M.S. asks from Trenton, NJ on November 18, 2006
Nutragemen Formula
Hello. My husband and I are having a big fight over feeding our son. He has colic and I have been breastfeeding him on a regular basis. He has great weight gain and is an eager eater. My husband thinks that this Nutragemen formula will rid the child of his colic b/c he knows of someone whose child has colic and it worked wonders for her.I am not a big fan of formula and have read that breastmilk is best for the baby and it says so right on the formula can. Does anyone have experience with this formula?
Featured Answers
S.P. answers from Hartford on November 21, 2006
I breast fed for the first 3 weeks, but then was in the hospital and we put my son on formula. We used Nutramagen and it worked really well for him. He had colic. I will say though, if it means that much to you to breastfeed then that's what you should do. I have a friend that breastfed and she found that things she ate affected her baby a lot. She had to cut out dairy entirely while she was breastfeeding cause her baby was lactose intolerant. So maybe it is something you are eating. Cut out cheeses and things and see if that works. Good luck.
More Answers
J.B. answers from New York on November 25, 2006
I breastfed both my children, but my second child, my son, seemed to have so many problems that we couldn't pinpoint what the problem really was. It turned out he had colic, acid reflux, and a milk allergy. I stopped breastfeeding, put him on Nutramigen, and he takes Pepcid (rx strength) even now, six months later. The Nutramigen helped, but so did the Pepcid. You may need a combination of things. Is your baby gassy? Does he spit up more than normal? We took our son to a pediatric gastroenterologist. That was very helpful. It didn't cost us anything, and the pediatrician said it is always a good idea, just to make sure there is nothing else going on. Anyway, eight months later, we still use Nutramigen! I wouldn't switch from breastfeeding yet, until you can rule out if something else might be going on. Good luck!
S.P. answers from Hartford on November 21, 2006
I breast fed for the first 3 weeks, but then was in the hospital and we put my son on formula. We used Nutramagen and it worked really well for him. He had colic. I will say though, if it means that much to you to breastfeed then that's what you should do. I have a friend that breastfed and she found that things she ate affected her baby a lot. She had to cut out dairy entirely while she was breastfeeding cause her baby was lactose intolerant. So maybe it is something you are eating. Cut out cheeses and things and see if that works. Good luck.
H.R. answers from New York on November 20, 2006
my breastfed son had colic and that formula did not work. sadely only time really rids colic. i noticed that nursing was the best thing for my colicey little guy. it was the only time he was quiet. he would just sit and nurse/pasify on me and i would get some reading done :)
i deffinitly would not switch from nursing to formula. if your husband is that persistent you should have him talk to your perdiatrition. perhaps he will take it better comming from an mds mouth. I am sure your ped will tell you the same.
I know it really stinks right now and it is stressful but it will pass soon. just keep telling yourself it is almost over.
I really do feel your pain though. Tell your husband that your baby is not going to get the same emotional comfort from the bottle as he is acustomed to the breast. If he is used to the breast he may not even take a bottle or take formula. My daughter and my youngest guy never took pumped breast milk from a bottle. i wouldnt mess with success, i wish i never had with my oldest.
good luck
S.D. answers from Syracuse on November 20, 2006
My daughter was on Nutramigen, at the MD's request, just as a test. It turns out that they think she just had a stomach bug for a week or so. It is easier on their tummy, but if it is colic, Nutramigen might not help. Enfamil does make Gentlease which is supposed to help colic.
C. answers from Hartford on November 20, 2006
Breastmilk is best, even better than the Nutragemen which is very expensive. If your son is that bad, you might want to try giving up dairy yourself. My sister's son was having a tough time and it turned out that he had a dairy intolerence from the dairy he got through her milk. Once she gave up the dairy in her diet, he got a lot better. You should also watch out for foods that make you gassy. Everything will pass through and that could cause some of it too. Good luck. He will outgrow it soon.
J.S. answers from Buffalo on November 20, 2006
My son is on Gentlease which is for extreme fussiness and gas. He had trouble digesting the milk proteins, and this really worked wonders on him. My friend gives her daughter the Nutramigen and it worked very well for her. It will really only cure the colic if it is caused by a cow's milk protein allergy. Check out the Enfamil website for more info-they have a huge list of formulas there. Maybe cut all dairy out of your diet to see if that has an effect on the colic.
M. answers from Philadelphia on November 18, 2006
There is no doubt that breastmilk is the best choice for any baby. However, Formula has come a long way nutritionally since we were babies. I did breastfed my first child and she had reflux. Is your baby arching at all, it could be reflux. You should check with your pediatrician about that. For personal reasons, I decided not to breastfeed my second and third child. My second child was on Alimentum because he could not tolerate any other formula and did not like the Nutrimagen. That is the Similac version of Enfamil's Nutrimagin. My third child is on Nutrimagen now. Both my second and third child had a difficult time with regular, soy, and lactofree formulas. My pediatrician wanted me to wait with my third child and keep giving her the regular formula. I decided to follow my instinct and started the Nutrimagen. Within 2 days the colic was gone. This was after trying Mylicon for gas which didn't help at all and also trying Baby Bliss Gripe Water which actually helped a bit. Nutrimagen and Alimentum are basically the same type of formula. You can sign up for coupons at both websites but Similac seems to send you more coupons at a higher value. Both are considerably more expensive than regular formula. Everyone's experience is different with colic. Sometimes switching to formula works sometimes your baby's digestive system just needs to develop a bit more which can take a few months. Generally babies get over the colic at around 3 months or so. Maybe you can try the bliss water first before you move to formula??? Breast is best and if you're doing well with it you should try and stick with it. http://www.babys-bliss.com/
Good Luck. Remember you and your husband both want the same thing for your baby, COMFORT, so try to compromise! Everything will be okay!
A.O. answers from Hartford on November 20, 2006
its your choice! And breast is best! If it were me i would tell my husband to drink 8 oz of that formula (its absolutely horrid) first! you baby may not even take it. trust me on this one its truely worse than a normal formula! if you husband tries he will surely chang his mind.
Email