42 answers

Need to Budget!

Hi there. I'm looking for some advise for a family budget. My husband and I both work and more than anything I want to be a stay at home mom. For years I have been asking my husband to sit down with me so we can create a family budget and a financial plan. He refuses. He says we are doing just fine. We do not have tons of debt, but we also don't have much in savings. Our savings contributions and my 401K contributions are sporatiic and small. We are not rolling in money and we would REALLY have to cut back for me to stay at home. How do I get him to agree to budget with me? I asked if he would like to go to a financial seminar (Crown Ministries) and he flat out refused. I said he was being lazy and he agreed. Basically, it would be hard and he DOES NOT want to do it. He thinks we can not afford to contribute to savings every pay check and I think we can't afford not to. Plus, I will NEVER get to quit working if we continue down this path. He just does not get it that you have to create a plan of attack if you want to get ahead. How do I convince him we will be so much better off if we just sit down and do it!

PS Plus we do not have wills or gardians for our children. Another "nagging" thing I ask him about.

2 moms found this helpful

What can I do next?

So What Happened?™

Wow, thank you for the overwhelming response! I have been looking in the Dave Ramsey website and will find a class. I even think my hubby might come with me!

Featured Answers

This is a GREAT budgeting program. http://www.mvelopes.com/
Once I just had to do it myself, and then the husband thought it was great.

1 mom found this helpful

I would say that you should just go ahead and make the budget. Show him that it is feasible for you to be a SAHM and what it will require. Sounds like if this is something you really want you're going to have to do the majority of the work. It'll be a good intro into the SAHM world ;)

If you want a savings you have to do it. If you want anything done, you need to do it. It will not get done if you are waiting for him to do it. My husband is the same way.
C. B

More Answers

First, I want to thank you for asking this question! The responses are fabulous and I have some great new ideas! But, I also want to share what I've used and works for me so far. First, I read "Smart Women Finish Rich" by David Bach. It was so fabulous and easy, I paid of over $30K in credit card debt BY MYSELF before I was married, then bought a house MYSELF. Then I read all of his other books as they came out. FABULOUS for educating me on financial things about which I had no idea! I even have a solid grasp on investing in real estate now and my husband and I just bought our fourth investment house.
As for family budgeting (which as VERY TRICKY for me when I decided to quit my job), I found www.YNAB.com. YNAB stands for You Need A Budget and is super simple to use. The concept is to get your debt paid off and live on LAST MONTH'S income so that you'll always have plenty to pay the bills. I love it. I actually found it when I was deciding whether quicken was right for me (it wasn't).
There's my two cents worth! Let us know how it goes! :)

2 moms found this helpful

I put this guy's widget on my google homepage:
http://www.iwillteachyoutoberich.com/blog/toc/

he has some good articles that you might like. If you set that as your homepage...or google as your homepage with his widget on it, maybe your husband would keep seeing it and get interested.

1 mom found this helpful

Dear M.,

This is a source of contention in most homes. Don't be afraid to budget your own money if you have too! My husband really got on the Dave Ramsey "band wagon" a few years back. It took me a while to join him, but since then we've had fewer money fights, and we're debt free and saving up to buy our own home again. (renting is best for our situation right now, but we are antsy to get into a home before the economy really comes crashing down!!) Savings and over-spending/debt are the biggies in what caused this most recent economic problem. We paid off $30k in debts to be debt free three years ago and we've never been happier about a choice we've made as a couple. As far as a budget goes those are the MOST difficult things to do, but Dave's budgets make great sense and cover basically everything, and even give you room to screw up, blow money on stupid things, and still get it all taken care of. I highly suggest his ENTIRE collection of books and cd's!!

And your first budget is never going to be perfect!! Like Dave says, "You'll call several emergency budget meetings in the first month to make it work."

hope that helps!

V.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi M.,

Wow, you've got a ton of responces! My husband and I did a Financial Peace University class by Dave Ramsey. It was awesome!! To find a class in your area go to www.daveramsey.com and click on the Finacial Peace University option from the list on the left. Then you can put in your zip code. You could just get the book but I think the class setting is the way to go! We got way more out of it doing it that way than just reading a book. It forces you to do your homework and the two of you to talk about everything! The course covers everything to do with finances and spending/earning money! Wills, insurance, budgets, college, mortgages, getting out of debt, retirement...! It has truly been a blessing in our lives!!! I've recommeded it to many of my friends and family! I've even given the book as a wedding present several times!! Sounds like a lame gift but I wish someone had done that for us!!! God bless!!

1 mom found this helpful

This is a GREAT budgeting program. http://www.mvelopes.com/
Once I just had to do it myself, and then the husband thought it was great.

1 mom found this helpful

Hi M.,

As much as I like Crown Ministries, a lot of men relate to Dave Ramsey better! DaveRamsey.com has great resources that you can buy and use at home. It really did change our finances to the point that we no longer fight about money. We bought Financial Peace University about 4 1/2 years ago and have shared it many times. Our two oldest know how to and desire to stay out of debt as a lifestyle. They also have children's programs that are really neat and helpful.

If you were to buy the book on tape, or check it out from the library, Total Money Makeover and ask your husband if he'd be willing to listen to it - if you ask you'll get a lot further than demanding - he may just change his mind. Or listen to it at strategic times when your husband is around to catch his ear. Ramsey is practical, entertaining, biblical and in your face all at the same time! His program is fun to go through yet still teaches you a great deal. His dvds are of a live seminar that he gives.

Understand all of us have a spender and a saver to differing degrees. Your husband's reaction is actually very normal. He'll need to be wooed in and think this is all his idea! Our husbands have a need to lead so appeal to that side of him. Best of luck to you!

Hi M., how are you?? I hope that I am not getting to you a little bit too late but I am a financial advisor and my market is the middle class Americans that most people are taking advantage of or are ignoring. I think that the best way to be able to sit down with your husband is to get him involved in your finances. The best way is to have a casual conversation about your future. What do you really WANT for you as a couple and for your children. Have you talked about their collage expenses?? What about your retirement?? Talk about paying yourself first so that you can do things that you both enjoy. I do not know if you have watched the movie call "The Secret"?? Find this movie and watch it together. Also, I do not know if you know Suzie Orman, she is one of the financial gurus in the country and she featured on Oprah show so many time and she has a new book out called "2009 Action Plan" it cost $9.99 you can get it anywhere like amazone.com or Barnes and noble. You can buy a book or a CD version. Have him read the books and just have a conversation about your future and what you would like to accomplish. Better yet have him come to our financial seminar that happend every Tuesday nights from 7:30 to 8:30 PM at 1773 Millennium Way, Meridian ID 83642. Ask for Y. and I will make sure that you find a comfortable sitting. I hope I am able to help.

Well, this isn't the best solution, but its what I had to do. 1. go on a long drive. he is stuck in the car and has to talk to you
2. bring up what would happen if you or he dies. scary, crappy but it has to be done
3. id he still won't work with you....
I made of our guardianship and will for my husband and myself and just marked where he had to sign. He might take more of an interest if he sees something already done. Does it sole the problem of him being lazy, no, but your kids are protected. Once you fill out the paperwork make sure to send copies to the people involved and make sure one is somewhere safe, but accessible.
Don't forget to make a durable power of attorney. If you and your kids are in an accident and you can't speak for them who will?
Good on you for being proactive.

Required Fields

Our records show that we already have a Mamapedia or Mamasource account created for you under the email address you entered.

Please enter your Mamapedia or Mamasource password to continue signing in.

Required Fields

, you’re almost done...

Since this is the first time you are logging in to Mamapedia with Facebook Connect, please provide the following information so you can participate in the Mamapedia community.

As a member, you’ll receive optional email newsletters and community updates sent to you from Mamapedia, and your email address will never be shared with third parties.

By clicking "Continue to Mamapedia", I agree to the Mamapedia Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.