19 answers

No Cry Sleep Solution

So I tried the cry-it-out method. It worked.... for a little while. But every time we hit a bump in the road, it's like we have to start all over. It takes too much out of all of us when my 13 month old cries. Sometimes he never let's up after 2 hours (that makes me feel and look like a terrible mom). Ferber seems to be worse. He screams harder after I go in every time. In the past, when he did fall asleep, he would fall asleep standing up and hanging over his crib. I've heard you are not supposed to move them.. so what? They just fall down eventually? :) Doesn't sound very kind to me. He'll aslo cry so hard that he poops his diaper, thus I'm sure it's uncomfortable to fall asleep. He's also thrown up after 45 min of crying. So I'm done with that method. I know a lot of you believe it works, but I think that my son is part of the 10% of babies that it does not work with. So here we go with the No Cry Solution. If anyone who has used it can give some advice or helpful tips, I would be grateful! I'm due in 8 weeks with our second, so hopefully there is enough time to get my 13 month old sleeping. :)

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Thank you!! I have not been able to find any relatives or friends who go against the cry it out method, so it's nice to see that there are a lot of you out there that agree with a solution that seems much more comfortable to me. I've already learned a lot in the one day I've had my question posted. I really appreciate everyone's time to give advice, empathy and encouragement.

Featured Answers

To help my baby go to sleep we would respond immediatey to her cries and not wait for 10 minutes like the Ferber method. But we would not stay in very long and comfort her. We would usually just rub her head, tell her it is going to be all right and then leave immediately. She usually would calm down right when we came in. At first we would have to keep going back in there like 8-10 times a night but now it is only 0-2. It worked for us but I know every baby is different! Good luck-I know how frustrating sleep can be with babies! Hang in there-it'll get better!

when i was pregnant with my third my daughter was still not sleeping through the night, the cry it out method did not work for us either. I knew that i could not get upo with both every night, so my husband stepped in. He took a week and slept in her room, on my oldest twin bed. Every time she sould wake up my husband from his bed would just tell her that she was all right and she would lay back down. It took a week or two but she stared sleeping through the night. I was lucky that my husband took one for the team as you will, cause it made all the difference for us. She now is a peaceful sleeper that goes to bed on her own. Good luck

More Answers

There is the cry it out or not crying it out, not crying means you are going to give him what he wants, to get up and be with you or sleep with you. So you need to decide if that is what you want for him and yourself. Maybe doing the super nanny method with putting a chair in his room, sitting there until he goes to sleep, each night moving it closer to the door. Do not talk to him or pick him up but reassure him you are there. Then eventually just let him be on his own. He knows there is a breaking point, if it is puking, pooping or whatever he will do it to get what he wants. After a year mark he needs to learn to soothe himself so try different methods before bedtime, like maybe one of those voice activated music boxes where if he if fusses or cries it kicks on and slowly winds down in five minutes. Is he doing this when you first put him to bed or in the middle of the night? If it is at bedtime he could be over tired, try putting him to bed before he is really tired as being overly tired can have adverse effects. Try a different routine for bedtime too. Ultimately you will have a newborn soon and your son needs to sleep on his own, even if it means him crying for two hours, he will stop and it will lessen in length....

1 mom found this helpful

I also had a son that would cry and make himself throw-up. And you HAVE to take care of that. Same as pooping. Despite that, persistence with the crying out method really does work. First, make sure his basic needs are being taken care of. Dry diaper. Fed. Warm/cool enough. Medicine for gas/growing pains? Scared? Night light and/or blankie and/or stuffed animal and/or one of your dirty shirts and/or a picture of you to comfort him. Consistent bedtime routine. Give him a snack before bed. Use lavendar in the bath and for lotion. Read him a story. Rock him. Sing him a song and slow dance with him. Play soothing music. Put him to bed. If/when he cries --- let him cry for 5 minutes and return to the room to reassure him without picking him up and touching him. Then leave. Repeat at 10, 15, 20, 25, and 30 minutes. He'll probably be sleeping by then. But, if he's not sleeping after 30 minutes, pick him up to console him. After he's settled down again, start all over. This is not something that can be fixed overnight. It could take days/weeks. I don't know who told you you can't move a sleeping baby. I think you can --- just be careful not to wake him up. And when you hit a bump in the road, yes, you have to start all over. You need to take care of this because you've got a second one on the way. Also, enlist your husband's help. You guys need to be a team. Plus, make sure you've got your baby active during the day so he is exhausted at night. And make sure he's getting nap(s) during the day. The problem may be he is overtired. You are not a terrible mom. You are teaching him independence. No one likes to hear their baby cry. But he (and you) will survive. Good luck.

1 mom found this helpful

I was in the exact same boat as you are 3 years ago, and my son was the same age when I started it! I think you definitely have enough time with 8 weeks. The book saved my life, I didn't know how to strike the right balance between cry and no-cry, and I couldn't stand to hear my baby cry. The main thing to remember with this method is patience. If you stick with it and are consistent, it will work. And it will work sort of "all at once" and you'll be surprised at how "easy" it is once it's over. Keep track of the awakenings just like the book says, and just take teeny-tiny baby steps each night. Some nights you won't make any progress, and other nights will be small miracles. I was also nursing at this time, so that made it even tougher, but every night I just unlatched a little sooner, even if it was one or two seconds. Then the next step was to get him to stay in his bed and cry for a few seconds more each night (I could never let him cry more than a minute or two--it just was not going to work for me!). Then all of a sudden, he just stopped waking and crying. So definitely give it a try, I think the book is wonderful, even though I don't agree with all of her ideas, it definitely worked for me with the night awakenings. Good luck!!

Hello N.,

I don't believe in letting a child 'cry it out' I think it breeds insecurity and makes the little one feel abandoned. I'm not one to hold a child in my arms until they fall asleep either... what worked for us, and I mean REALLY worked for us is a method suggestion by an English Nurse and author ,Tracy Hogg. She's written a book titled the "Secrets of the Baby Whisperer" She saved my life! Our son was had severe GER for almost 12 months, so sleeping was hard for the little guy (and us) He never slept during the day, so once we got him down at night, we wanted to keep him that way. Buy the book, borrow the book...and fast. Good luck

when i was pregnant with my third my daughter was still not sleeping through the night, the cry it out method did not work for us either. I knew that i could not get upo with both every night, so my husband stepped in. He took a week and slept in her room, on my oldest twin bed. Every time she sould wake up my husband from his bed would just tell her that she was all right and she would lay back down. It took a week or two but she stared sleeping through the night. I was lucky that my husband took one for the team as you will, cause it made all the difference for us. She now is a peaceful sleeper that goes to bed on her own. Good luck

To help my baby go to sleep we would respond immediatey to her cries and not wait for 10 minutes like the Ferber method. But we would not stay in very long and comfort her. We would usually just rub her head, tell her it is going to be all right and then leave immediately. She usually would calm down right when we came in. At first we would have to keep going back in there like 8-10 times a night but now it is only 0-2. It worked for us but I know every baby is different! Good luck-I know how frustrating sleep can be with babies! Hang in there-it'll get better!

There is a great book out there called the Baby Whisperer. She is definitely full of practical advice about sleep difficulties and is not an advocate of the "cry it out" method. She has consulted families on child rearing for many years, and has great results with her methods. I have never had the slightest interest in letting my children cry it out. I sure don't want to be left alone screaming in the dark when I'm scared and need comfort, so I can't imagine leaving my baby to suffer through that. I understand sleep deprivation, and it is very difficult, but this book helped a lot, and it was worth the ability to serve and bond with my children(3).

God Bless you,

Hi N.,
You are on the right track. I have never been a believer in the cry-it-out method. The key to any method is consistancy and patience. This will take weeks (could be many weeks) but it will be so worth it for you and your son if you can stick with it long enough to get him in a good pattern.
Good luck to you. Take care,
B.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.