A.V. asks from Rockaway, NJ on December 08, 2008
Overly Needy Infant?
I have a beautiful 4-month old boy and while he is relatively easy to soothe and calm down, he becomes intolerably fussy within 2 minutes of being put down anywhere. I end up playing with him or holding him the entire day which I know they need a lot of at this age, but makes it impossible for me to get dressed or cook a meal without listening to a screaming fit. I hear different things: 1) let him cry it's good for him but only for 15 minutes at a time or 2) don't let them cry, they perceive this as abandonment and retain subconscious memories of negative experiences during infancy. Does it get better? Is this normal? I've tried everything: I bring him into each room with me, I talk to him as I work, I use the infant carrier, I use a mirror, music and toys to keep him entertained. I've tried just 1 toy in case he is overstimulated and at other times, several toys. I've tried the swing, the play mat, vibrating bouncy seat/rocker. Nothing seems to work except my undivided attention. Is he capable of being spoiled already? He is well slept, changed and fed regularly and doesn't seem to be gassy. I'm at my wit's end, especially with the holidays. I can't get a minute's peace to write out a Christmas card let alone decorate or shop . . . He's been screaming constantly as I type this, but will calm down the second I pick him up. HELP!
Featured Answers
J.H. answers from New York on December 09, 2008
My son, now six months, was like that too for a period of time, but he grew out of it. They change so much in the first year, don't worry everything will work out.
1 mom found this helpful
K.L. answers from New York on December 09, 2008
This sounds exactly like my two month old daughter. She was just sound asleep in my arms not two minutes ago and now she is crying as I am writing this to you. I hear the same thing....let her cry, she'll get spoiled if you don't. But after 5-10 minutes, the crying gets to me. She is not the type to cry herself to sleep either. So, for now, I've just been picking her up and doing everything one-handed since I do not have a sling or carrier (back issues.) She'll go on her playmat for 5 minutes but then starts crying. She's not too intersted in Baby Einstein videos yet either. I wish I had some better advice but I just wanted to let you know that you're not alone.
1 mom found this helpful
R.C. answers from New York on December 09, 2008
A.
My son will be 5 months in a week but a few weeks ago i noticed the same thing too. That whenever i put him down he would cry and this past weekend I went to visit a friend and his kids and their nanny was there. The first thing they both said is you hold him way to much... he needs to learn how to play by himself. and then they pointed me to his son who is 2.5 and playing by himself. they said that I have to let him cry a bit so he knows that i'm not giving in and he should be playing by himself for 15-30mins at a time. so since yesterday i put him down on the play mat and let him play and walked away even though he got fussy and kept doing it and this morning he's getting the hang of it...
1 mom found this helpful
More Answers
A.T. answers from Syracuse on December 09, 2008
DO NOT LET HIM CRY! He is not old enough to manipulate you! Something is wrong if he is crying. Babies want to be loved and held. Put him in a front or back carrier like these ladies suggested. BUT DON'T LET HIM CRY! The abandonment thing is all over the internet and books and is very real. I was breastfeeding my daughter and she was very fussy, I couldn't put her down for more than two seconds. I started to rake over my diet and realized that I ate a lot of dairy and cottage cheese. I decided to try to stop eating the cottage cheese. That very day she was a different baby! People had been telling me..."Oh she is so spoiled" "She is ruined" "She manipulates you" and all of this other stuff, well they were completely wrong, she had a stomach ache. Can you imagine how mean and awful that would have been of me to just lay her down and say "oh you manipulative bad baby, I will let you cry!" I am so glad I listened to my own motherly instinct and tried other things first. She is almost two now and very happy and secure. So I don't know if you are breastfeeding or formula feeding, but I would try looking over my diet or changing to a different formula. Take him into the Dr. just to make sure that he doesn't have some problems. Babies don't just cry all of the time for no reason. Babies cry on occasion and that is normal. But don't be a mom that just lets your baby cry without trying to solve the problem first. I promise you, if you give him what he needs now, these are the crucial months of his life and if you are there for him he will grow up to be a lot less needy in the future. He has to know you will meet his needs. You are the only one he has to meet his needs he can't meet his own. He is so young and crying is the only way he can communicate. Don't abandon him. Good Luck!
Angie
3 moms found this helpful
A.P. answers from New York on December 09, 2008
Hi A.. You've gotten quite a mix of advice! I know it's so confusing being a new parent. In my opinion, I would not let him cry. My son was fussy as a baby, and I used to get angry, and even had to stop myself from yelling at him at times, even though he was too little to understand. Just last night, I was crying to my husband, because my son will be two next week, and he has changed so much. He barely needs me at all anymore, and I miss those baby days. As much as I thought it would last forever, and I looked at people like they were nuts when they told me I would miss those days, and that he would be out of those phases before I knew it, I didn't believe them! But they are only little for so long, so hang in there. It will not last. If you want a good book to check out, take a look at the Dr. Sears Baby Book. It's more of a resource guide, not something you have to read cover to cover, but it's a very helpful book, practical and intuitive. Lastly, I'll leave you with the best piece of advice I ever got as a confused new mom. Follow your own instincts. You are the mom, and you know best. If you try or do something and it doesn't feel right to you, change it. Good luck.
2 moms found this helpful
K.K. answers from New York on December 09, 2008
IT IS SOO HARD!! but believe me, it get's better! i was going through the same thing 8 months ago with my little girl. I agree with the "just relax and go with it" approach. My best days were when I just accepted that I wasn't going to get anything done and focused on being with her and enjoying her. He'll only be that little once.
sling, baby bjorn, and a wrap were all helpful.
I can't speak to whether this approach spoils the child, but at one our little girl is fearless, joyful, really outgoing and independent. we think maybe it's because for the first 5 months of her life, she and i were totally attached.
hang in there. this year is rough rough rough but it does get progressively easier. so far at least :)
2 moms found this helpful
R.Y. answers from New York on December 09, 2008
By all means check out the possibilities of what might be upsetting your son (teething, reflux, other diet or digestuon issues, etc.) If it is a digestive kind of think I saw a product that was like a heaing pad that was attached to a knit belt to put against the baby's tummy (I wish I knew the name or where to get it). A soft baby carrier is also great for as much of the time as you can use it. But realistically you probably do have to put him down sometimes to get through the day. I know some people are totally against crying it out. But I think it depends on how it is interpreted. I don't think letting a baby fuss or cry for a few minutes is the end of the world. My son was not a big crier and he almost always settled down in well under 5 minutes of crying unless he really needed something (unexpected diaper change, teething or being sick, etc.) I would probably try getting him used to being near you (like on a play mat or a baby seat) and getting your attention without being in your arms. Maybe if you try it starting a few minutes at a time you can eventually get him to go for longer stretches.
I have read a lot about attachement parenting...and it sounded a lot better before I had children. Even if I agreed with all of it I know myself and I just couldn't do it all. Being a mom is a balancing act and you have to figure out how to get enough of your own needs met to be able to be a good parent for your baby. If you are at your wits end and need to put down the baby in a safe place and take 5 or 10 minutes in another room where you can't hear the crying you are not a bad parent and it is unlikely to cause the baby lasting harm.
2 moms found this helpful
J.B. answers from New York on December 14, 2008
how about taping your voice and some music and seeing if that will soothe the little one...or some of your scent on the bulb in his room...just so he knows you are around. Good luck.
1 mom found this helpful
N.D. answers from New York on December 09, 2008
What a smart little boy. He has trained his mommy already. Let him cry.. where did you get that abandonment thing? When you are doing the dishes or cooking put him in an infant seat on the kitchen table so he can watch you. Of course he will cry at first. It worked so well already. Eventually he will learn that it doesnt work anymore. Keep him in the same room as you, but dont pick him up when he cries. Try to pick him up from his naps BEFORE he cries. When he is in his infant seat and stops crying pick him up for a few minutes once in awhile. Not all the time.
OH you ARE a good mom. TOO GOOD. Babies cry, thats how they communicate, expand their lungs and learn. There is nothing wrong with letting a clean well-fed baby cry.
Check out the post from Regina, where her 20 month cries all the time. Thats what you have to look forward to if you carry your baby around all day.
1 mom found this helpful
J.N. answers from New York on December 09, 2008
A., I agree with all the other postings, let him cry it out a little at a time, but remember babies sense your tension, so try and stay calm when this happens. I had a set of twins and staying calm during their first few months was a huge challenge, but it helped. This only lasts for a couple months! As my mom tells me "This too shall pass"
Good Luck!
1 mom found this helpful
C.M. answers from New York on December 10, 2008
My son was the same way! At 4 months I had to return to work so I looked for a small daycare for infants where the babies were not just in one room all day but rather in the entire apt. When he started to transition by our visiting, he immediately wanted to sit in the exersaucer & floor mat along w/ the other babies his age! It was peer pressure, or socialization needs immediately! Thank God I said- the answer to my prayers, worries & dilemma. He wanted constant or near constant companionship and he wanted to stay in there happily socializing at the age of 4 months.
After that, I was able to have him sit in the floor mat at home as well as the exersaucer and he was more content! If you do not have to bring your child to daycare- GREAT you may want to consider a music class or play class in your area for mommy and me for your babies age range. It really helped my baby begin to appropriately separate from me and not be so clingy all day!
1 mom found this helpful
Email