comfortable potty seat to keep on the big potty, a large baby bajorn. It was a little expensive, but well worth it. It doesn't slide around. Best wishes, I hope this helps.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.