12 answers

Picky Eater....

I am sure this has been asked a lot but I have a 3 1/2 year old that is the pickiest little thing when it comes to food. He won't touch casseroles or anything where the food is combined (unless it is chicken pot pie) He is starting to tire of the rotation of foods that he usually ate without any problems. I need ideas of healthy simple foods that will give my son the nutrients he needs but doesn't have all the pizzaz of a meal. He is no longer eating macaroni, chicken nuggets. He loves eggs so we do a lot of scrambled eggs with wheat toast for dinner. He helps me cook by pouring and mixing but he wants nothing to do with the final product. He wont touch quesodillas, spaghetti, and several other foods. He is growing great 50% all around I just want him to eat more. I am doing instant breakfasts for some extra vitamins and also the juice plus gummies. Ideas would be great on recipes. I do not mind cooking my kids something different if it makes them eat, my husband and I usually have some of what I make for them anyways. Im not creating them some gourmet meals I am just trying to get them to eat and grow. When they get bigger I will opt out to "make them starve til they eat" but right now when the reasoning isn't quite there and you better eat it or you will go to bed hungry just leads to another huge war at bedtime when he cries out he is hungry. I want my little ones to eat even if that means I make them a little something on the side.

What can I do next?

Featured Answers

I agree with the other 2 responses. My kitchen is not a buffet line. You eat what I cook or don't eat at all. I rarely cook just one item, so fine if you don't like salad, but there is meatloaf, peas, corn and rolls to choose from. And I don't allow one person to eat all 8 rolls (I make enough for 2 servings of each item for each person at the table that way if you skip the corn you can have a double portion of peas, but you aren't eating 8 servings of peas and none for anyone else just because you don't want corn, rolls, meatloaf or salad.)My kids are 9 and 10 and they know it's eat or go hungry until the next meal.

1 mom found this helpful

More Answers

I would stop catering to your baby, I know it seems like he won't eat anything but really they will eat what you cook if they are hungry, it is hard in the begining cause it seems like they will starve but they won't, having said that some of this is a phase, and all of mine have gone through it, one thing I do is offer one thing I know they like plus whatever is for dinner, I give them a small amount of all choices first, they almost always eat what they like first then ask for more but here is the trick I use, they can't have more of what they like until they take 2 bites of everything else, at first they throw a fit but I stand firm and give them nothing else, by the second or third day they learn I am not going to back down and will try there other foods, It does work, my kids will eat just about anything know, that doesn't mean there aren't foods they don't like but they do have good eating habits. So just keep offering foods you know he likes but also offer the other foods.

1 mom found this helpful

I agree with the other 2 responses. My kitchen is not a buffet line. You eat what I cook or don't eat at all. I rarely cook just one item, so fine if you don't like salad, but there is meatloaf, peas, corn and rolls to choose from. And I don't allow one person to eat all 8 rolls (I make enough for 2 servings of each item for each person at the table that way if you skip the corn you can have a double portion of peas, but you aren't eating 8 servings of peas and none for anyone else just because you don't want corn, rolls, meatloaf or salad.)My kids are 9 and 10 and they know it's eat or go hungry until the next meal.

1 mom found this helpful

let him help choose the main course or other foods now and then. also, you can try to make healthy pizzas. raw vegis and fruit are good too.

I love the book by Ellyn Sater called Child of Mine: Feeding with Love and Good Sense. She also has a recipe book called Secrets of Feeding a Healthy Family. Give those a try.

If you cook "to order" now, you will be expected to have a menu to please everyone forever! Stick to your guns- you cook one meal- they will eat or go to bed hungry! They will quickly figure out that they will eat or go hungry til the next meal.

A lot of this is a control issue I firmly believe. It is a way of manipulating you to do what he wants you to do.
You have to be the one in charge, not him. He will figure out that he actually does like these foods just fine. If not, he won't let himself starve- he will eat when he gets hungry.
Don't offer a menu, and like the other girl says "My kitchen is not a buffet line- you eat what I cook or you don't eat!"

Sounds like you are doing everything right. A picky eater is normal. I have two cookbooks --- The Sneaky Chef and Deceptively Delicious. I would keep trying different things and make it fun for him. There are two approaches here: (1)Don't make it a control issue and give him choices. (2)You get what you get and don't throw a fit. Find what works for your family. Good luck. I've had the same problems with both sons. When they're young I chose option #1. Once my oldest became school age I started practicing option #2.

I recently asked our Dr about this, because my 2 yr old just doesn't eat. He told me tobuy some vitamins for her so that she is still getting some. My 4 yr old is very picky. So we have resorted to doing what my parents did and what my siblings do. Our dr seemed fine with this approach. I fix one meal. I tellthe kids, "This is your breakfast, luch, dinner. This is what you will eat. You will not get anything else to eat until you eat this or until the next meal." Then I stick to it. They get no snacks, fruit, etc. Until they take at least so 2-4 bites of everything served or until the next meal. Sometimes they do miss a meal, but if and when thy are hungary enough, they will eat it. They usually discover that it tastes good and end up liking it. There are some exceptions. Like when we have peas, the texture makes my kids vomit, they love the taste. They also do not have to eat anything that we won't eat. My siblings kids will eat almost anything now, the started out picky. We are still working on ours. My husband has a hard living by this rule, so I often have to start over. I know it sounds mean and harsh, but they do get the point. Good luck.

Let him get hungry. Kids brains are programed for survival...when they get hungry they will eat whatever you give them.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.