18 answers

Non-Hormonal IUD - Garden Grove,CA

Can anyone share their experience with non-hormonal IUD's with me? Did it hurt to have put in or taken out? Were there any side effects? Would you recommend it?

I had my second son almost 5 weeks ago and do not want any more little ones for at least 3-5 years (although we may just stop at 2), so my doctor recommended an IUD and because of some health problems I need to be on non-hormonal birth control.

2 moms found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thanks to everyone who responded! You are all great. I really appreciate all of your stories and experiences (good and bad) with the Copper IUD (non-hormonal IUD). I think I am going to give it a try - I see my doc Friday. Thanks again! ~H.

Featured Answers

Hello! I have had a non-hormonal IUD since I had my second child 5 years ago. I absolutely love everything about it except for one thing - I have VERY long and heavy periods with it. My periods last on average 7-10 days which my doctor said is a side effect of the IUD. Other than that, I don't even know it's there. It was a little uncomfortable getting it inserted, but nothing I couldn't handle. Overall it's great! Hope this helps, and good luck!

Hi H.,
I've loved being on the IUD. I had my first one put in when I was 27 years old after my second and had it for 11 years! (Yes, I went a little over the recommended 10 years - Yikes!) And, I didn't get pregnant. At first, I was scared and actually walked out of the office. I went back and when it was done I said, "That's it?". Take a couple of Advil BEFORE and you should be fine. I just had by 3rd after 12 years and chose to get the IUD. No change. All good. Initial cramping, first couple of periods heavier than usual, then back to light, no cramping, and spontaneous sex! Good luck!

More Answers

Just make sure you balance your zinc levels because copper will deplete the zinc in your body.

I have had a Paraguard IUD for 18 months. I wanted to go non-hormonal, but in retrospect, I should have just gotten the Mirena.

The insertion was not painful at ALL. My OB said that he has inserted well over 1000 now, so he's gotten "good at it". Talking to friends, I think the more experience your OB has, the less pain you feel.

On the other hand... my periods have been EXTREMELY heavy-- much heavier than normal. I thought that would subside in time, but 18 months later, it's still like Niagara Falls for three days each month. I have to change a super tampon every 2 hours. I know not every woman has that experience though.

My advice--try it! Give it 6 months. If you don't like it, you can have it removed at any time.

Hi. I have one too. I had it put in at my six week appt after my last baby. I'm SO glad I was warned that you can feel it for the first few days/maybe a week or two. It's uncomfortable but then you forget about it. My husband, too, complained about the string, but not anymore. Every time I have a cramp or something I blame the IUD, but it's still there and fine. Periods are heavier (two full flood days), but I forgot to contribute it to the IUD. Not any more cramping for me (thank goodness).

Good luck! It's a good choice. On a side note since it was after the baby and six weeks of nothing - I went home and told my husband we'd have to wait another six weeks! We didn't of course, but it was really funny the look on his face. Because of the cramping/uncomfortableness, we only waited a day or two.

Hi H.,
It was interesting reading all these responses. I have had a copper IUD for 33 years! Only way to go! I am currently on the 3rd and last one which is ready to come out. I have probably had this one for 15 years or more, but with all my different doctors blessing over the years. I have it checked annually and up until this last year I had many ultra sounds as the string was always up there. I always checked out good. So, they tell me it's fine and I'm good to go for another year. This year the new doctor said he felt the string and I was shocked. I can't tell you what the other women have about symptoms upon insertion because I can't remeber ever having any. But I do recall having a couple removed and replaced that I likened it to a sting, like falling on a bar of a boys bicycle. I was 22 when I first had mine put in and had not had children. When I met the man who would become my husband he already had 3 childrend so we chose not to have anymore. So I have had it continuiously for the 33 years. Best form of birth control bar none as far as I am concerned. (I always had issues with pills.) It allows you a spontanous sexual freedom not having to worry about stuff you do with other forms of birth control. As with anything, all people are different and their are possible issues like Riley J mentioned but not a high percentage. It's definately worth the try. Go for it. Good luck. C. D.

I had mine for 7 years and loved it to pieces. If we weren't planning on having another little one soon, I'd have another now. I had very little problem with insertion or removal; I found insertion a little bit more painful, but nothing that Advil wouldn't fix. My husband could feel the string, but that only really became an issue on the, uh, more adventurous days. My flow didn't increase, although I was slightly more crampy while I had it. It did take me about 6 months to conceive after having it removed, but my husband and I were also working on a cross-country move so I feel that the stress levels and the very limited amount of time together were the largest factor in that. It was also quite cheap when compared to other forms of BC. Granted that I got mine a decade ago, but without insurance it cost me $350 when it was inserted ($50 for the appointment and $300 for the IUD itself), and there was the cost of the appointment to have it removed, but that was it over the course of seven years. I can't think of anything else that would cost that little, especially anything nearly as reliable.

As I said, if I weren't planning on having another child in the very near future, I would get another one in a heartbeat. It was cheap (when factored over the time I had it in), low side effects, practically unnoticeable when I had it in, no worries about missing a pill or inserting a diaphragm wrong, highly effective, and the best BC I've ever used.

I have the paraguard and I love it. It allows my body to cycle normally, so it doesn't interfere with what my body ought to be doing on its own to keep itself healthy.

After having DD, insertion was a breeze. I expected it to be a lot more painful, but it wasn't. More like one big cramp and that was it. It doesn't have any hormones with it, so none of the nasty side effects from hormonal birth control.

This is my second paraguard IUD, and it continues to be the ideal method of birth control for me.

Hi H.
I have used a non-hormonal IUD for 4 years now and I have had zero complications. The insert was a slight pinch feeling (hard to explain, but didn't bring tears), but I did feel some cramping later at home for about 5 minutes and that was it. As a nurse I have seen some doctors in clinics not take the care in placing the IUD that my OBGYN did and some of the clients were in some pain. Just beware and try to be calm and relaxed about the whole situation. As far as the long term....my periods are very predictable and actually shorter in duration than pre-IUD.
I think the bottom line is that everyone is different and responds differently. Hope this helps

I had one in for 7 years and had no problems. There was a bit of cramping when I first had it put in but nothing advil did not take care of. When I had it removed it was not painful at all and I was pregnant within 6 months of having it removed. Good luck!

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.