This is what I did one year for my husband, I wrote a poem about our first date, and how I had butterflies in my stomach and our wedding day and having those same butterflies. I typed it up on the computer and printed it off on a really pretty, yet manly piece of paper and framed it. Don't forget to put the date so he will have it forever and he'll remember when he received it. I actually a 5 x 7 frame so it's not too big, or too small. This is a perfect yet inexpensive gift and it's very personal and meaningful. It also brings back those wonderful memmories for both of you.
I hope this helped. Good Luck.