K.E. asks from Harrisburg, PA on April 11, 2008
Potty-Training My 22 Month Old Girl
Hello,
My daughter has been sitting on the potty with success on and off since she was 14 months. We have purchased books for her and bought every "training pant" imaginable.
She is just really inconsistant.
She does not seem to care if she is wet even in a cotton diaper or training pant. She'll sleep all night with a wet bottom and bed without even waking up.
Is it to early? Or is she just not ready?
I don't want to push it and have it become a negative thing... but I'm due in August with #2 and a diaper break would be so nice...
Thanks!
1 mom found this helpful
So What Happened?™
Thank you for all the wonderful advice! IN NO WAY DO I WANT TO RUSH/PRESSURE HER! My daughter is a little bit of an exception as she began talking at 4 months and was up to sentences by 15 months. She goes in phases in and out with it and I just wasn't sure when and how to push. She is really getting fussy about wearing diapers, she does like her verious "panties" and she does show interest. She has had a lot of problems w/ teething and diaper rash which makes the diaper/changin issue worse for her. The poor thing seems to always get multiple teeth at one time.
Perhaps I'll try the bottomless method and the stickers are a great idea too! We'll see how that goes for her. If she's not ready we'll just wait no biggie.
She is my first so I am still learning! Thanks for all the great advice!
God bless and thanks again!
Featured Answers
J.W. answers from Philadelphia on April 12, 2008
She is not ready. Please don't push her on this; it can have far reaching consequences and create problems that would be so much worse than having to simply change another diaper. (Holding, constipation, severe pain, stool softeners, mineral oil! just to name a few) Just leave the potty in the room where she is playing; when she seems like she is wetting, casually ask if she wants to sit on the potty. Don't make a big deal out of it; if she does, and she pees in the potty--applaud and compliment her. Sometimes if you let a child play bare bottomed, it helps her to realize she is wetting and she'll move to the potty--just be prepared to clean up accidents! Some moms will spread a splat mat to play on for easier cleanup. Give her a bit more time though--she's not even two yet.
J.M. answers from Philadelphia on April 12, 2008
I just finish training my 21 month old and it took a while. What I have learned is that she gets lazy when she is in the training pants so I started putting her in underpants. That way she really news when she is wet. The only thing is you have to stay after them. I would take my daughter to the potty everytime I could and if she wanted something I would bribe she and tell her she had to go before she got what she wanted. Yes there will be accidents but if we give them the diaper or training pants back they think its Ok. The last two nights she has been sleeping with training pant and has had no accidents I just take her before bed and if she wakes up in the middle of the night to crawl in my bed I take her again. Then first thing in the morning. It is a slow process but she will get there.
Good luck with baby #2.
More Answers
A.P. answers from Pittsburgh on April 11, 2008
Contrary to popular opinions, potty training should NOT take very long. When it takes longer than 2 weeks, then the child is not ready. Potty training that takes extensive amounts of time isn't good for anyone involved! When you push the issue due to YOUR schedule or agenda, you end up setting the child up for failure because their little brains and their little bladders just aren't ready. I had 2 in diapers for about a year and you survive, believe me! Once you commit to training...put her in undies ONLY (no pull ups) and DON'T look back!!
2 moms found this helpful
L.H. answers from Pittsburgh on April 12, 2008
A wise older woman with six kids told me once that when they are ready to potty train, they will do it. When they're not, it's a waste of time.
Sometimes it seems to be that potty training is a competition among moms to see whose kids get potty trained youngest. It really shouldn't be that way. Another wise older mom told me that often when a child is appearing to be potty trained at a young age, it is really the parents that are trained, they know when their kids need to go and respond quickly.
Sometimes the parent is in denial, like the mom who told me in the church nursery that her son was potty trained. She never sent a change of underclothes and pants for him, but he needed them regularly. He wasn't completely potty trained, and I didn't know his signals. You can't take a kid to the potty every five minutes when you have a room full of other kids to take care of, even with helpers. He needed his own personal helper to make sure he didn't have an accident.
My youngest child potty trained the quickest. All her sisters were in school, and she wanted to go to school also. I told her she could not go to preschool in diapers. She was potty trained way before preschool started. Was she just ready earlier than her sisters, or did she super motivate herself to do it?
The moms here have given good advice. If you have tried all the tips and it's not working, then I'd back off and try again later. I know that it's tough to have two in diapers, well I've been there, and I can relate. But trying when the child isn't ready is not going to work.
1 mom found this helpful
S.C. answers from York on April 12, 2008
Unless your daughter is Extremely Exceptional, it's a little early for potty-training. I believe someone else said that when they're ready it typcially only takes a few weeks, and that's about right. Every child is different, but the norm seems to be somewhere between 2 & 3 years. My son, who has a learning disability, was nearly four before he was fully potty-trained, and even now he occasionally has an accident during the night. (BTW, what usually happens is that he's Exhaused and sleeps really well, only to wake up & discover that he's wet) I try not to fuss over the occasional accident as it IS an accident! When he wakes up & realizes he's wet, he's usually VERY upset & distraught. We simply strip him down & let him get a shower again. (normally showers before bed). With summer coming, it's a great time to do sundresses with whatever type of underwear or training pant underneath. Fewer layers makes it easier to make it to the potty once they're actually at that stage. Good luck & God Bless!
1 mom found this helpful
C.S. answers from Sharon on April 12, 2008
Perk up K.! I have a now 6 year old daughter who I swore would be wearing a diaper at her high school graduation. She, too, was sitting on the potty at about 21-22 months but it was like a phase. She would love to sit and read on the potty and would be excited when she was successful, but it wasn't consistant. I asked my pediatrician what to do after so long of trying unsuccessfully to train her. She suggested a potty "party", which if you have the time is not a bad idea. It will help your daughter recognize when she has to go and hopefully get her to the potty more consistantly. Here is how it works:
Pick a room that has no carpeting...because you may have to clean up a few messes. Put the potty chair in that room and make yourself comfy with books, games, etc. because you will be there awhile. Let her drink as much as she can consume. You want her to have to go often. Don't put a diaper or training pants on her. You want her to know she's going. The first time she doesn't make it to the potty chair, don't scold her, but be supportive and suggest she sit on the potty. You may notice as the day wears on that she will get to the potty a little quicker each time...she may still have accidents, but not as much. Make her feel like it's the coolest thing in the world when she makes it without an accident...do a little dance, sing a song, give hugs...they will love the attention.
Don't be discouraged. She may not respond right away. When all else fails, she may just need time. I know it's inconvenient for you because of #2 coming (I too had to double up on diapers for a short time because I had a 2nd child when my daughter was 33 months), but sometimes they are not ready (or willing) to give up those diapers until they want to. My daughter finally decided to give them up (thank God!), but not until she was 3 years, 5 months old. Best of luck. I hope this helps!
C.H. answers from Allentown on April 11, 2008
would give it a break for a month or 2 and try again but might have to wait till after baby is born. Some kids do tend to regress with new baby around so if it gets close to due date, skip it.
M.M. answers from Harrisburg on April 12, 2008
I had to let my girls run around in a dress with no panties cause if I put something on they assumed it was to pee in. I put them on the pot a half hour after drinking and sometimes I used a squirt bottle with water and squirted her spine.
D.M. answers from Harrisburg on April 13, 2008
Hello, My name is Debbie and I am mother of 2 boys. Ages 6 and 4. My 6 year old was hard to potty train. Like yourself, I bought quite alot of potty training things to help us out. I had a video that I found online, we even purchased Potty Elmo, which i think helped us out. My 4 year old was not hard at all. It was much easier to get him interested. He still likes to sleep in pull ups for that just in case i dont make it, but he always wakes up dry each and every day. It may take some time, i would just try to keep working with her, but dont push the issue.
I also read that you work part time from your home, may i ask what kind of part time work you do? I would love to be able to make some extra cash working at home? Thanks.
Debbie from...Carlisle PA.
K.B. answers from Harrisburg on April 12, 2008
22 months is early to expect a child to potty train. Some have done it, but generally speaking, it's too early. I know you're wanting to have her out of diapers because of a new baby coming, but sometimes you just have to do what you have to do, and have two kids in diapers as many have done before. It's goo that she has pottied before but it's expected that she'd be inconsistent, especially for so long. She's obviously not ready yet. Let her potty at every diaper change. If she goes, great. If she doesn't, that's ok. But do not push her. Night time training comes after day training. Some can train rather fast at night, but most others will take much longer, months. Don't expect too much out of her. She's still a baby. I mean, you're still counting her age in months and not years, so that tells you how young she is.
K. B
mom to 5 including triplets
Email