19 answers

Potty Time........... - Bay Shore,NY

hi moms, i have been potty training my son since monday and he still tells me no when i ask him if he has to go potty but when i put him on it after a couple of minutes he goes. how long usually does it take to officially potty train? i know all kids are different but when he goes on the potty he claps his hands and knows to wipe, flush and wash and dry his hands. he still has accidents which are expected but today he sat on the potty for 10 minutes and as soon as i pulled up his pullup he peed. i want to start to put him in underwear but i dont know when to get rid of the pull ups and start with the underwear. my question is how do you know when they are fully potty trained enough to be in underwear while they are awake? thanks.

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

still potty training though he still has his accidents it is going fairly well. he doesnt always know when he is about to go but other times he will tell me mommy pee pee or mommy poop. its a work in progress. thank you for your advice moms.

Featured Answers

Pull ups definitely prolonged potty training for my daughter. Kids are smart...they know pull ups are really just a diaper. Once I stopped using them she realized she didn't like to be wet. I brought a change of clothes everywhere we went for about 6 months.

I have friends who tried at 2 w/ boys and they didn't take to it. Then tried again at 3 and they trained quickly.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi J.! Congrats on potty training already!!! I know a couple of people have said this already, but it might be best to do without the pull ups for a couple of days when you know you can be home, or close by. When my oldest was training he was about 2 and he was doing so good at home with underwear on. If I would take him out in a pull up like to the park or something he would pee in it all the time. I finally realized that he could feel the difference and if he felt the diaper his brain just said feel free to pee. :) Anyway, for like 2 days I took him outside in underwear and brought with me a few changes of undies and sweat pants. He had a couple of accidents, but he got it pretty quick. The hard part is that it's winter now. I also have a 2 year old (26 mos) and I'm waiting till it gets a little warmer out so I can try to do the potty training the same way I did with my first.

Hope it all works out for you. But he's doing a great job. He is still so young and he seems to get it all. Way to go Mom!

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

Hi J.,

I have successfully potty trained three children using the method outlined at Growing Families International. You could check it out on their website: http://www.gfi.org/java/jsp/article_category4.htm
It's a crash course in which you do it over the course of three days, getting rid of all diapers and pull-ups except at naps and bedtime and loading the child up on liquids. You take the child to the bathroom at regular intervals set by a timer and gradually extend the time in between trips. I loved it.

Hope this helps!

1 mom found this helpful

Hi J.. My advice is to get aq potty that you can put in a room where he is for a couple of weeks. Leave him in a underwear. If he sees the potty is close by then he will try to use it. If he has accidents it is fine, he will not like the fact that he is wet and will use the potty. Then after a couple of weeks take the potty seat back to the bathroom and then take him to the bathroom to use the potty. He will learn soon enough. I know it is frustrating but he will get it. Just try to leave him in a underwear for as long as you can during the day while you are still at home.

1 mom found this helpful

you know when i started having children the mom book never said how trying to potty train your child was going to be so nerve racking. my son is 4 and well just as stubborn as a child can be!!! we started with a timer, when to put him on and when to take him off the potty. i put him in underpants now and we still have accidents, but getting out of the pull ups stopped giving him the excuse to "forget" to go to the bathroom. now we use the pull ups at night only. i have found that every child is different, even siblings, and you need to just be the mom, you know better than anyone how your child will progress in such aspects of life. good luck, dont get discouraged, keep trying.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi J.,

When I did the toilet training with my son, he was a month before turning 3. I used the triple layer cloth training pants with the waterproof outer layer. I took him to the toilet every hour and a half. I'd suggest not asking your son if he has to go, but just taking him. Don't give him the choice at this point.

I would also ditch the pullup diapers. They aren't underwear, they don't feel uncomfortably wet when he pees in them and if he views them as a diaper, he's not likely to just stop.

If you switch to underwear, underwear with plastic pants over them, cloth training pants or cloth diapers, you may find this speeds the process. With the widespread use of disposable diapers and pullups, kids don't really know what it feels like to be wet. With cloth, they realize what happens when they pee - they get wet! And they start to recognize what it feels like just before that happens.

Good luck!

1 mom found this helpful

Hi J.:
My kids are all grown up now(26, 24, 21, and 17) but I do know a thing or two about toilet-learning! First of all, boys are usually not ready until they are at LEAST 2 1/2 and sometimes closer to 3! If you hear otherwise, it's because Mom is trained! Your son has obviously shown some interest, which you should continue to encourage-Dad modeling, potty visible in bathroom, pullups instead of diapers, but I would go really low key and let him set the pace. It will be a lot less frustrating . the longer you wait, the more he will be ready and it won't seem like such a long process. With my 3 boys we waited until they were about 2 yrs. 9 months, and then they were ready and it was a matter of days/weeks and they were diaper free during the day-much longer at night though. He may also respond favorably to big-boy underwear that he picks out at the store, but not till he is closer to 3. Also, when the weather starts getting warmer, have him run around with very little clothing at home, so if he does pee, he will feel uncomfortable and be more motivated to use the potty. The more you push the more he will resist. That is the definition of a two year old. Relax, Mom, he won't be going to kindergarten in diapers! God luck.
Cathy

1 mom found this helpful

With boys it takes longer, my son is 4 now and he just got potty trained 2 months ago. It was extremely frustrating. I was hoping to have him trained by 2, 3 at the latest. It just did not take. I started putting him in underwear at 2 1/2 during the days. Let him pick out his own at the store. It's alot of fun and he thinks he's a big boy. Boy, the peeing took very quickly, however the pooing was just accomplished recently and I threw out many pairs of underwear. Everyone told me he'll do it in his own time, I had a very stubborn little boy. I still have him in pull ups at night we are working on that right now. I know from hearing from other people, some boys are still in pull ups at 5. Thank god it didn't take that long. My suggestion is just keep being persistent. I also got a small foldable potty for the minivan. It has disposable liners and is very convenient. I got it at Burlington Coat Factory, I think it is called Potty on the Go.

Good luck. Boys are tough.

1 mom found this helpful

Sounds to me like your son is doing just fine. If its only been a short time and he is only 2 yrs old. Be patient and eventually he will get the hang of it. Its still new to him. My daughter was 3 when she really comprehended the potty thing/. One day we ran out of diapers and I said no more, and we bought her pantys. She had a few accidents and that was it. But Like I said she was 3, we started getting her used to it at 2 yrs though. We would sometimes sit with her for the longest time until she would go. and when she would go we would give her a reward (like a special cookie, or putting a stamp or sticker in her special potty book we made). She loved being able to tell everyone she was a big girl. Just be patient and it will happen. You are in for a long haul, and if you think it will just happen over night youare mistaken, especially at 2. Good luck.

1 mom found this helpful

Pull ups definitely prolonged potty training for my daughter. Kids are smart...they know pull ups are really just a diaper. Once I stopped using them she realized she didn't like to be wet. I brought a change of clothes everywhere we went for about 6 months.

I have friends who tried at 2 w/ boys and they didn't take to it. Then tried again at 3 and they trained quickly.

1 mom found this helpful

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.