R.P. asks from Lynn, MA on September 28, 2009
Obamas Plan for Longer School Days
i just read an article that president Obama wants to even out the field of school hours that American children have with other countries. He is saying that academically American children are far behind other countries. so here's my questions :how many of you think this is unfair and how many agree? my personal opinion is this: if the u.s.goverment would put more money into the schools here in America our kids would not be so far behind but they don't. If they trained the teachers better and gave them classes for free to upgrade their teaching skiills are children wouldn't be behind but they don't. but thats just my opinion.
2 moms found this helpful
So What Happened?™
please don't get me wrong i meant no disrespect what so ever to teachers, i think teachers have one of the hardest jobs in America, i guess i just should of used my words better before posting this. I think what the govt needs to do IS pay teachers more, and allow them to go to school for FREE, so they can keep up with all that might have changed, or just for a refresher course(man i hope i'm wording this right) I also agree that schools do need more days in than out, my beef is why did this take so long? but still the govt needs to supply all schools with more money instead of always cutting one program or another like they always do, they need to upgrade US schools period. our children have no text books in many many schools, teachers are coming out of their own pockets to pay for supplies that these schools should already have but they dont, etc etc. but the govt doesnt look at it that way, if they do make school hours longer then they need to first upgrade upgrade upgrade, every school everywhere and pay our teachers more money, and more resources. this is what i should of said first, but i guess im fixing it now
More Answers
J.Z. answers from Boston on September 29, 2009
A longer school day certainly would not be the end of the world! Why is it okay by so many parents to cart their children from one sport or activity to another to the point where they barely have time to grab a quick dinner and do their homework??? But, the mention of extending the school day or year will set so many people off. Some of these kids schedules with after school activities are more jam packed than most busy adults!If you ask me, I would say that as a society we need to recheck our priorities and this is just one of the examples.
3 moms found this helpful
R.K. answers from Boston on September 28, 2009
I couldn't agree w/ the previous poster more. I am lucky enough to stay home but I feel for the parents that don't that have to worry about babysitters and daycares for random days off during the year, half days, long weekends, holidays, vacations and especially summer vacation. I honestly wouldn't see the harm in going to school longer. I know my oldest is often lonely during the summer and can't wait for school to start again.
2 moms found this helpful
L.C. answers from Boston on September 29, 2009
I agree with him wholeheartedly. 5-6 hours of school a day is nothing. What's wrong with 8-10 hours of school? It will leave less time for gangs, drinking, sex, hanging out doing nothing, etc., etc., etc. Three months of school vacation? Why? I know so many parents who scramble in the summertime trying to find affordable and worthwhile care and activities for their children. One month school vacation will keep them busy and give teachers extra money. The children are the future and we need to stop coddling them so much. I can't begin to think of how many latch-key children who will be happy for supervision and company until mom or dad gets home. I'm all for it. I support him.
2 moms found this helpful
C.M. answers from Boston on September 30, 2009
I would like to see a longer school day, especially seeing I am a working parent. A longer school day would mean that instead of my daughter going to daycare, she could stay in school where she would be learning instead. I would also love for them to re-instate gym and the arts back into the daily curriculum. I agree that we are behind other countries in education. Those countries have children learning 5 languauges by the time they are 6 or 8. I also agree that the government needs to provide more funding in education. However, us Americans need to realize that this funding doesn't come from anywhere. Other countries have a more socialistic government where the majority of the money they earn goes back into the government in the form of taxes, thus giving the government the spending power to educate our children better and give universal healthcare. So if we want less taxes, we need to take more personal responsibility on our child's education. If we want more government assistance, we need to pay for it!
2 moms found this helpful
L.B. answers from Boston on September 29, 2009
I was sure I went to school for much longer days than the kids today do. I confirmed this with my mother. I remembered correctly. Our days were much longer. We had homework, but not the excessive amounts that todays kids have. We had things like music, art, physical education - even Home Economics and typing! I think teachers today do not have the time to do what they did past generations.
Another point: We move a lot and my children have experienced many different schools. We were once in a school district that had year round school schedules. This came about because of overcrowding in schools, so the teachers hated it, because they had to move out of the classroom every couple of months. From my perspective, though, it was great! About the time the kids would get burned out in school, they would get a break. They were more than ready to go back to school after a few weeks. They retained more of what they learned and stayed motivated throughout the year. Not the biggest consideration, but an added benefit, is that we could take vacations in the middle of the year, when things weren't so crowded or so hot. My only complaint was that I had three children on three different schedules. This was due to the age difference of my kids. One in elementary school, one in middle school and the other in high school. There was rarely a time when all three were out of school at the same time and often had just one at home. If the three schedules could have coincided, I would have absolutely LOVED the year round school schedule. Even with that - If I were to only factor in the children and not my own needs/wants it was the best thing for them. They thrived in that environment. I suspect teachers would like it as well, if they weren't required to move out of their classrooms every couple of months.
2 moms found this helpful
C.B. answers from Boston on September 28, 2009
I am from the Netherlands and the school year is a lot longer than the 181 days that Massachusetts demands and we still have a pretty long summer vacation. Japan has the longest school year with something like 300 days per year in school. It is no wonder US schools cannot teach kids as much since they only go to school for 181 out of 365 days total. I would hate to have my kids give up summer vacation, but during the school year we have so many vacation days, half days, holidays and 3 week long vacations that it is hard to actually keep a job and take care of your kids. The HUGE 2+ months summer vacation was for kids helping parents with the harvest on a farm. No one I know still lives on a farm but all parents are going broke figuring out how to keep kids supervised while working. I think the school calender needs to change.
2 moms found this helpful
R.B. answers from Lewiston on September 30, 2009
Like one of your other posters, I remember getting on the bus at 6:30 in the morning and not getting home until 4:30 in the afternoon. I checked with my niece and she gets on the bus at 7:45 and comes home at 3:50. What ever happened to quality education and time in the classroom. she has 6 periods in a day and it seems like she really doesn't learn much because when she comes home with homework she doesn't know how to complete it. (btw she's in 5th grade) Her great grandparents who take care of her aren't able to help much because it has been so long since they have used their school skills they are at their wits end often calling in backup from their kids to get her help. I am all for year round school if the schedule is steady. Give the kids 4 semesters with 2 weeks off between each. That is time for a break and time for parents to do all kinds of things especially save money on babysitting. Also a longer day would coincide with the parents schedule and make it safer when kids get off the bus. Just my thoughts though.
2 moms found this helpful
D.N. answers from Boston on September 29, 2009
This will be an interesting discussion,R.! My answer is more than my opinion though, it is based on facts and real experience. (Background: I taught school in the US and in Europe, and later managed a worldwide education business that gave me the opportunity to visit classrooms and meet ministers of education from countries all over the world.)
We already spend more $$ per student than most other western countries, and we are still behind (although not as far as we once were.) Children in most other comparitive nations start school younger, and go to school for a much longer day and school year. Add up those hours of instruction and you can't help but be better educated.
There are good teachers and there are bad teachers; that's true in any profession. But teacher unions prevent weeding out poor performers and rewarding the best performers. So a teacher's pay is based on number of years in the system, not how effective they are. Again, it isn't money, it is management's inability to manage.
So I agree that we should have longer school days and a longer school year. (Homework would probably be somewhat less as a result, because you would have more time to practice in class.)
Some quick data points: a high school grad from Hong Kong or Austria is at least 2 years ahead of the US high school grad. (I have looked at their curricula.) If a European high school teen speaks multiple langauges, it is not because he/she is around people speaking all these languages (contrary to popular opinion) - it's because they start languages at a very young age and take many years of instruction (not the 2-4 years that our kids take.) I know several young adults from Europe who are fluent in at least 3 or 4 languages. They are from remote towns where few people speak English, but they started studying it in the first few years of elementary school, and continued for many years.
Here's my most important observation. I probably shouldn't
have saved it for last since most people won't read this far. :-) The single most important influence on children's academic success is the attitude and support of their parents/guardians: restricting TV time, supporting the teachers and the school, letting your children know how important education is, making sure they devote enough time to homework, making sure school comes before sports or anything else... the list goes on.
My town has one of the best school systems in the state, but not every child who goes through the system ends up with a great education. That's because the opportunity is there, but not every child/family takes advantage of it.
Sorry this was so long. I can get carried away on this subject!
1 mom found this helpful
Email