8 answers

Playdates Turn into Boys Versus Girl

I have regular playdates with several neighbors - they have boys who are 3, 4, and 6, and I have a 5 year old daughter. We enjoy having time to hang out and spend mom time together, but the playdates invariably turn into the boys trying to exclude my daughter - "no girls allowed in here!" My daughter comes and tells us what they said, and then we go and tell the boys that they have to include my daughter. I would love to hear solutions on how to discourage my daughter from tattling, how to teach her how to play with the boys, and how to encourage the boys to include her in their games. Any suggestions would be much appreciated!

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thank you all for your responses. I would like to clarify - we have regular play dates with girls in the neighborhood too. I would love ideas on how to talk to her and other children about issues of some children being excluded - whether for boys versus girls or other reasons. Many thanks!

Featured Answers

Hi P.-

I agree with the other moms regarding trying to find some little girls for her to play with, but in the meantime if you want to continue getting together with this group of children I would suggest you and the other moms try to organize a few more planned activities for the kids rather than just allowing them to go off and play there own games. It's more work for you and the moms, but it might result in more cooperation and fun being had by all of the children. Once they see that they do have fun playing together it might cross over to when they are playing on their own.

Good Luck,
K.

More Answers

I don't have any real suggestions on how to make the boys play well with your daughter; my boys have always played with girls, but the girls were the same age as the boys, so that may be the difference. Maybe at the beginning of the playdate you could have the other mothers talk with the boys about including your daughter for at least a certain amount of time? However, about tattling. . . at our house, the definition of tattling is when you tell a grown-up what a child is doing to get that child in trouble, vs. telling to get someone out of trouble (someone could get hurt, etc.). Hope that helps!

I've read some of these responses and just want to add a little "social-worker-ism" to the subject of tattling. It is always a slippery slope to ask children to stop "tattling". There are so many things that can happend to children that they need to share with mommy and daddy. At such a young age, how is she supposed to decided which are the really important things and which are things that annoy you. I always encourage my children to tell me anything they like. Whether it is petty or not. You can actually use those petty things, like playing well with others, as an opportunity to teach socialization.

I have taken my children over to my girlfriends houses, and there are always age differences, gender differences etc. If you want to continue to be a part of this group, may I suggest that you provide your daughter with something special to do while she is there. Crafts that she can do by herself, interactive DVDs with singing and dancing. Some small portable DVD players can be reasonable. You might even check at a pawn shop or on-line for a refurb one if the retail price is too much. I have even purchased short "books on tape" with a headset and kid friendly cd player. Even if the other children do not join in, she may see the visits are special because she will have special activities reserved for that play-date!

Hey P.,
I know you probably didn't mean to sound this way, but it sounds like you're making her the problem (get her to stop tattling, teach her to play w/ boys). She feels left out! We have similar problems here at that age....but it's not as prevalent a problem, b/c there are girls to play with. I think at this age gender is HUGE, so you might want to seek girl friends for your daughter outside of your street (school). Good luck! I didn't want this to come off that I think you're causing a problem...just wanted you to be aware of what I felt as I was reading your request.

Are there any girls around that can play with your daughter? Instead of trying to get other people's children to play nicely with your daughterl maybe it is time to venture out and find her more thoughtful friends male or female. They are at that age anyway where they want to play with their own gender. They will be interested in each other soon enough and you will wish you had these days back..lol.

Hi P.-

I agree with the other moms regarding trying to find some little girls for her to play with, but in the meantime if you want to continue getting together with this group of children I would suggest you and the other moms try to organize a few more planned activities for the kids rather than just allowing them to go off and play there own games. It's more work for you and the moms, but it might result in more cooperation and fun being had by all of the children. Once they see that they do have fun playing together it might cross over to when they are playing on their own.

Good Luck,
K.

It isn't so much your problem as it is the Moms of the boys. They need to advise the boys, in no uncertain terms, that she is to be included in their games. Invest in some board games that all can play. Little boys usually like to play cars, army or just rough-house that little girls don't care about. How about video's. Get some movies that they all would enjoy watching.

I know what it is like trying to make play dates and enjoying the company of other moms as well. I would also suggest finding other play dates that your daughter would enjoy with other girls. Your daughter may be feeling left out. Are there any girls that you might ask to join this play group? I have 2 girls and they play differently than boys.

I think its great that you would like your daughter to learn how to get along with these boys. I really suggest that you find her a different group or include another girl in the mix for her. This is the age where the kids only want to play with kids there own gender. Good luck.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.